He never made that appointment.
Who is JB?
I scan the remainder of the month, then flip back to May. The same initials appear three more times. Switching to the journal, I search for a name with the initials JB. I find their page. His notes are different this time. Short. Clipped sentences. Informal. I can’t tell if JB is a man or a woman.
May 5th—Nervous. Said something happened at a party but shut down before explaining. Thought someone saw us talking and bolted. Need to work on them more.
May 20th—Met in the woods. Less on edge this time. Worried about repercussions. Told me to talk to Harlo.
It has to be a woman.
June 1st—Met in the woods again. They paced a lot. Asked if I started dating Harlo because of what they said. Didn’t confirm nor deny. Told them without using their name, I can’t press Harlo because I don’t know what I’m supposed to be asking. But I am trying. They made me promise not to use names. Back at square one.
June 8—JB called. Ready to tell me everything. Set up a meeting.
My stomach drops.
And then Brody was dead.
I shove everything into the box, my hands shaking as I slam the lid shut. “Why? Why, why, why?” I scream, guilt flooding my chest, sharp and suffocating. “You didn’t have to die for me. I was fine—I am fine, damn it!”
Would I have wanted the real person to pay for what they did? Hell yes. But not like this. Not at the cost of losing my brother. I press my palms against my eyes, willing the tears to stop. I feel like I’m living in this nightmare of this town again.
The box sits on the bed, its presence alone suffocating. But can I walk out of here? Pretend none of this exists and go back to my life? The real question is, can I live with myself if I let my brother’s death mean nothing?
The answer is obvious. There’s no walking away. I cross the room and dig into my purse until my fingers find my phone and a business card. My breath comes out sharp, and I enter the number. She answers on the second ring. I hope Brody was right about her.
“Hey, it’s Wren. Can we meet?”
We’re meeting in the park near the waterfalls. A popular place we’d hang out at when we were in high school. It’s midday, so the vicinity is quiet, save for the sound of rushing water. I spot Sadie as she steps out of her car, parked along the street, glancing to her left and right as if she’s checking for something.
Or someone.
When she gets closer, I notice a familiar brown bag in her hand.
“Is that what I think it is?” I ask.
She holds up the bag, shaking it. “You know you miss it.”
“I’ve yet to find one that tastes as good. And I’ve tried.”
“I tried too, when I was away at college, but nope,” she says, dropping the bag on the table.
I pull out two foil-wrapped gyros as she slides into the seat across from me. My stomach grumbles, unhappy that I’ve been neglecting it since I arrived. Eating hasn’t been a priority. And after last night’s tequila-fueled disaster, I’m surprised it wants anything.
My mouth waters unwrapping one. She grabs two waters out of her bag, sets them down, then unwraps hers.
The first bite makes my eyes roll back. Something about their tzatziki sauce is different. It has, like, crack in it, or a certain ingredient that’s addictive.
“Damn, this is so good,” I mumble with a full mouth.
“Some things never change,” she says, taking a bite herself.
I chuckle, dabbing my lips with a napkin. “Everything else has, though. What’s with all the new cabins in The Pines?”
She scoffs. “New mayor. Everyone is pissed, but they’re the ones who voted him in.” After taking a drink of water, she swallows hard before her tone softens. “I still can’t believe Brody’s gone. He was one of the good guys.”
He was the best.