Frank held up both hands. “All right. I’m just checking.”
He went back to his report, and I went back to mine, but I couldn’t concentrate. My mind kept going back to the look on Theo’s face when Frank said the house was ready to list. I thought about the flat way he’d said “great news,” and the way he’d left without touching me or making a joke, when Theo always had a joke.
I kept running the conversation back, trying to find the moment it had turned, and I kept landing on my own smart-ass line about wasted trips and wondering what that had sounded like from the doorway.
I got to Theo’s house a little after six. He was in the kitchen making pasta with garlic and butter, and he kissed me when I came through the door, long enough that I relaxed for a second.
We ate. He asked about my day, and I told him about Nate’s hose drill, and he laughed in all the right places.
Everything was fine, but fine was new for us. Before tonight we’d been easy and funny together, two people who fell into conversation without even thinking about it. Tonight he seemed like he was working at it. I could hear it in the little pauses before he answered me, and I could see it in the way he kept glancing at his phone on the counter and then looking away.
He was performing the evening instead of living it, and he was good enough at it that anyone who didn’t know him would have believed it.
But I knew him.
“How was your call with your new boss?” I asked, because it seemed like the place to start.
Several emotions flashed across his face so quickly I couldn’t interpret them.
“It was fine. It was just scheduling stuff for the new job, talking about paperwork and briefing me on projects.”
“When do they need you in Seattle?”
“We’re still negotiating.” He said it quickly, to the window over the sink instead of to me. Theo was a terrible liar.
I didn’t push, even though I probably should have. Pushing meant hearing the answer, and I wasn’t sure I could handle it.
After dinner, we sat on the porch. My kind-of boyfriend leaned against me, and I put my arm around him, exhaling when he relaxed against my side. At the edge of the porch light I could make out the flower bed he’d started along the front walk, a row of dark dirt where he’d planted bulbs that wouldn’t come up until spring.
I wondered if he’d be here to see them.
“The garden’s coming along,” I said.
“I have no idea what I planted. I bought whatever Deb told me to buy at the nursery.”
“It looks good.”
“I didn’t really know her, but Aunt Constance would have had opinions.” He smiled, and for a second the evening felt easy again. “Deb told me that she would have told me exactly how she wanted everything planted and why, and insisted on fixing it herself if I did it wrong.”
“That sounds about right.”
“I keep finding out things about her,” Theo said. “Every time I talk to Deb or Gray or Mrs. Pruitt, I learn another piece of who she was.”
“Does that bother you?”
“I like learning about her,” he confirmed. “She seems like a cool old lady, and I’m sorry I didn’t get to know her before she passed. To me she was just a distant relative that I exchanged Christmas cards with, but to her I was someone worthy of leaving her house to. I don’t understand it, to be honest, but I don’t take her gift lightly either.”
He went quiet for a few minutes. “Wade?”
“Yeah?”
He paused, and I could feel him deciding whether to say something by the way his breathing changed against my side.
“Nothing,” he said. “Never mind.”
I kissed the top of his head. We sat there until it got cold enough to see our breath, and then we went inside. He didn’t ask me to stay over like he usually did, and I tried not to read too much into that. I had an early shift, so I made myself go before I could do something stupid, like beg him to ask me to stay or ask him to marry me.
Theo walked me to the door and kissed me goodnight, and his hand rested on my chest for a second before he pulled it back slowly, like he was trying to memorize the feel of me.