“You got here fast,” I say as I open the door, then slide into the passenger seat.
“I was in the neighborhood.”
I pull the door closed and look over at him. “I bet you were.”
He holds my gaze for a few seconds, then backs out of the parking spot.
“You know, I appreciate you letting me borrow this car,” I say, glancing over at him, “but I don’t appreciate having it dangled over my head like this. If I have to worry about you taking it away anytime I displease you, then it doesn’t really feel like I can depend on it.”
He doesn’t look at me, but he does respond. “I didn’t take the car away because you displeased me.”
“Then why?”
“I wanted to see who you’d call.”
His words stop my heart and send it tumbling down into my stomach. He says it so calmly, so evenly, like it’s a perfectly normal thing to say.
He looks over at me, and his eyes glint with something I can’t quite put my finger on. “You called the right person. You don’t have to worry about me taking the car from you again.”
My mouth works, but I can’t even find any words.
He turns left out of the parking lot, but it makes more sense to go right. He points suddenly to the dark, empty parking lot of a dentist’s office right next to where I work, behind a row of hedges that need trimming. “I was parked there waiting for you. I wouldn’t leave you stranded alone in the dark.”
That doesn’t make me feel better.
Staring at him, I finally find my voice, but I continue to struggle with my words. “What—Why…?”
He takes a sharp right down a side street, since we need to get back on the road that will take us to the lake house. “Why what?” he asks, flicking a glance in my direction.
I don’t even know.
Why was he waiting to see what I would do?
What if I had called someone else?
Why is he telling me he did it?
It seems like most people doing something creepy would try to hide it and not blatantly tell on themselves. And I know Tor well enough at this point to know he thinks things through, so it’s not some thoughtless mistake. He wants me to know… what?
Licking my lips, I try to find the right question, but my mind is all over the place. “Why would you tell me that?”
His answer is simple, but my mind is too muddled to take it at face value. “I’m not trying to trick you, Cassie. I want you to have the information you need to succeed.”
“What does that mean?”
“You’re a smart girl,” he says. “You’ll figure it out.”
I don’t feel like a smart girl right now.
I still have questions about his motives, but I can’t untangle them, let alone put them into words, so I stay quiet for the rest of the ride. Yet my mind continues to work, replaying snippets from earlier… Tor at the restaurant while I was working.
The way he looked at Josh.
That has to be what he means, right?
It feels arrogant to think so, but at the same time, I remember how uneasy I felt, my instinct to keep them separated and not even let Josh talk to Tor. I didn’t want to look too hard at why it made me so uncomfortable in the moment, but now that he’s said what he just said, facing it feels pertinent, no matter how uncomfortable it makes me.
Tor killed my ex-boyfriend, and he framed it as a matter of practicality, but I don’t know if even a slight sense of twisted jealousy contributed to his willingness to do it. I don’t know if Tor is a jealous guy. Based on what I do know, I’m uncomfortable with the idea that he might feel threatened.