When I came back, Theo was standing in the kitchen doorway, barefoot and shirtless, his hair going in four directions at once.
“So that’s a regular occurrence?” he asked. “Cats breaking into people’s houses?”
“Just that cat. Just this neighborhood. Mrs. Pruitt’s had him for years. Constance used to leave a dish of food for him here in the kitchen.”
“She left food out for a cat that broke into her house?”
“She liked the company,” I explained. “Plus it kept him from trying to eat whatever food she happened to have on the counter.”
Theo leaned against the counter and looked at me with a soft look. The kitchen was warm and quiet, the candle on the table burned down to a stub. Any other time I would have remembered that it was a bad idea to leave candles unattended, especially in a house that was still getting its wiring fixed. But at that moment I was standing in the middle of the kitchen without any of the armor I usually wore, grinning at Theo like an idiot. I couldn’t put on my armor, not after what happened between us tonight.
“Stay over tonight,” he said.
“I have a shift at six in the morning,” I said regretfully. I didn’t want to leave any more than he wanted me to.
“I’ll set an alarm and make you coffee in the morning.”
“Theo.”
“Stay, Wade. You just took my clothes off and made me forget my own name. The least you can do is be here when I remember it.”
I stayed. Of course I stayed. I knew I was getting in too deep with Theo, but I couldn’t seem to help it. We went back upstairs, and he fell asleep with his head on my chest and his hand on my ribs, and I lay awake listening to him breathe and thinking about how long it had been since I’d let someone fall asleep on me.
Allan had been the last. When he left, I’d put that part of myself away the same way I’d put away his things, boxed up and pushed to the back of the closet, dealt with by not being seen again.
Theo was nothing like Allan. My ex had been cautious and quiet, a man who chose his words carefully and always was examining the angles in any conversation. In contrast, Theo talked fast and with an open manner, his mouth sometimes working faster than his brain. He said what he meant, and when he didn’t, it was so obvious that it might as well have been the truth anyway.
When the alarm on my phone went off at five, Theo groaned into my chest and informed me that firefighters were a menace to society. I lay there a minute longer than I should have with my hand spread on his back, and then I kissed his hair and got up. He immediately fell back asleep, hugging the pillow and forgetting all about his vow to make me coffee. I didn’t mind though. I could stop at Bean There, Drank That on the way into work, and besides, he looked so adorable sleeping I’d hate to wake him anyway.
On the drive into work, I caught myself smiling. I was still smiling when I walked into the fire station, which Frank noticed the second I walked in.
“You’re in a good mood,” he said mildly.
“A guy can be in a good mood,” I said, heading for my desk.
He followed me of course.
“Rumor has it that your truck was parked at Theo’s house all night.”
That was the problem with living in a nosy small town like Clover Ridge, nothing was secret.
“I cannot confirm or deny that rumor,” I said.
“You don’t have to,” he laughed. “One of the neighbors posted a picture of it on the town’s Facebook page.”
I groaned. “I’m going across the street for coffee.”
“When Jess is done grilling you about last night, tell her I said hi.”
Theo
Wade left a little after five, pressing a kiss on my cheek. I’d meant to get up and say goodbye, but instead I fell right back asleep. When I finally rolled out of bed a few hours later, I did something I hadn’t done since I arrived in Clover Ridge, which was absolutely nothing. I made coffee, sat on the porch, and ignored my phone, wanting to sit with the memories of the night before.
Having Wade spend the night was nice, more than nice. Sleeping with him pressed into my back, with one thick arm around my waist, had made me feel safe and cherished. Everything about the night had been better than the weeks I’d spent imagining being with him.
The fact that I’d had the best sex of my life with him didn’t hurt either.
I drank my coffee and stared out into the yard daydreaming, which was not like me at all. My mind was filled with images of turning this house into a home, of staying in Clover Ridge and waking up with Wade every morning for the rest of my life. And that scared me in a way I didn’t know how to joke about yet.