Page 84 of Light It Up

Page List

Font Size:

“He’s not registered here, but we need to be doubly careful just in case.”

She nodded gravely. With the cassette player perched on her lap, she looked like a sexy grad student, and he wanted nothing more than to get into the bed and get naked again. Not just for the sex; she’d be safe under those covers with him. This intense protectiveness was hard to juggle.

“How about we give this player a spin?” she said, pulling the old cassette tape out of the pocket of her hoodie.

“Let’s do it.” He shoved aside a pile of papers to make space for the player. They each took a seat, almost ceremoniously. The moment felt so significant. Were they about to hear a voice from the grave? A thirty-year-old incident caught on tape?

She slid the cassette into its slot. They shared a sober glance, then he tilted his head her way, offering her the honor of pressing the play button.

At first, they heard only static. Then some rustling.

“I think it’s in a backpack,” whispered Marigold.

He squinted, trying to picture it, and found the idea plausible. Ollie could have brought the pack into the woods with him. Then came a surprised, “You!” in a young, high voice.

“Is that the girl?” Marigold asked. Fergus jotted down a note. The missing girl was still one of the big holes in this case. They hadn’t found any trace of her. He’d done a cursory check of missing persons and sexual assault reports from nearby islands, but nothing had lined up.

Then came some unidentifiable sounds. Then a lower voice, that of an older boy, but still young, spoke. “Stop fighting me. I know you want this. Ow!”

More rough sounds, and some grunts and groans. The girl cried, “Stop! Please! You don’t understand!”

Then… ”What the fuck? Are you a⁠—“

And then a sickening crunch, the sound of a fist slamming into flesh and bone, over and over, and then a bone chilling howl of pain and fury.

“Forget it, just go,” cried another voice, this one also older. “Run!” After that came rustling leaves and footsteps. Panting breaths.

“That sounds like someone running,” Marigold murmured. “With the recorder.”

But someone was chasing. Fast footfalls and angry shouts. After a short time, those sounds receded, and then a door slammed shut.

And there, the tape ended.

Marigold sat wide-eyed, staring at the recorder. “That’s it?”

They played the tape again. And again.

“No one ever identifies themself.” Fergus hit his fist again the table in frustration. “This is worthless to us. Fuck.”

They played it again. “Maybe we could run a voice print on it? Can a fifteen-year-old be ID’d thirty years later?”

“It’s technically possible, but very unreliable. I doubt any court would admit it. Anyway, there’s no way to know what happened from what’s on this tape.”

Marigold slumped back in her chair and ran her fingers through her hair. “Goddamn it. I really got my hopes up. I figured it must be a bombshell if Aunt Dorothy kept it so long, and it was in Dennis Murphy’s will.”

Although he felt just as deflated, he kept that to himself. “It’s progress. Maybe there’s something we’re missing.”

Marigold nodded, a bit disconsolately, then let out a huge yawn.

“Bath? Bed?” he offered. “Food?”

“All of the above. And more.” She gave him a naughty little wink. “Bathtub first? Is it big enough for two?”

“People our size? Not if we want any water in it. How about you get in the bath and I’ll be the hairiest spa attendant you ever had.“

“Can’t turn down that offer.”

38


Novels you may like ...