Shadows emerged from the darkness as my eyes slowly adjusted. Random pieces of furniture that had been left behind after Brandon’s brother had either sold or donated what he could—a hard-backed chair against the wall, a coffee table in the middle of the room, a stool at the kitchen counter—creating the skeleton of a house.
Even breathing into my arm, there was something off about the smell. Everything in this house reeked of wrong.
I used the light on my phone to guide the way, looking for any signs of an intruder here. But the silence and the stillness had their own presence.
I passed the kitchen window that I’d once thrown open in a panic. I kept the light pointed down so no one would see me in here.
Next, the garage door, where Chase had yelled for me to hit the automated opener—the responding mechanical hum painfully slow in the chaos—while Charlotte had run for the living room windows, throwing open the back door, too.
I followed the hallway, swooping my light up to the ceiling, to that small, discolored circle where the carbon monoxide detector had once been. The stairs to the right, where I’d followed Chase.
I’d found him at the foot of their bed. I’d never forget the look on his face. Sometimes I couldn’t look at Chase without picturing them, too. I couldn’t imagine why anyone would want to break in here now. Especially Ruby.
At the end of the hall, the scent suddenly changed. It became something beachy, more fragrant. A scent to mask another smell. The closer I moved to the front of the house, the more the scent grew.
The Truetts had converted the formal dining room at the front of the house into Fiona’s office, with French doors. One of those doors was ajar, and the source of the smell revealed itself: a blue candle in the middle of the wood floor, currently extinguished but burned all the way down to the melted wax. The label declared itOcean Breeze.
I approached it slowly, this single sign of life in an otherwise barren house. The office was empty except for a stand-alone desk shoved against the far wall, and I didn’t want to use my flashlight in here—too visible, with the uncovered windows, from the front sidewalk.
I almost didn’t see it in the shadows: the heap of fabric in the back corner under the desk, stuffed against the wall.
Keeping my light off, I got down on my knees, inching closer, hand extended toward the fabric. A rustle of material, the shape of something rolled up—
A sleeping bag that had been tucked into the corner space.
Like someone was squatting in here. I’d heard of this problem in other abandoned places, people breaking in and taking up residence. But not here. Not in this neighborhood. Not with everyone so close to others who would notice people coming and going, who would hear something in the night.
I slid the sleeping bag my way, and a small black notebook dislodged from where it had been balanced within. I took thenotebook and backed out of the room to where I could use my flashlight without fear of being seen.
A pencil marked a page in the middle like a bookmark. Opening to the marked spot, I recognized the handwriting immediately. Knew for certain who had broken in and who had been staying here.
This belonged to Ruby.
At the top of the page was a date. The day before the party. The day before she died: July 3. Her notes seemed to be written in a complex system I couldn’t quite work out. Letters and arrows, dates and times.
I flipped to the front page to see if I could make sense of it. In faint print, she’d written a series of numbers on the inside cover: 62819
6-28-19.
The date of her release.
I turned the page, and a square of folded paper slipped out.
I unfolded it to reveal an old computer printout. Like something from our message board.
But it wasn’t recent. I recognized it from long ago. This was a screenshot of our message board from the early days of the investigation:
HOLLOW’S EDGE COMMUNITY PAGE
Subject:CHECK YOUR CAMERAS
Posted: 4:48 p.m.
Chase Colby:You all saw the video from the Seavers—looks like Ruby, but it’s not a clear shot with her hood pulled up. What we need is footage between midnight and 2 a.m. We need to track Ruby, and it has to be airtight. Check yourdoorbell cameras, any security footage, anything that picks up noise… let me know what you’ve got.
Margo Wellman:What if we find something else?
Chase Colby:Don’t.