Page 42 of One More Goal

Page List

Font Size:

“Brooks is the captain of the Jacksonville Mud Hens, and that’s how he knows this guy, Leo Santos, the team’s newest forward,” she continues, gesturing in Leo’s general direction.

As soon as she motions toward him, our eyes follow her movement so we’re basically all staring at the poor guy. I know he’s gotta be hating every second of this. He didn’t like being the center of attention four years ago, and it looks like that hasn’t changed. And really I'm doing my best not to stare. I’m trying to get a gauge on how to play this thing between us. Do we acknowledge that we’ve already met? Do we go full throttle and overshare that we’ve seen each other naked? Or do we act like total strangers?

Without warning, Leo thrusts his hand out between us and gives mine a hearty shake.

Okay, then. Option number three it is. Total strangers. And that’s totally fine by me.

I’m not going to have an ounce of trouble pretending I’ve never laid my eyes—or my hands—on the guy. I’m the Queen of Cool. The Maven of Meh. The Sovereign of Serenity.

Just kidding.

“Leo! Oh my God! Hi! It’s so nice to meet you.” The words tumble out of my mouth at a rate of speed that is rivaled only by the ridiculously high pitch of my voice. I’m usually way smoother than this. I’m not the kind of girl who’s intimidated by high profile athletes. I’ve been around them my entire life. But that’s not who Leo is. At least, not to me. He's the first man I slept with. The one I gave my virginity to. The one who took care of me when I was sick. Who made me laugh when I wanted to cry. The one who held me in his arms like I meant something to him.

Thankfully, no one mentions my fangirling as Sadie expertly takes the reins of the conversation. Leo’s buddy, Brooks, still looks a little shocked, but he’s doing his best to hide it as he nods along with everything Sadie has to say.

“You’re just two people meeting up for coffee, okay? Nothing more, nothing less. I have a feeling you two are going to hit it off, but even if I’m wrong—which, incidentally, I never am—at least you can each gain a new friend.”

Leo nods like he’s just received his marching orders and I find myself smiling at how serious he is. That hasn’t changed.

“Great. Well, Brooks and I are going to head out and let you two get acquainted.”

As soon as the words are out of Sadie’s mouth and she reaches for her bag, Leo nods again, and I can’t tell if he’s just acknowledging the fact that Sadie and his buddy are leaving, or if he’s resigned to it, but either way, a minute later, Leo and I are all alone and staring at each other.

Silence stretches between us as I try to think of something to say. But what do you say when you’re face-to-face with a man for the first time in nearly four years? A man you saw naked. And let’s be clear. We didn’t just see each other naked. It wasn’t momentary or accidental. I didn’t walk in while he was changing and then slam the door with enough force to erase the image of his perfectly sculpted body from my memory.

No, we saw each other naked for a reason. A really good reason. And we didn’t just look. We touched. And tasted. And⁠—

“Coffee.” Leo nearly spits the sword out and for a horrible second I wonder if I was thinking out loud. “I should get coffee. I mean, we’re in a coffee shop, so that’s the next logical step, right? Yes, of course it is,” he says, answering his own question before I have the chance to. “So…I’ll get us some coffee and then I’ll be right back.”

He gets up so quickly that his chair tilts precariously for a second before he rights it. And then he makes a mad dash to get in line. There are only a handful of other people in the shop—an older couple, a trio of teenage girls, and a pair of women with baby strollers—so it’s not like he’s got to beat the crowd or anything. I didn’t get the chance to give him my order, but that doesn’t really matter. I’m not too picky when it comes to coffee. Besides, it’s Leo. I’ll drink whatever he brings me because he’s just so damn sweet.

I let my eyes roam around the coffee shop, taking in my surroundings. I give myself an invisible gold star for not picking up my phone and scrolling through it. I always have the best of intentions—I’m just going to check my messages or send a funny video to Fallon. But the temptation to check to see if my name is still trending is too hard to resist sometimes. And now is not the time for me to go wandering around the internet. Being setup with Leo is strange enough. The last thing I need is for him to come back to the table and find me fighting back tears. I’m not usually a crier. Or at least, I wasn’t until recently. But there’s something about total strangers picking apart every aspect of my life and facet of my body that turns the waterworks on.

“Do you still like hazelnut? I remember you using Fallon’s creamer, so I figured you might still like it,” Leo says, setting a cup in front of me. “But I take mine plain, so if you’d rather have that, we can switch. And now I probably sound like a weirdo for remembering the way you take your coffee. I’m not. It’s just that I have a good memory for details.”

His cheeks are ruddy, like he just ran a mile or came in from the cold. But it’s September and even though the sky is overcast, the chance of chilly temps in Florida today seems unlikely. I think it’s cute, the way he blushes, though I have no business thinking about him at all. Before I get all sappy and start reminiscing about our weekend together, or say something about how damn good he looks, I decide to steer the conversation in a light-hearted direction.

“I don’t think you’re a weirdo, and thanks for this, by the way” I say, lifting my cup. “I’m just glad you remember who I am. I wasn’t so sure there for a second when Sadie was introducing us.”

Leo’s cheeks turn from pink to crimson and I realize I passed light-hearted and went straight to awkward. “Uh, yeah. Sorry about that,” he says. “Sadie said she had a friend she wanted me to meet. Why she wants me to meet someone in the first place is a long story, but she and Brooksie have done a lot for me lately, so when she told me to drive out here to a little coffee shop a block away from the beach, I didn’t hesitate. But when I saw you and realized you were the person Sadie paired me up with? I froze. I was not expecting that. I didn’t even know you lived here now.”

“It’s just temporary,” I tell him as I toy with the cardboard collar on my coffee cup. “Ollie’s folks have a place down here, so I’m crashing at their beach house for a few weeks.”

“Oh, that’s nice,” he says as silence descends around us once again.

I take a deep breath before addressing the giant velociraptor in the room. Because my recent woes are no elephant; they’re a whole-ass dinosaur with talons and claws and a tail that could probably slice my head off. I need to be honest with Leo about why we were set up

“Look, Sadie and I aren’t friends, exactly. She’s a friend of Fallon’s and I met her last week. She’s great, but she’s not just playing matchmaker. My life has been a little complicated lately, and⁠—”

“And it’s bullshit,” Leo says before taking a sip of his coffee. It must be piping hot because he takes the lid off and blows on it.

And no, the image of his perfectly puckered lips does not make me think dirty thoughts. Well, maybe just a few. I manage to shake off the lust-fog just in time to catch what he’s saying.

“So you’ve heard about my interview faux-pas? Or worse, you saw it live?”

“I only saw a clip that they replayed later. It was on in the gym during workouts.” He blows on his coffee again before taking a tentative sip. It must be the perfect temperature now because the smile that graces his lips is one of pure satisfaction. It’s a smile I remember. And that’s a surefire sign that I need to politely make my way out of here and tell Sadie she needs to go back to the drawing board.

“It was on the TV at your gym? Like, the private one in your house?” I ask, though I already know the answer.


Novels you may like ...