I don’t have much time to ponder that question because the bell rings a moment later. When I pull open the door, I smile because no matter how rude he was when I came over to his house, I believe in greeting guests with warmth and politeness.
“Hi,” I say, gesturing for him to step inside. “Hope you didn’t have any trouble finding the place.” The lame joke slips out before I think better of it, and I internally cringe until I see his mouth twitch. Not quite a grin, but it loosens the knot in my stomach.
He stops a few steps into the living room and looks around. His eyes sweep the room, taking in my large Christmas tree in the corner with hundreds of lights and ornaments hanging from almost every single branch, the holiday throw pillows on the couch, and the porcelain Christmas village on the sideboard near the wall. His eyebrows twitch downward and his jaw tightens, but he doesn’t say a word.
I’m already irritated with him. What’s so bad about decorating your home for Christmas? It brings me joy to walk into this room every day and see these things, so why does he have to be such a grump about it? Even if I do give him points for keeping his opinion to himself.
“Would you like some coffee?” I ask, gesturing for him to take a seat on the couch.
“That’d be great. Thanks.”
I’ve already brewed a pot, and I pour some into two snowman-shaped coffee mugs before placing them on a matching serving tray with sugar and cream—plain and peppermint-flavored. When I return to the living room, he’s sitting on the couch, his eyes on the stack of papers I’ve left out on the coffee table.
“Those are my students’ writing assignments,” I say as I place the tray on the table beside the papers. “I teach fourth grade, and they had to write a persuasive essay about what kind of toy they think a toy company should make to sell at Christmastime.”
“And how did they do?” he asks, sounding like he’s actually interested in the answer.
I take a seat beside him on the couch, then grab my coffee cup and add a heaping scoop of sugar. “Some did better than others, but I think they all enjoyed coming up with their own ideas.”
I almost tell him that my students usually love this time of year because of all the Christmas-themed assignments, but I hold myself back. No need to start a debate about the holiday this early in the conversation when I know it’s likely to lead to another disagreement.
“And what do you do for a living?” I ask, taking a sip of my coffee.
“I play football. I’m the new left tackle for the Charleston Wranglers.”
“That’s great. Congratulations.” I’m impressed.
He grins. “Thanks. Are you a football fan?”
“My dad is but I have to admit that growing up, I was more into reading than sports.” I blush at the admission.
“That’s okay. I forgive you,” he says, and winks in a way that sends shivers down my spine.
There’s peace between us, flirtation even, so I don’t add that I’m clueless about whether a left tackle is a defensive or offensive position. But I have to admit that the idea of him running the field or tackling another player makes my pulse quicken. He’s so big and muscular that I can easily picture him crashing into another player, taking someone down with his strength. That physical dominance speaks to a primal part of me, a part that wonders what it would be like to have all that firm muscle pressed up against me.
My pulse races at the idea. I bet he looks amazing in the uniform …
“Are you okay?” he asks.
I blink back to reality and meet his gaze. A tremor of awareness rushes through me, and I wonder how I can be aroused by and attracted to a man who is the complete opposite of me. Who outwardly hates the very things that I love. But when he’s relaxed like he is now, he’s likeable. It doesn’t hurt that he smells delicious, a combination of smoke, wood, and cedar.
He’s staring at me and I realize he’s waiting for an answer.
I clear my throat. “Yes, I’m fine.”
His eyes narrow, flickering over my face like he’s gauging if I’m being honest.
“Do you want to talk about the toy drive?” I ask, changing the subject.
“Sure.” He adjusts his position, coffee in hand, and his shoulder brushes mine. A slight touch but I’m ultra-aware of him. “I assume you have a plan in mind?” he asks.
I laugh. “What makes you think that?”
He shrugs his big shoulders. “I don’t know. You just strike me as the organized type. A woman with a plan and all that.”
He’s not wrong.
“You’re right. I do have a plan.” He’s lucky I haven’t had time to outline it or take out my iPad and walk him through it. “Well, to start with, my family started a charity that helps low-income families, so we’re going to partner with them. That will ensure that the gifts we collect go to those who really need them. We want to make their Christmas special.” My voice softens because this is my favorite part of the holiday. “Some of them wouldn’t even have Christmas without our help.”