She turned it over one more time and found what was ugly underneath, as she always did if she stood still long enough.
She wanted it to be him. Not for Dana Kelsey and not for the case. She wanted it because eleven pieces of an unnamed person had come up out of the harbor on Monday morning and her first thought had not been who is that. Her first thought had been let it be mine. Somebody's son, brother, or father had spent eight months in nineteen feet of moving sand and Isla had stood over him on a spoil deck and hoped he was a monster, because that would be more convenient for her sleep.
She put her palm flat on the cold glass and left it there until it hurt.
The phone lit up on the counter.
SULLIVAN: Emma got the truck into second twice. Also, I ate the other half of your roll, it's been in my coat since 8am, no regrets.
Then, thirty seconds later, because he never did leave it there:
SULLIVAN: You good?
Isla looked at it for a while. Out past the piers the air had gone colder than the water again, and it was starting — the first white ropes of it lifting off the black, unhurried, thickening as they rose.
I'm fine, she wrote.
It was almost true, and she sent it anyway, and then she went and checked the deadbolt.
CHAPTER ELEVEN
The trouble with the water was that it kept wanting to be pretty.
Reid Calloway had been standing in front of it for eleven minutes without touching it, which was the most useful work he'd done all week. Nine feet by five, stretched over bars he'd milled himself in September because nobody in this town sold pine that straight anymore. The commission had come out of Cleveland — a shipping company that wanted its lobby to feel like the inland seas and had been talked, over four months and a great deal of email, out of a sunset.
What they were getting instead was the harbor in March. Rotten ice going out through the entry in plates, the color of a nickel and the color of a dirty sheet, and above it a sky doing almost nothing at all. He had killed the far shore twice. The second time he'd taken it back to canvas with a blade and stood there sweating in a fifty-degree room.
Now it sat.
He didn't allow himself the word often, because the word was a trap and he'd watched better painters than him get caught in it. But it was there in his chest anyway, low down, as it had been three or four times in twenty-two years: this is the best you have ever done.
Not finished. One more session — the near plates on the right, where the light came up under the ice and he'd gotten it eighty percent and then, sensibly, stopped. You didn't finish a painting at eleven at night in your own light. You came back at nine in the morning with coffee and a stranger's eyes and you either fixed it in forty minutes, or you learned something about yourself.
"Tomorrow," he told it.
The studio was the second bay of a marine repair shop off Garfield that hadn't repaired anything since 2011, and it held cold as a thermos holds coffee, which was to say better than you wanted. His heater burned its one red bar by the drafting stool. The radio was on low — the AM out of Superior, a man reading grain prices to nobody. Through the high windows there was black, and past the black, four hundred yards of slip, and the deck lights of a laker laid up for the season.
He'd been careful about the news all week. He hadn't known Dana Kelsey well — a panel once, a group show in 2019, a woman who'd said something kind about a small painting of his and then said it again a year later, which meant she'd meant it. He'd made himself stop reading on Wednesday.
Reid took the brushes to the sink.
That part he did identically every night and had since a teacher in Milwaukee had put a hand on his shoulder and told him a man's brushes outlast his opinions. Murphy's oil soap. Palm of the hand, work it into the heel, rinse until the water ran clean and then twice more. Shape the tip with two fingers. Fourteen of them, and they went back into the coffee can handles down, bristles up, standing in a row like people waiting for something.
He wiped the palette. He set the knife on the taboret with the blade turned in.
Behind him the bay door rolled, one foot, on its bad wheel.
He heard it and he did not hurry, because the door did that in a north wind and had done it all autumn, and because a man alone at night builds a small warm shed of ordinary explanations and lives inside it. He dried his hands on the rag hanging out of his apron pocket. He reached over and turned the radio down out of politeness to nobody.
Cold came across the floor and touched his ankles.
"Hello?" Reid said.
He got as far as turning his head.
CHAPTER TWELVE
The weather had turned in the night and turned the wrong way, which in November on this lake meant warm.