Bobbie threw up her hands. “What we know about dating apps could fit in a thimble.”
“Luckily, we have Charlie. Even if he’s not using them, he’ll know what they’re called.”
Charlie knew the names of several apps, but when he told Nora she’d have to sign up for an account to use them, she paled.
“Can I use a fake name?”
Charlie’s fingers flew over his phone keyboard. “On Tinder, yeah. But that’s just one app. According to Reddit, most people create a unique username for each app. It’s totally common for people to use fake names, fake profile pics, and post all kinds of lies about their jobs, hobbies, and marital status.”
“I am never signing up for online dating,” vowed Bobbie.
Unwilling to dive into the daunting world of dating apps, the two women returned to the dossiers. They’d read and reread every file by the time Sheldon and the rest of the Secret, Book, and Scone Society arrived at five. After asking Charlie to man the checkout counter until six, Nora told her friends to gather in the Readers’ Circle.
The only two customers in the store were Charlie’s classmates. They’d spent nearly an hour in the YA section before carrying their books to the front. Nora heard an occasional giggle from the girls, followed by Charlie’s low, rumbling laugh. Knowing the trio might chat until closing, Nora addressed her friends in a hushed voice.
First, she caught them up on what McCabe had told her about Bo Marks.
“He was going bankrupt. He knew people in the art world. He owned a rifle. According to a former employee, Bo used to throw hunting parties at a luxury cabin he once owned. Grant texted me right before you all got here. Bo’s phone records revealed that he’s been communicating with someone using a burner phone since May. The calls increased in number in September. On Jess’s wedding day, there was one incoming call from the unknown number and two outgoing calls. All the calls occurred while Jess was at the church.”
“Clarke has a clear view of Jess’s house. Maybe he called his accomplice to tell them the coast was clear,” said Hester.
Sheldon tugged on his mustache. “Anyone in the church could’ve sent a text saying the same thing. Except me. I was too busy promising Jess that everything was going to be okay.”
June rubbed his back in sympathy while keeping her gaze leveled on Nora. “Tell us what’s in these files.”
“Info on all the members of the Blind Date Book Club. Background checks, employment history, social media presence, financial summaries—you name it. The only thing that’s missing is phone records. I guess money can’t buy everything.”
Pointing at the files, Estella said, “I bet Rupert has those and more. He’s not about to share information he obtained illegally.”
“Good point,” conceded Nora. “Okay, friends. Bobbie and I will handle the setup for tonight’s meeting, while the rest of you focus on the files.”
Everyone looked at Sheldon, as if seeking permission. He reached for Clarke’s folder and gently placed it on his lap. “We don’t have much time. My book club peeps will be here in two hours. I need to know what questions to ask tonight. I’ll do all the asking. You ladies listen to the answers.”
Ten minutes later the teenage girls left the store. Nora told Charlie to lock the front door.
“I’ll work on our Instagram feed from home,” he said as he flipped the sign in the window from OPEN to CLOSED. “I took a bunch of pics of the quilt, so I’ll post about the silent auction. The latest bid is three hundred bucks, by the way. I’m also going to make a reel of the two table displays Sheldon made. I love the one with all the faces.”
“Me too,” said Nora.
After Charlie left, she stood next to the table, gazing down at the book covers and thinking of all the faces a person wore over the course of a single day.
She thought of the people in Sheldon’s book club, and of the facts Rupert and his team had gathered about each member. They’d uncovered all kinds of details, but not every secret could be found online. Some were buried deep inside a person’s heart. And some faces were hidden behind well-worn masks.
“I’m heading out too,” Bobbie said, breaking into Nora’s musings. “I’m cooking dinner for Jess tonight. Nothing fancy. Just pasta and veggies. I know part of her wants to be with her book club friends, but I don’t think she’ll come back until Ravi’s murder is solved.”
After Bobbie departed, Nora began arranging the food. As she worked, she wondered if Jess would ever return to Miracle Books. After all, one of her friends had betrayed her, and that betrayal had led to the death of the man she loved.
Nora and Estella were lining up bottles of wine in the ticket agent’s booth when June poked her head around the corner. “I’ve read every file, and I think Rupert’s people overlooked something that might be important. I think we need to know why certain members of the book club moved to Miracle Springs.”
Hester’s face appeared in the pass-through window. “Which ones are you talking about?”
“Jess, Ravi, Bella, Isaac, and Clarke are relative newcomers to the area compared to everyone else. Maybe one of these people relocated for the sole purpose of cozying up to Jess. Join her book club, become her friend—or boyfriend—and gain her trust. I mean, the girl is worth millions.”
Estella quirked a brow and turned to Sheldon, who was hovering in the doorway to the ticket agent’s booth. “Did she and Ravi have a prenup?”
Sheldon shook his head. “Rupert told me that Jess had a postnup drawn up, which Ravi agreed to sign. She told him about her inheritance the night they got engaged. To her relief, his behavior didn’t change at all. He’d make jokes about her buying him extravagant things, but it was silly stuff, like a rocket ship or the Mona Lisa. She truly believes he kept her secret too.”
“I could not keep that secret from you guys!” said Hester.