That sounded like heaven. But there was still something nagging at her. And then it hit her, along with a zing of excitement. “I’ll meet you at the truck. Go ahead, I’ll just be a second. I have to talk to my mom.”
He shrugged and did what she said, zipping up his coat, then heading for the road. She did the same, but she veered off toward the far side of the house instead. After stepping carefully through snow-covered perennial beds, she tapped on her mother’s window, which was covered by a Venetian blind.
“Mom? Can you hear me?”
A long moment later, her mother peered from between two of the aluminum slats. Then she opened them all the way, and cracked open the window.
“I’ll be quick, Mom, so you don’t freeze in there. In the woods that day, with Aunt Dorothy. Did she give you the tape Ollie made? That’s why she wanted to meet, isn’t it? She wanted to go to the spot where it all happened.”
She watched the tension drain from her mother’s body as she gave in to the inevitable, and nodded.
“Please. Will you give it to me?”
37
“I don’t know, maybe the school?” Fergus frowned at the ancient tape resting in Marigold’s palm. How the hell were they supposed to play it? “They might have a player.”
“Let me text Grady.” Marigold tapped on her phone. “No,” she said a moment later. “Mom said that old Fisher-Price player is broken. I’d suggest the historical society but their office is only open in the summer. But I can text the new head.”
She fired off another message.
Fergus grumbled out loud. “The first actual solid piece of evidence, and it’s so outdated we can’t even listen to it.”
Marigold looked up from her phone and clapped her hands. “We can! She’s going to drop a cassette player off at the Lightkeeper reception desk later tonight.”
They shared a high-five. “To the Lightkeeper, then?”
“Yes, please! That bathtub is calling my name.”
But the bed called her name even louder, and the moment they stepped inside his room she crashed out. Fergus made sure she was covered up snugly with the extra blanket in the closet, and took his phone into the bathroom to check in again with Stephanie.
“Listen, Fergus,” she said urgently. “I have a name for you. Elliot Fineman. We’ve been monitoring the water taxis services, and one of them reported transporting a lone male of about the right age yesterday. He said the man wasn’t an islander, but that he’d seen him at the Lightkeeper dock before.”
“Do you know where he’s staying?”
“I checked with the Lightkeeper Inn, and he’s not registered there. But that’s no guarantee of anything. I don’t want you to let Marigold Olson out of your sight. Watch your back. We’re sending reinforcements. Me and a couple of agents are heading up from Boston.”
Fergus automatically wanted to object, since more agents would blow his cover completely. But it was probably for the best considering the unpredictability of the situation. “Got it. See you soon.”
He hung up, splashed some water on his face, then went back to the bedroom.
The bed was empty.
Panic lanced through him. The Water Killer. Perry. Elliot. On the island. Marigold.
He thrust his feet back into his boots, grabbed his coat, and yanked open the door. Only to stop dead at the sight of a smiling Marigold holding up a tape player.
“The reception desk just called me. It’s here!”
Her strawberry blond hair was a silky tangle, and her shirt was half untucked from her nap, but she was the most beautiful thing he’d ever seen. He gathered her into his arms and nearly cried with relief.
“Don’t do that again,” he growled. “Not until we catch this guy.”
After a quick moment, she got it, and hugged him back. “I’m sorry. I called to you that I was headed down, but you must not have heard.”
He hauled in a deep breath, pulled her inside, and closed the door behind her. His heart was still racing. “Stephanie called. She said Perry Atwell might be here under the name Elliot Fineman.”
“Oh wow. Okay.” She sat back on the bed with a plop. “I didn’t notice any other guests on my way up or down the stairs.”