“Whoever did it knew you’d come over. They knew about us. You were an easy target.”
She tsks, swinging her legs to the other side of the bench. “Well, that narrows absolutely nothing down. Everyone heard about us by Monday afternoon.”
“The timing doesn’t track.” I pace again, wringing my hands together. “Everyone at school found out about us that day. On Monday. But this had to take time to plan. Having my dad’s car break down that morning so his car wasn’t there. The Snap to you. And I still wonder if my dad was dead before the fire started. You called out when you walked into the house. He would’ve heard you.” Our house wasn’t that large. And Dad never closed doors unless he was in the bathroom. But when they found him, his bedroom door was shut. “Unfortunately, the new autopsy was inconclusive.”
Her fingers squeeze the black bench as she drops her head, thinking. After a few silent beats, she says, “There’s no way anyone could have known before then. I mean, the first person I told was Sadie that Monday morning. And she acted surprised.”
She flashes a questioning expression.
“I told you, I didn’t tell anyone.” I echo my previous words, swallowing the edge in my tone. I get it. She’s trying to make sense of everything, but I wish she would trust me. “Even after Brody and I got into a fight that afternoon, I told him it wasn’t any of his fucking business. But there was a house full of people the night we were together.”
Her head rears back. “Are you insinuating someone in my house that night did this?”
That wasn’t what I meant. “Shit, I hope not. More wondering if one of them heard or saw us and then they told someone.”
“Okay,” she starts, holding up one finger. “We have Sadie, Bri, Chloe, Harlo, um…Brody and Levi. We can cross—”
“And Christian,” I add.
Her gaze narrows. “Christian wasn’t there.”
I remember who I walked into the house with. We had finished our all-day tournament, went to McDonald’s, and then Brody’s for him to grab some clothes. We hadn’t planned on staying. But Brody’s plans changed when Harlo accompanied him into his bedroom. We were beat from the games, so nobody pissed and whined too much.
“He was. He and Levi crashed on the couch. I took a shower.”
“I talked to Levi. He left.”
I shrug. “Yeah? And Christian was still passed out when I left that night.”
“Hmm,” she says, twisting her lips. “He had a lot to lose.”
No way Christian did this. Sure, he had a lot to lose. The Major League Baseball draft was only a month away, and he was good enough to hear his name called. No chance he’d jeopardize that, least of all rape a girl and commit murder.
“Could he have overheard us? It’s possible. But the other stuff? Absolutely not. How do you explain your brother’s death? Christian’s in the middle of baseball season. In fact, he was on TV playing the other day.”
Wrenlee groans, dragging a hand down her face. “We need to find who has Leslie!” She crosses the living room to her bag and rummages through it. She pulls out a business card. “I’m calling Levi. Maybe he knows who Leslie was with that night. You know how guys talk…”
I’d rather she didn’t. But if I say anything, it’ll only make her double down. So, I keep my mouth shut. She watches me, waiting for a reaction.
“What?”
Her lips twist. “I’m just surprised.”
I snort. “Picking my battles.”
She types in his number, then lifts her gaze. “I’ll put him on speaker for you.”
I mouth thank you as it rings.
“Hello?”
“Hey, Levi, it’s Wren.”
“Wren. What’s up?” His voice shifts from worried to excited in one beat. But we both caught it.
“I was hoping you could help me with something. Remember the night of my sleepover when you guys showed up after the game? When Harlo and Brody hooked up?”
“Among other people…” he adds, then sighs. “Sorry, that was a dick move.”