My hand froze on the wood, not quite sure how to make myself knock. I knew I’d come this far, and it didn’t make any sense to back out now, but… every part of me locked up, and I tried to play out in my head how it would go once she opened the door and saw me there. What I would say.
Why was I even here? Did she even want to see me?
“For fuck’s sake, Jordan, knock,” I whispered, and I cringed as I knocked quietly. No response. I grimaced, and I summoned up everything I had to knock harder.
And still, nothing. I was going to throw up.
You shouldn’t have come here. You should have told Emma no, should have gone home, should have been normal. You screwed it up again.
I felt around for a doorbell, finding a button at the side, and I heaved an anxious breath as I pushed it. No response.
Great. Right. She didn’t want visitors. Why would she?
Thunder rolled in the distance. I stood there frozen—my pants were getting soaked, and I needed to move, needed to make a decision and do something one way or another, but I couldn’t figure out how to do anything, how to move my body in the most basic ways for the most basic tasks.
I didn’t know what was wrong with me, but I knew I was crying now. I felt tears angry on my face, and I squeezed my hand into a fist on the door, spiraling into self-hatred once again, when I felt a hand land on my shoulder.
I jumped with a scream, whirling around on where—my face flushed hot at the sight of her there, eyes gleaming as she looked at me. 75.
Michelle.
Her… car was behind her. Oh, Jesus Christ. It hadn’t been in the driveway when I’d arrived. How had I not clocked that?
She wasn’t refusing to answer the door because she hated me. She wasn’t there.
“Far be it from me to say, but a sensible woman would have waited in the car instead of standing in the rain looking like a sad puppy fresh out the bath.”
I wiped my eyes. God, it was obvious I’d been crying. Not just could she maybe tell, but full-fledged, this girl has been sobbing on my stoop. “Do I look like a sensible woman?”
“You look like a very uncomfortable woman. Do you want to come inside, or do you like getting soaked in the rain?”
I laughed thickly. She wasn’t mad at me for showing up here. “I don’t know, I’m kind of torn. Do you think the drowned sewer rat look is good on me?”
She smiled, unlocking the door. “If you’re going for ghost that drowns people in the lake, you look lovely. Otherwise, let’s get inside.”
It was a beautiful place on the inside, too, nicely decorated—if maybe a bit tacky—and warm, especially once Michelle flicked a switch and a gas fireplace lit up. It smelled like a cedar chest, and I huddled in the warmth that wrapped around me as soon as she shut the door back behind us. I held her bag up for her.
“You, um… you left this at…”
“I know.” Her fingers brushed mine as she took it, and if I didn’t know better, I’d swear it was intentional. “I went back when I realized. Your manager told me she’d already dispatched her most loyal soldier to bring it to me. Then I found you standing on my stoop looking like you should be in a charity advert with Sarah McLachlan playing.”
“I am not an ASPCA dog,” I laughed, but the sound of tears on my voice didn’t help. “But my apologies for the intrusion, Michelle Forrester.”
Her eyes lit up, and she grinned. “I knew it.”
“Knew I’d finally rat you out eventually?”
She leaned against the wall with one hand casually in her pocket. “I knew the buildup would make it sound even better when you finally said my name.”
“Um… I…” I felt a sudden whoosh of heat that sent the damp cold packing.
That was… definitely… flirting.
Holy shit. Never mind Kina being right—why was she flirting with me?
Michelle just smiled wider. I swallowed, looking away, fully aware I probably looked like a color swatch of every Pantone red. “Well, in that case, I’ll just stick to the dumb number. I wouldn’t want you to win that easily.”
“Whatever you like, 61.” She winked. “Do you want to do something other than drip in my doorway? Or were you just coming around to brag you finally figured out my name?”