Theo thanked her three times. She told him she expected both of us at her Christmas cookie exchange in December, and that she’d be bringing General Sherman by next week because the cat missed the house.
“The cat broke in,” Theo said. “That’s not the same as missing the house.”
“He missed the house,” Mrs. Pruitt said firmly.
Then the door closed, and I heard Theo put the casserole in the fridge and come back upstairs. He stood in the doorway with the hall light behind him, holding two bottles of water and looking like a man who’d survived an interrogation.
“She says you’re a good man,” he reported. “She also says you need a haircut, and that General Sherman has visitation rights.”
“Mrs. Pruitt thinks everyone needs a haircut.”
“She also told me she’s taking full credit for us getting together, and that anyone who disagrees can take it up with her.”
“Nobody’s going to disagree with her,” I assured him. “They’re all too afraid of her, even Gray.”
Before he got back into bed, Theo set the water down, dug through the pocket of his jeans, and came up with a worn index card.
“I found this in Constance’s recipe box the week I started cleaning out the dining room,” he said. “I’ve been carrying it around ever since, which is probably weird.”
I recognized the handwriting before I read the words. Triple batch for the boys at the station. Wade likes the ones that come out a little burnt.
For a second I couldn’t say anything at all. Constance had brought those cookies to the station every Christmas for as long as I’d worked there, and I’d never once told her the burnt ones were my favorite. She’d just noticed, the same way she noticed everything about everybody, and she’d written it down so she wouldn’t forget.
“She would have liked you,” I said, once I trusted myself to talk. “I told you that once, but I never told you how much I miss her.”
“Tell me about her sometime,” Theo said. “I want to know the parts nobody’s told me yet.”
Theo set the card on the nightstand, then climbed back into bed, pulling the blanket over both of us. I pulled him against me, his back to my front, and slung my arm over his waist. The house creaked around us the way old houses do at night, and somewhere inside the walls ran the new copper wiring that Gray had pulled through every room. It was good wiring, and it would hold.
Epilogue - Theo
Two months later…
The Countdown to Christmas Festival opened on the first Saturday of December.
I stood in the town square watching the crew string lights on the big tree, with a cup of Jess’s peppermint mocha in one hand and Wade’s glove in the other. He’d left it on the kitchen counter that morning, and I’d grabbed it on my way out without thinking. I did that with his things all the time now, and he did the same with mine.
That would have terrified me when I first came to town. Now it felt as ordinary as locking the front door. Not that anyone locked their door in Clover Ridge.
Our clothes hung side by side now in the closet of the newly updated master bedroom, and the kitchen counter held both of our coffee makers, because neither of us had been willing to give up our own. Our toothbrushes were still sharing the same cup, the rest of our toiletries organized on the shelf nearby.
We were still making the house our own. Constance’s wallpaper was gone from the master bedroom, replaced by a soft blue paint Gray had helped me pick out and put on the walls. Wade and I purchased a new bed with a heavy wooden frame and a king-sized mattress, then went back to get nightstands that matched it.
About once a month we double dated with Gray and Adrian, switching off houses and cooking responsibilities. The hosts cooked and the visitors brought beer and dessert. The four of us got along great.
I’d taken a remote marketing contract with the agency’s Seattle office, because my would-be boss had answered my email declining the job by asking whether I’d consider working on contract instead. It paid less than the assistant director job would have, and it came with no fancy office, no badge photo, and no team dinners on a schedule someone else set.
What it came with instead was double date nights, Thursday trivia, and weekend mornings on the porch with Wade, drinking coffee while Deb watered her garden next door and shouted unsolicited advice over the fence about my flower beds. A few of my bulbs had come up in November, which Deb said meant I’d planted them too shallow. She was right. I’d looked it up.
I cared about things like bulbs now, and I still couldn’t get over it.
My mother had taken the news better than I’d expected. When I called to tell her I wouldn’t need a moving truck after all, because I was unpacking instead of packing, she was quiet for so long that I thought the call had dropped. Then she said she was glad somebody had finally gotten me to settle down, and that she and my dad were coming out for Christmas to meet the man who’d done it.
Our first public outing as a couple who was actually staying had been the Fall Bonfire, two nights after Wade showed up at my door with Jess’s coffee cup. We didn’t make any announcements, and we didn’t need to, because Wade’s truck had been in my driveway every night, the For Sale sign was gone from the yard, and everyone in town could do the math. Half the town came over to shake Wade’s hand like he’d won something.
Now the holidays were coming, and the town was holding another one of its ubiquitous festivals. Jess appeared at my elbow with a cup of coffee I hadn’t asked for.
“You look happy,” she said. “It’s a good look on you. You were way too stressed when you first moved here, always looking for an escape route.”