They’d reached Main Street, and Nolan pointed to a shop halfway down the block. “That’s it.”
Imogen had decorated Artisan Chocolates with hand-painted, glittery snowflakes in the window and bright white lights this year, and the store gave off a warm glow as they approached. The shop was bustling with customers, all looking for gifts or sampling the chocolates.
He pulled open the door, and a bell chimed overhead. The scent hit them immediately: rich chocolate, peppermint, cinnamon, and vanilla. It was warm and inviting, a smell that made you want to sit down and stay awhile.
Abigail stopped just inside the doorway, her eyes wide. “Oh,” she breathed. “This is beautiful.”
And it was, Nolan supposed, if you were into that sort of thing. The walls were painted a warm cream color, with the wall behind the hot chocolate bar painted in vintage striping of pink and white. Dark wood shelving displayed pre-wrapped gift boxes and mason jars of hot cocoa mix wrapped with red and green and white twine. More white lights were draped around the store, and a small Christmas tree was in the window, with confection-themed ornaments. A chalkboard menu hung behind the counter, listing various hot chocolate flavors in cheerful script.
“Nolan!” a voice called out, and Imogen emerged from the back room, a smile on her face and several boxes of peppermint bark in her hands. “I don’t think I’ve ever seen you in here during December without a package that won’t fit in the mailbox in your arms.”
“There’s a first time for everything,” Nolan said gruffly. “Apparently.”
Imogen’s gaze shifted to Abigail, and her smile widened. “And you’ve brought a friend. Welcome! I’m Imogen.”
Abigail had stepped fully into the shop by then, and she took a breath, a genuine smile on her face. “Abigail,” she said. “This place is wonderful.”
“Thank you. Can I get you something? I always recommend the peppermint hot chocolate.”
Abigail looked at Nolan. “What do you recommend?”
“I’m not exactly an expert,” he admitted. “But the peppermint sounds fine.”
Imogen glanced between them, her expression slightly perplexed. “One or two hot chocolates?” she asked, and her eyebrows rose in surprise when Nolan shrugged.
“Two’s fine.”
“Oh! Okay, perfect.” Imogen smiled, and there was that hint of amusement in it that had been on Tom’s face too. “Two peppermint hot chocolates coming right up. Whipped cream and crushed peppermint topping all right?”
“I’d love it however you like to prepare it,” Abigail said, and Nolan shrugged again, nodding.
They stood at the counter, and Nolan was aware of how close Abigail was standing. She had a springy scent on, something that smelled like fresh grass and a hint of florals, and it felt like a bright spot in the cold, frigid day.
“So you really don’t like hot chocolate?” Abigail asked, amusement in her voice.
“I didn’t say I don’t like it,” he said, a touch grumpily. “I said it’s frivolously done up.”
“And yet here you are.” She smiled. “I’m glad you decided to give it a try. It sounds amazing.”
Imogen returned with two mugs, and Nolan had to admit they were exactly as frivolous as he’d claimed—piled high with whipped cream, drizzled with chocolate sauce, and topped with crushed peppermint and a candy cane stirrer. The mound of toppings was almost as tall as the mugs themselves.
Abigail’s face lit up, though, her expression utterly enchanted. “Oh my gosh, these are perfect. So Christmassy!”
Nolan paid for both drinks before she could protest, and Abigail glanced over at the boxes of peppermint bark sitting on the counter.
“Can I get one of those?” she asked. “I’ll pay separately,” she added quickly, before Nolan could think she was adding on to the order.
Imogen rang them both up, and they took their mugs outside, finding a bench near the shop despite the cold. Abigail took a sip of her hot chocolate and closed her eyes. “Oh my goodness,” she said. “This is incredible.”
Nolan tried his own, and he had to admit—grudgingly—that it was good. Rich and creamy, with just the right amount of peppermint. Not that he’d ever admit that to Tom.
Abigail opened the box of peppermint bark and offered it to him. He took a piece, and they sat there in companionable silence, eating peppermint candy and drinking their frivolous hot chocolate while the December afternoon grew colder around them.
And suddenly, Nolan realized to his shock that he wanted to linger. He wanted to keep sitting on this bench with this beautiful stranger and sip ridiculous hot cocoa, while trying to think of something to say to keep her here next to him.
That was insane, he knew. He had mail to finish delivering, and she was leaving as soon as her car was fixed. He needed to come back to reality. And he should stop imposing on this young woman who had better things to do than entertain the grumpy mailman.
“I should get back to my route,” he said finally, although the words felt slow to come.