Mabel’s heart leapt into her throat. George’s voice called out from the living room: “Mabel? I’m home! They didn’t have the right size screws, so I’ll have to go back tomorrow.”
She panicked, feeling like she’d had ice water dumped over her. She nearly tripped over the onesie as she tried to fold it back up the way it had been when she’d pulled it out, but it was like a fitted sheet, she thought. The fabric was slippery and didn’t want to stay folded.
She frantically tried to stuff the onesie back into the box, but the horn immediately caught on the cardboard flap. She pushed harder, but the fuzzy material was bulky and refused to compress. The ears got tangled with the tail. The more she shoved, the more everything seemed to expand, like the onesie was actively fighting her attempts to contain it.
She could hear his footsteps coming down the hallway, getting closer by the second.
Mabel gave up on the box and tried to throw the onesie back into the closet, but the horn caught on a hanging coat. She yanked, and the ears got tangled in some hangers. The tail somehow wrapped around her wrist like it had a mind of its own.
“I was thinking we could—”
George appeared in the doorway and stopped mid-sentence.
They froze, staring at each other.
Mabel stood there with one unicorn ear flopped over her head, the other sticking straight up, and the tail was wrapped around her wrist like a fuzzy purple bracelet. The horn wobbled above her, catching the light and throwing sparkles across George’s face.
“I can explain,” Mabel stammered, her face burning so hot she was sure it matched the purple of the ears’ lining. The giant horn wobbled accusingly.
George’s expression was carefully neutral, but she could see his mouth twitching behind his beard. “Can you?”
“I was just… putting away my shopping bags, and I saw the box, and the tag said it was for me, and I thought…” She trailed off, gesturing helplessly at the absurd onesie still tangled around her. The tail swung with the movement, nearly knocking over the lamp on the nightstand. “I’m sorry. I know I shouldn’t have peeked. I just couldn’t help myself.”
George stepped into the room, his face still maddeningly unreadable. “So… you found your Christmas present.”
“Yes.” Mabel tried to smile and look enthusiastic even though her heart was sinking. She loved George so much. If he’d misinterpreted what she’d wanted for Christmas this year this badly, well, it was the thought that counted. That’s what she’d tell anyone else. He’d cared enough to get her a gift and wrap it carefully and that all definitely counted for something. “It’s… it’s really something. Very… colorful. And the horn is… it’s very tall.”
“Do you like it?” George asked, his voice serious, as if this was very important to him.
Mabel’s mind raced. How did she answer this honestly without hurting his feelings? She couldn’t tell him it was the most ridiculous thing she’d ever seen. He’d put thought into this. He’d wrapped it carefully. He’d written that sweet note on the tag.
“It’s very… unique,” she managed. “I’ve never seen anything quite like it. That horn must be twelve inches tall.”
“Fourteen inches, actually,” George said seriously, his face grave. “I wanted to make sure you got the full unicorn experience.”
Mabel nodded, clutching the fuzzy fabric. The full unicorn experience. Because that was definitely something she’d been missing in her life. “The full experience. Of course. And the tail is a nice touch. Very… authentic.” What color were unicorn tails, anyway?
“I’m glad you think so.” George leaned against the doorway, looking pleased. “So you’ll wear it? I think Philip especially will love it, Christmas morning.”
Mabel’s eyes widened, and she gulped, trying to imagine herself shuffling around the house on Christmas morning, helping Vanessa with Philip, opening presents, serving breakfast…”
But if it made George happy…
“Of course I’ll wear it,” she said, forcing brightness into her voice. She could do this. She’d done harder things. She’d given birth. She’d opened her own store. She ran a business. She could wear a unicorn onesie. “I’ll wear it all Christmas morning. We can take pictures. Vanessa and Philip will… love it.”
Something flickered in George’s eyes. His mouth twitched at the corner.
“You’ll really wear it?” he pressed. “Even though it’s completely ridiculous and you’d look like an oversized toddler who raided a costume shop?”
Mabel blinked. “I… well, I wouldn’t say—”
George started to laugh.
It started as a chuckle, deep in his chest, and then grew into full, rolling laughter that made his shoulders shake. He bent forward slightly, one hand on his knee, laughing so hard he could barely breathe.
“George?” She frowned, feeling a little put-upon now. She’d tried so hard to be understanding, and now he was laughing at her? When he’d decided this was what she must want in the first place?
He couldn’t stop. He reached out and took the onesie from her hands, holding up the enormous horn. The sparkles created a disco ball effect across the ceiling. “Mabel, honey,” he gasped between laughs, “did you really think I would buy you this?”