Page 33 of Fragments of the Lost
Now, the photos take his spot on the bed. The only thing out on the surface of my dresser is the broken dragonfly necklace, not put away, not replaced on a new chain, just waiting there, as if I’m not sure what to do with it. All it does now is remind me. He’s everywhere now. Even here.
I sort through the photos, pulling out the shot of us at the Delaware Water Gap.
I lean closer to the photo of us at the waterfall, Caleb staring back, his eyes locking on mine through the lens and time. I turn on my computer, to try to map it exactly, remembering where we were, the details from the sign. I check the photo to see if there are any mile markers, something that might map to our final location. I look at various images from other people’s hikes at the Delaware Water Gap, trying to find an exact match.
There’s something similar in several of the photos, but nothing that captures this exact perspective. There will never be another shot like this—the two of us on the rock, an arc of water in the background, our faces frozen in place and time, a feeling I can remember just from my expression alone.
There’s a knock on the door downstairs, and I shut my laptop and stack the photos, sliding them into my top drawer. I check my phone for messages, thinking Hailey would’ve texted first. But there’s nothing. The bell rings as I walk down the steps, and it echoes, sets my nerves on edge.
The lights are on in the foyer downstairs, and my car’s in the driveway, so I can’t pretend I’m not home. I check the front window and see a car I don’t recognize. The bell rings again. I peer through the peephole, and it’s Terrance Bilson, my brother’s ex-teammate, current alumnus, previous giver-of-questionable-look at the coach’s meeting.
My shoulders relax as I pull the door open. “He left already,” I say. “Sorry.”
But Terrance doesn’t move. He peers over my shoulder into the empty spaces, the darkened rooms. “I didn’t have your number, or I would’ve called first.” He angles his foot across the threshold, and I tighten my grip on the door. “I wanted to talk to you,” he says.
I don’t open the door any wider, because I don’t really know Terrance all that well, other than the fact that he played baseball with Julian and Max.
He must sense this fact, because he steps back. “Will you come out for a minute?”
It’s cold, and the neighbors are home, and his car is in the street, and anyone can see. “No, it’s okay. Come on in.”
Terrance looks around briefly, lingering near the entrance. He doesn’t speak, doesn’t really seem to know how to start.
“So, what are we talking about?” I ask. I remember the look he gave me Saturday night, and it puts me on the defensive.
He blinks, his gaze shifting back to me, as if remembering. “Caleb.”
My jaw tenses, the word echoing in the foyer with the too-high ceilings, and I know my body language must give me away.
“I saw him, in September,” Terrance continues, and then I understand. I remember.
“The college visit. Was that with you?”
He nods. “It was supposed to be. He showed up, but then he disappeared.”
“What do you mean, he disappeared?”
“Just that. He checked in, but I didn’t see him again until he was leaving. He came back Sunday afternoon for his luggage. He had a bag from the school store in his hand, and he looked like crap. He apologized, and left, and I never saw him again.” His voice trails off, because his words have an unintended finality. I wonder if everyone has their own story for the last time they saw him. A story they each tell anytime the name comes up, becoming more embellished over time.
Caleb’s phone had gone to voicemail during that trip. We had fought about it after. All I had to go on was my imagination then, and now Terrance is here, making those images even more real.
“Why are you telling me this now?”
“Because I think it’s a dick move, what they’re saying.”
I almost sayWhat are they saying?just to watch him squirm, but that would be a dick move too, so I don’t.
What they’re saying:He came to see her, and she sent him away at the race. He looked angry. She sent him away, he was upset, and he crashed. He drowned.
It’s the precipitating event. There’s no logic to it, but it’s the simplest explanation. All I’d said was,Please hold this for me. Please be careful.But it was too far for anyone to hear, so the words become anything, become everything.
What they believe: Caleb had come to ask for my forgiveness (one rumor), or to try again (another rumor), or to confess he was still in love with me (uncorroborated, but a nice sentiment), and I’d said no. Something I did caused him to leave angry, and he wasn’t paying close enough attention, and then he died. Cause. Effect.
“I mean, he wasn’t this perfect guy,” Terrance continues, filling the silence. “It’s not your fault, right?”
“I never sent him away,” I say. I hadn’t told anyone this before—first, because I was in shock, then because I wondered if it was true, and now because it didn’t matter anymore what I said: it was too late. But something about Terrance in my foyer, a stranger giving me secrets—I was a sucker for them. “I asked him to hold my necklace. He disappeared. That was it. He didn’t say anything. I don’t know why he left. I don’t know where he was going.” It was another student and a parent who gave that account—who both said they saw him standing in the crowd after, that he looked upset. With nothing else to go on, the story filled in around it.
Terrance nods, unsure what to do with the information, whether to believe me or not—then seems to decide on something. “Okay, there’s one more thing.”
