He shook his head, pulling out a toothpick and balancing it between his teeth. "When Amanda left, you stopped by to see how we were doing. It was like you were holding out hope that she'd come home, and when she didn't, I thought you'd finally moved on. But now that she's here, I'm starting to think that those feelings never went away."
"I visited you and your family because I cared about how you were doing. Just because Amanda left didn't mean I stopped caring," I said, avoiding the other thing that he was referencing, the fact that I still had feelings for Amanda. I wasn't sure how I felt about that.
"Yeah, but it's more than that. You were hoping she'd come back. Whether you'd admit that to yourself or not. And now she's here."
"She is here, but that doesn't mean anything will happen between us," I insisted stubbornly, knowing that he wasn't convinced.
He squared his shoulders. "What's holding you back?"
I chuckled without any humor. "Her home is in Boston."
"People move all the time."
"You and I both know that won't happen." They’d resigned themselves to having a daughter living in Boston a long time ago.
"I have, but her mother seems to think she will eventually decide the city isn't for her. That this place is in her blood. She knows Amanda better than I do. By the time I came along, Amanda was already so responsible. Colette said Amanda held them both together over the years. Amanda had to grow up quickly. No matter how many times I tried to tell her that she didn't have to play that role anymore, she never stopped. She was her mother's protector, and when I came along, it destroyed her purpose. I'm afraid I'm the reason she left." His last statement was said softly, as if he was afraid to say it too loud. I had a feeling he'd never mentioned it to anyone before.
"You can't blame yourself," I said, even as I'd done the same thing over the years. "It was her choice. Whatever her reasons."
"You have to admit that the outcome might have been different if I hadn't come into the picture. She would have stayed to protect her mother."
"You know, you could think of it another way. You became her mother's protector, and Amanda was finally free to pursue what she wanted."
Dale let out a long breath and touched my arm. "You're a good man. She'd be an idiot to walk away from you a second time."
"I don't know if I want to give her that chance." It was easier to keep my distance. So why had I offered to bring her to the pumpkin festival?
"I hope you think about what it will feel like to let her go without telling her how you feel." With that cryptic comment, he joined his wife and his daughters.
They stood together in line, their little circle expanding to include Dale. From an outsider's perspective, it looked like Amanda fit in just fine. But I could see how she would feel differently. And maybe I should have said something to Dale. But he seemed to have a pretty good idea of the situation. He knew that he'd taken Amanda's position in the family, but he'd hoped that it would allow her to be the kid she was supposed to be.
It didn't quite work out that way. But in the end, she was able to lead the life she wanted. And who was I to say that she shouldn't continue doing that?
The more time I spent with her, the more conflicted I felt.
Amanda looked at me and waved me over. They were inching toward the front of the line, and I was confident she wanted to make sure that I got whatever it was I wanted to eat. But I saw it as her way of including me in their family dynamic. Maybe I helped her not feel like a fifth wheel.
We ordered hot dogs and sodas, then sat on a nearby bench and ate them.
The girls faces were covered in ketchup, and Dale leaned over with a napkin to scrub it off. He was a good dad. Better than the one Amanda was dealt. It was too bad she never viewed Dale as a father figure. She'd played the role of little adult for so long that she couldn't fall back into the kid role just because she was given permission.
Maybe mistakes were made back then. Dale and Colette didn't know how to deal with the dynamic, and Amanda wasn't forthcoming with her feelings. But that didn't mean that things couldn't change now.
How amazing would it be if Amanda could see that change was possible? That she could forge a new relationship with her family now that she was an adult. But she would have to see that for herself.
Dale had acted like a father figure when he questioned my motives. And I respected him for that. He'd come into a difficult situation and tried to be the man her mother and Amanda deserved. Amanda rebuffed those advances, but she might see now that her relationship with them could be different. And maybe better than she ever imagined.
I thought I knew where her head was at, but I was usually wrong. I thought I understood her, but I obviously didn't.
After eating our hot dogs, the girls insisted on grabbing a slice of pumpkin pie, so we moved to the pie tent.
Afterward, we perused the various vendors that were selling fall items: scarecrow signs for the front yard, jewelry, candles, cider, baked goods, and flowers.
When we passed the flower table, I recognized Jovie, the girl that frequently worked with Hattie in her hot chocolate truck. She lived on a farm next to ours that was owned by her grandparents.
Her jars were filled with sunflowers today, and I couldn't resist stopping to buy a bundle for Amanda.
Jovie wrapped the stems together and said, "Get them in water as soon as you can."