I push past the guilt creeping in. There’s nothing I can do to change the past, but I can help her set it right.
That’s the only reason I’m here.
Keep telling yourself the lie, Keats. It might soften the impending fall.
By now, I’m sure she’s gone through Brody’s things. She’ll realize I was helping him and I’m not the enemy. Driving over here this morning, I wondered if she’d still be here. If I were in her shoes, I’m not sure I’d stick around.
No, I’d have been long gone before they wheeled Brody out of the funeral home.
But she’s in there. And I’m out here.
So, what the hell do I do now?
I catch my reflection in the rearview mirror, practicing. “Hey, Wrenlee. Just stopping by to see if…” I trail off. It needs to be a good reason. But the only thing at the tip of my tongue is, “because I wanted to see you again.”
I groan out loud.
She’ll for sure try to slap me again.
When the door to her room opens, I straighten in my seat, wondering if she caught me sitting out here, watching her like some kind of stalker. My pulse picks up as she walks down the stairs. I reach for the door handle, ready to hop out, but she walks straight to her car. Didn’t even look my way.
I shouldn’t feel disappointed, but hell, I do. It’s a good thing she didn’t spot me.
A quiet laugh escapes me, remembering all the times I used to steal glances at her from across a room in school or at games—how she’d catch me, and I’d have to force my gaze away. Pretend that the pounding of my heart wasn’t because of her.
When Brody and I first crossed paths again at UNLV and started talking, I laid it all out. I told him the truth; I’d always been in love with his sister. He said he already knew. And the reason I’d kept it quiet was the same reason he never called me on it. We were best friends. And back then, that mattered more to us than anything. And little sisters were off-limits.
I regretted never acting on it. He regretted never saying anything. We both agreed everything would’ve been different if we had.
My phone rings, yanking me out of the past. I glance at the screen and answer against my better judgment.
“Hey, Mom. What’s up?” I say, tracking Wrenlee as she backs out.
“What’s up?” she replies with a sharp tone. I know where this is heading. “I heard about Brody Reed. And that he was living with you!”
“He was,” I say matter-of-factly.
“Keaton,” she sighs. “What was he doing there?”
Mom and Dad hated each other. When the fire happened, they’d been divorced for ten years. He fought her for custody out of spite and somehow won. So, when he died, she tried to act sympathetic, but there was no genuine grief there. No love lost. She had a new husband by then, and they had a little girl, my half sister, Lily. They moved to Oklahoma right after the fire.
Mom never knew what to think of Wrenlee. If she were guilty or innocent. She could only go by what was presented in court. And they painted a damn convincing picture.
“Brody was here on business. I offered him a place to stay.”
It’s not a lie.
Wrenlee pulls out into the street. Not a beat later, a silver sedan rolls out behind her. Where did they come from? With windows tinted black and out-of-town plates, my body tenses immediately. Shit. She might not be safe here.
“Mom, gotta go. I’ll call you later.” I fire up the truck and throw it into drive, cutting across the curb straight onto the street instead of wasting time going through the parking lot.
“Keaton—”
“Bye, Mom. Love you.” I end the call and hit the gas.
I follow at a careful distance, two cars between me and the silver car, with Wrenlee a few cars ahead of them. Every light we hit, I will the other car to turn off. Instead, it stays locked behind her.
When Wrenlee pulls into a parking lot ahead, relief and unease hit at the same time. Hazel Falls Police Station. I slow down, watching to see if the sedan follows her in, but we both drive past. I’m stuck between keeping going to find out who’s in the car or turning back and making sure Wrenlee comes out. I don’t trust our police department. There’s no telling what bullshit charges they’ll dredge up on her now if she starts asking questions.