I didn’t even hear anyone sit down.
I don’t look over as I reply, “Nope.” I take another pull from my beer, ignoring the stranger.
My mind snaps back into a mirage of seeing her. She’s a baby wrapped tight in a blanket this time, Wrenlee holding her close to her chest, pressing her lips to her chubby cheeks. Then she lifts her, extending her out as if she’s handing her to me. I step forward, but someone cuts between us, takes her, and walks away.
A sound comes out of me I don’t recognize. Low and broken. After a beat, I mutter, barely audible, “Got any kids?” I swing my attention to the stranger for the first time.
Maybe talking will make the images stop. Quiet the noise.
His hat is pulled low, shadowing his eyes. Scruff lines his jaw. He’s wearing a worn flannel with the sleeves pulled up. He puts his beer down and shakes his head.
“Yeah.” A ragged breath rattles from the back of my throat. “I didn’t think I had any either.” The words scrape out. “Till about an hour ago.”
He hums. “One of those calls,” he says. “That’ll knock the wind out of you.”
When does it come back?
Because it’s so hard to fucking breathe.
I stare straight forward, the stars on the American flag blurring together. “I’ve lived my entire life thinking about her every day,” I say, the words spilling out as if I’ve lost control of them. “Even when she went away, she owned my thoughts.” My jaw tightens. “And she had my baby and never told me.” I dig my palms into my eye sockets. “Then she put her up for adoption.” The words snag, and I choke on a sound I don’t recognize as my own.
“Fuck,” I groan, swiping at the tears that escaped. I finish my beer. Slamming the glass down gets the bartender’s attention. I point to my empty glass.
I don’t need to say a word. He’s got eyes and ears. The low hum of music in the background isn’t drowning out a damn thing. I twist on the stool and wince at the stranger and shrug, hardly holding it together. “Bet you regret coming in that door tonight.”
His crooked grin is easy, relaxed. “Son, I’m exactly where I’m needed.”
A bitter laugh escapes as my entire world caves in.
“She would’ve never told me,” I whisper.
“People don’t keep secrets that monumental because they don’t care. They keep them because they’re scared shitless.”
My mind drags me back to the day I left for college. I drove past Wrenlee’s house. The reporters had moved on, and I remember being furious. How could they forget so easily? My dad was dead because of her, and my childhood home was nothing but ash. The anger was sharp and blinding. I’d wanted to park, storm up to her door, and make her feel every ounce of pain I was carrying. I needed her to hurt the way I was hurting.
“Ten years ago, she was on house arrest,” I say, tugging my hat off and dragging a hand through my hair before putting it back on. “And I left her. That’s when she had the baby.”
“Dare I ask what she was on house arrest for?”
“Starting a fire. And killing my dad.”
Silence drops between us. When I peer over, his expression has stilled as he processes what I said. I don’t have the energy to explain.
Is this what she regretted not telling Brody? She didn’t even tell her brother? “You’re right. She was scared shitless.”
I see it now. I see the eighteen-year-old girl trapped in her house. Branded a killer. Carrying my child. Alone.
“Had you known about the baby…” His words are careful. “Would you have done anything differently?”
I take a swig from the cold, fresh beer. I want to say yes, that I’d have taken the high road and been there for her.
But the truth is ugly.
“At that moment?” I huff out a hollow sound. “I was on my way to a pro baseball future. I had a full-ride scholarship. Nothing was going to tie me down, least of all her. The woman who killed my dad.”
It hurts to say that out loud.
He nods once, no ounce of judgment in his expression. “Sounds like she made the tough decision for both of you.”