Jackson looked utterly confused. “You want to buy Christmas cookies?” He cleared his own throat.
“You’re selling them, right?” Nolan said grumpily.
“Well, yeah. But you’ve never been one for holiday sweets. I believe the last time you came in and saw us packaging them up, you said something about how it was a waste of time to cut them into all those silly shapes when they tasted exactly the same in a circle.”
Had he said that? Nolan winced. That sounded like something he would have said. “Well, maybe I’ve changed my mind.”
“Yeah?” Jackson was staring at him curiously, and Nolan felt heat creep up his neck.
“They’re not for me,” he said, more defensively than he’d intended. “They’re for Abigail. The woman staying with Mabel and George. She’s having a rough time of it this season, and I thought—” He stopped, not sure how to finish that sentence. What was he thinking? That a box of cookies would somehow make her feel better?
But Jackson’s expression had softened, and he gave him a knowing look. It made Nolan want to get up and walk right back out the door.
“Abigail,” Jackson said slowly. “The one whose car broke down.”
“Yes,” Nolan said gruffly.
“Right.” Jackson was grinning now, and Nolan wanted to sink through the floor. “Well, lucky for you, I’ve got a fresh box right here. Just finished packing it this morning.”
He disappeared into the kitchen and returned a moment later with a white bakery box tied with red and green ribbon. Through the clear window on top, Nolan could see an assortment of cookies—snowflakes dusted with sugar, gingerbread men with perfect icing details, chocolate crinkles, and something that looked like it had cranberries in it.
“This year’s signature collection,” Jackson said, setting the box on the counter. “Sugar cookies, gingerbread, chocolate peppermint, cranberry white chocolate, and snickerdoodles. All made fresh this morning.”
Nolan pulled out his wallet, trying not to look at the price Jackson quoted. It was more than he could have ever imagined spending on cookies, of all things, but he handed over the bills without comment.
“She must be pretty special,” Jackson said as he made change.
“She’s having a hard time,” Nolan said shortly.
“Well, I hope the cookies help.” Jackson slid the box across the counter. “It’s good to see you doing something nice for someone. Especially during the holidays.”
Nolan just grunted and picked up the box, tucking it under his arm. He could feel Jackson watching him as he headed for the door, and he thought he practically hear the wheels turning in the other man’s head. By this afternoon, half the town would probably know that Nolan had bought Christmas cookies for the woman stranded there.
The thought should have bothered him more than it did.
Nolan walked quickly toward his truck, feeling conspicuous carrying the festive box with its cheerful ribbon. He set it carefully on the passenger seat and sat there for a moment with his hands on the steering wheel, wondering again what he was doing.
He hadn’t been able to stop thinking about Abigail since yesterday, when he’d seen her at the mechanic’s shop, looking lost. Since they’d gotten hot chocolate together and he’d watched her face light up at the taste of it.
He kept thinking he wanted to see her smile again. He couldn’t remember the last time he’d felt that way about someone—he wasn’t really sure if he ever had. Dating wasn’t really a thing he did. At least not more than casually, because just like the holiday season brought back so many bad memories, he couldn’t think about the idea of having a family without wondering if he’d screw it all up too.
He pinched the bridge of his nose. What was he even thinking? Abigail was leaving soon, so he didn’t know why he was going down this train of thought. None of it mattered. And at this rate, it would be good when she left, so he could go back to his peaceful, quiet existence of delivering mail and chopping firewood and being left alone.
Nolan started the truck and headed toward Mabel and George’s house. He’d heard Mabel mention yesterday that she was planning to decorate her Christmas tree today, and he assumed Abigail would be out exploring town or resting at her place. He figured he could drop the cookies off with Mabel, ask her to give them to Abigail later, and make his escape before anyone could make a big deal out of it.
When he pulled up to the house, he started having second thoughts. Mabel was well-meaning and a wonderful woman, but she was also a little bit of a meddling busybody, especially when it came to people’s love lives. Not that there was a love life for her to meddle in, or the possibility of one…
He didn’t let himself finish that thought. He grabbed the box and got out of the truck before he could talk himself out of it.
The front door opened before he could knock, and Mabel stood there with a delighted smile that immediately made him suspicious.
“Nolan! What a wonderful surprise. Come in, come in.”
He stepped inside and was immediately hit by the warmth and the scent of pine and cinnamon. The living room was a scene of cheerful chaos. A large Christmas tree stood in the corner, half-decorated, with boxes of ornaments scattered around its base. Packages of tinsel were scattered over the couch. He thought he smelled eggnog and spiced coffee.
And, he realized as he stopped in his tracks, Abigail was there as well. She was standing by the tree with a silver ornament in her hand, and her eyes widened slightly when she caught sight of him.
She was wearing yoga pants and a tank top with a long, soft-looking red cardigan over it, her hair pulled back in a ponytail, and there was a smudge of what looked like glitter on her cheek. She looked much more relaxed than the forlorn woman he’d seen at the mechanic’s shop yesterday.