“Oh my god,” he says suddenly, a surprised look coming over his face.
“… what?”
“You were jealous,” he breathes, like he’s just had an epiphany.
“Um, when?” I ask, knowing there could be lots of times to choose from.
“About Caitlin and the dance,” he says. “When she asked me, that’s what that was. That dripping, oozing stuff in my chest.”
“Ew, what?” I laugh. “Is that what jealousy feels like?” I love hearing Caleb describe emotions. He’s gotten more and more comfortable explaining his ability to me, and I could listen to him talk about it for hours.
“That’s what it felt like then,” he says. “It’s different now, when you get jealous. Like with Damien—when you were confused about why I wanted him to like me.”
“To be fair, I was confused for a lot of reasons,” I say. But I want to hear more. “Why was it different?”
“I think because we’re together now?” Caleb tilts his head like he’s tuning in to the radio of my emotions. “Like, it’s less pointed than it was with Caitlin. God”—he shakes his head and smiles—“there were so many things about you that I just didn’t get for the longest time.”
“But you get them now?” I ask.
“Yeah, I’m starting to.” He smiles.
“You know,” I say, “you can always ask me what I’m feeling. I’ll tell you.” I do my best to really believe this, knowing that there are still things I haven’t told him, and that Caleb can feel that desire to hide.
Wanting to mean it must be enough, because Caleb says, “I know,” and we grin dopily at each other before I ask him to tell me more about the scrimmage. Caleb grows animated, and I keep having to pull his hand back down as he gestures, causing both of us to laugh. It’s been twenty minutes and I’ve barely painted one hand.
“I think Chloe might come to the scrimmage too,” Caleb says.
“Chloe the mind reader?” I ask.
“That’s the one.”
I put down the bottle of polish and lean back on my hands to look at Caleb. He’s giving me the puppy-dog look, like I’m going to have a problem with the fact that he’s been hanging out with Chloe. Which I don’t. Even if I got a little freaked out by the whole encounter with her and Damien, spying on his therapist’s patients was my idea in the first place.
“That’ll be cool,” I say, careful to keep my voice neutral.
“She’s really chill,” Caleb says earnestly. “I went to her art studio a few days ago and she’s really good.”
“What kind of art does she do?” I ask, sensing that Caleb wants to talk more about it.
“She says she’s mostly done ceramics until now, but she’s starting to do a lot of painting,” he starts to explain, before continuing with a hesitance I haven’t seen from Caleb in a while. “She met this guy—Frank—who used to be an artist too. He’s a Marine and, well, he’s been having a hard go of it. Homeless and stuff.”
“Man, that’s hard,” I say.
“Yeah.” He nods, looking down at his nails. “And I guess he really loved to paint before he joined up so Chloe’s helping him get back into it. She’s reading his mind and then painting what he can’t. I think he’s got an injury in his hands or something.”
“Wait, what?” I struggle to keep up. Our little stakeouts in front of Dr. Bright’s office had been a fun, silly game. But then it opened Pandora’s box and a whole new, complicated, unreal world sprang out of it. “She’s reading his mind and painting what she sees?”
“Yeah! So, like, he’s thinking about what he wants his paintings to look like,” Caleb explains, “and then Chloe reads his mind and does the painting for him. Isn’t that cool?”
“Does he know that’s what she’s doing?” I ask, thinking that yes, it is cool, but also completely freaky.
“Oh, yeah, totally.” Caleb nods seriously. “They’re working on it together.”
“So she just up and told this guy that she’s a mind reader?”
“Well, no, not really,” he says. “It’s not like he’s just some guy. They’re friends. And … well…” There’s that hesitancy again and it still makes me grind my teeth. “I think he’s special too. Not like me and Chloe are—he’s not an Atypical. But he … it’s weird. When I met him, I realized I’d actually felt his feelings before.”
“What do you mean?”