“The best one yet,” Jackson agreed.
CHAPTER TWENTY-ONE
Nolan had never been the kind of man who overthought things. For years, he’d lived his life in a carefully constructed routine—deliver the mail, go home, and avoid anything that reminded him of the things that had turned his childhood from a happy one into something much more tumultuous. His life was set up in a way he liked it, with a good job and a routine that he liked just fine, and he hadn’t ever put too much thought into anything beyond that.
But now, sitting at the counter of the Snowdrift Diner and nursing a cup of coffee that had long since gone cold, Nolan found himself doing something he hadn’t done in years—contemplating the future. Or more specifically, contemplating a future that included someone else.
Abigail Palmer had been in Fir Tree Grove for little more than a week, and somehow she’d managed to slip past every defense he’d spent years building. She’d made him laugh, caused him to find enjoyment in the holiday and its traditions this year instead of just enduring them. He’d found himself wanting to sit out under the lights with her eating peppermint bark, wanting to take her up to the lookout point to show her how beautiful the town was from there, something he’d pointedly avoided for his entire adult life.
And last night, when he’d caught her as she slipped on the ice, when he’d held her briefly in his arms and seen the way she looked at him, he’d felt something shift in him, making him think about things that he hadn’t ever really seriously thought about… like what it would be like to share his life with someone. What it would be like to date someone with serious thoughts about the future.
The problem was, Abigail was leaving. Her car would be fixed soon, and she’d drive away from Fir Tree Grove, back to her actual life. The logical part of his brain told him it was foolish to get attached. It would be better for him to keep his distance and protect himself from the inevitable pain of watching her go.
But there was another part of him that whispered it would be a mistake not to at least show her that she mattered, that these few days had meant something.
He thought about the gingerbread contest they’d won, and how it had come with a gift certificate to the Maplewood Tavern. George had handed him the prize afterward—possibly as a way of setting him up to ask Abigail to dinner—he realized belatedly, and neither he nor Abigail had talked about it before he’d left. He didn’t think she’d even really noticed the prize at all. For her, all the fun had just been in competing. He’d folded it up and put it in his wallet and hadn’t given it another thought.
But now…
He wanted to spend more time with Abigail, even though he knew that might be setting himself up for more loss, given that she was leaving. But he thought of how her ex had made her feel worthless, like she wasn’t good for anything but what she could give him. He wanted her to feel like she was worth putting in effort for, worth remembering, and for her to know that he was absolutely going to remember her after she left.
He didn’t want to be too forward, but the gift card to the Maplewood Tavern was the perfect excuse. It didn’t have to be a date, if that was too much. He could just pose it to her as them enjoying the prize they’d won together before she left. That would take some of the pressure off. He wouldn’t feel as if he were being too pushy, and she wouldn’t feel like she was leading him on by accepting a date when she wasn’t staying much longer.
At the very least, it definitely lessened the chance that she’d say no. And he very much wanted her to say yes.
With that in mind, Nolan paid for his coffee and headed out into the cold December afternoon. The town was busy with the usual Thursday afternoon activity: people running errands, stopping to chat with neighbors, ducking in and out of shops with bags of Christmas purchases. He headed toward Mabel’s house first, thinking Abigail was probably there. But as he walked through town, he caught sight of her through the window of Artisan Chocolates instead.
Abigail was standing at the counter, talking animatedly with Imogen. Even from outside, Nolan could see the way her face lit up when she smiled. She was wearing a deep green sweater that made her look as if she fit right in with everyone else here, and she looked so lovely that Nolan’s breath caught in his throat.
He really hoped she’d say yes to dinner.
He took a deep breath, squared his shoulders, and pushed open the door to the chocolate shop. The bell above the door chimed as he walked in, and both women looked up.
“Nolan!” Imogen’s face broke into a delighted smile. “I’m starting to think you have a sweet tooth after all.”
“Something like that,” Nolan said, feeling suddenly shy all over again. His eyes found Abigail’s, and he saw surprise flicker across her face, followed by clear happiness to see him. That lifted his spirits immediately—she was looking at him like there was no one else she’d rather have seen come through that door.
“Hi,” Abigail said softly, and the greeting made his heart skip a beat.
“Hi.” Nolan stood there awkwardly, suddenly very aware of Imogen watching them with barely concealed amusement. “I was, uh… I was looking for you, actually.”
“For me?” Abigail’s eyebrows rose, and a faint blush colored her cheeks. “Is everything okay?”
“Yeah, everything’s fine. I just wanted to…” Nolan trailed off, the words he’d been rehearsing in his head suddenly evaporating. Why was this so hard? He’d faced down angry dogs on his mail route, dealt with difficult customers, and generally made a life for himself despite his hesitation to get close to anyone. But asking Abigail to dinner felt like the most complicated thing he’d ever attempted.
Abigail looked at him curiously, but she didn’t push or rush him, which he appreciated. She didn’t make him feel foolish for his awkwardness. It enabled him to finally find the courage to say what was on his mind… when the bell above the door chimed again.
He turned and saw Layla walking into the store. She looked tired, with dark circles under her eyes, and she was looking down as she came in with a sharp gust of cold behind her. She looked lost in thought as she paused at the counter, staring down at her feet.
“Layla?” Imogen asked gently as she walked over to where Layla was standing. “Are you all right, honey?”
Layla looked up, and Nolan could have sworn her eyes were faintly glossy. She blinked quickly, forcing a smile that didn’t reach her eyes. “Oh… yes. Sorry. I was wondering if you had any of your famous hot chocolate mix in stock, Imogen. I could really use something comforting right now,” she added with a small laugh.
“Of course I do. I always keep plenty of stock this time of year.” Imogen moved toward the shelves where she kept her mixes, but she was still looking at Layla, worry evident in her expression. “How did the fundraiser results turn out? I’ve been meaning to stop by the B&B to ask.”
Layla’s forced smile crumbled immediately, and she took a shaky breath that looked as if she were fighting off tears. “The fundraiser was wonderful—everyone was so generous, and we’re so grateful for what everyone did. But…”
She trailed off, and Nolan felt his chest tighten with dread. He’d hoped, like everyone else, that the fundraiser would be enough. Probably not enough to cover everything, but at least enough to make it so that Christopher would be able to come up with the difference.