He reached for his nightstand, rifling through until he pulled out a condom. He ripped it with his teeth and smoothed the rubber over his length.
Despite the recent pleasure, I felt empty. I needed him inside me. I reached for his forearms, urging him to move faster.
He positioned himself between my legs and nudged my entrance with the tip. My eyelids fluttered closed at his touch. And when he slipped inside, I sighed. It was like coming home again. Everything was familiar yet different.
Cal was bigger and more skilled, yet the same man inside. He was the same guy I'd fallen in love with. It would be so easy to fall again, but I had to be careful.
This wasn't a trip down memory lane. It was a moment of pleasure. A confirmation that things were the same between us physically. But you needed much more than chemistry to forge a relationship.
We weren't there, and we probably wouldn't ever be. In the meantime, I'd enjoy this moment. This coming together after years apart. I was feeling a lot because it was Cal. This was to be expected. It wasn't a rekindling of our relationship.
"Look at me," he growled, and my eyes flew open.
His expression was intense as he moved over me, slipping deeper inside me. Why did it feel so much bigger than just this moment? Emotion swelled in my chest, ballooning to the point that I was afraid I might explode.
He braced his hands on either side of me as he moved his hips, hitting me deep.
I held onto his forearms as if he could ground me in this moment. Maybe we were both worried about the other not being present.
"You feel so good."
I couldn't answer because a lump formed in my throat. If I thought I could have one night with Cal without emotional consequences, I was sorely mistaken.
Neither of us could believe we were in this position. But the possible outcomes weren't enough to get us to stop and pull back. We were in this together.
16
Callum
I wouldn't let her avoid the reality of this moment. I'd invited her to leave with me, and she'd come willingly. We both knew what we were doing.
There was no avoiding it now. I was prepared to deal with whatever happened next. Seeing her naked again—the changes that came with womanhood, the added curves—only made me want her more.
She was different yet the same. She was the same scared girl inside but a confident woman on the outside. We'd both gone through things but made it back to each other. It was too soon to think that this could be anything more.
Somehow, everything felt heightened, and maybe it was related to our history or the fact that we were doing something that we probably shouldn't. There was a surreal quality to it. As if I wasn't really here.
Being inside of her again was hard to describe. I dropped my mouth to hers, kissing her while I moved, and she whimpered.
I wanted to make this good for her and draw out a second orgasm for her, but I was already overwhelmed. I was going to lose control if I wasn't careful.
Her hands moved from my forearms, running down my back. The scrape of her nails only heightened my desire.
I whispered things to her. "I can't believe you're here with me. You're so beautiful." I couldn't even find the words to describe how I was feeling, but I hoped she got the idea. What we had was special. I just hoped that she could see that too.
I was barreling closer to that edge where I wouldn't be able to hold back. I lifted myself slightly so that I could reach between us and press her clit.
She cried out my name, and that was all it took for me to let go too. Her walls clamped around my dick, and I was lost.
I lowered myself to her side and kept an arm around her. I wasn't going to let her go. I wanted her to stay the night.
If she went home, she'd talk herself out of this, and I didn't want that.
She rested her hand over my arm. "That was intense."
I rolled so that I was on my back, staring at the ceiling. "It was always more between us."
She didn't respond, and I wondered if she didn't want to acknowledge that. There was always the possibility that she'd been with someone else who'd been the love of her life. But for me, it had always been her. No one else had compared.