The truth was, she could stab me in the heart repeatedly and I’d apologize for bleeding on her shirt.
I would never intentionally hurt her—especially not by weaponizing her past.
My emotions were getting the best of me, the fury and rage morphing into desperation as I took her face into my hands. “I swear on my life that I never said that to you, Scarlett.”
“I believe you,” Scar responded, but I couldn’t hear her over the roaring in my ears. Couldn’t think over the wound opening in my chest, my heart feeling like a pin cushion.
“Baby, I don’t know what happened, but I swear I will find ou—”
“I don’t know why or how it happened, but ...” Her warm palm rested against my cheek, the strain in my middle lessening slightly. I stopped rambling, needing to hear what she had to say. “I believe you, Finn.”
The panic subsided momentarily as I brushed another tear from her cheek, not wanting to see another ounce of pain on that pretty face. “You do?” I was breathless, my voice barely above a whisper, because what had I done to deserve this goddess of woman in my life?
“I do,” Scarlett nodded with her head still in my hands, so it didn’t move very far. “You’re a lot of things, Finnegan MacCallum, but you were never cruel to me. I thought it was weird that you would say something like that to me, but then be so …” She gave a small, weak shrug with her shoulders. “Pestersome for my attention.”
“I never want to hurt you, Scarlett.” Her bottom lip wobbled, a fresh set of tears on the verge of falling at my words.
She was right. I was a lot of things. Arrogant, annoying, loud, cocky; but being capable of hurting her wasn’t something I could manage.
Not ever.
“I’m going to get to the bottom of this,” I swore, even though she wasn’t asking. To her, it was still the past and probably some fluke she could work through, but I knew how much those words had haunted her. I knew what seeing that message had caused her. I could still see it in her cerulean eyes, the insecurity nestled beneath her cold façade. I felt like I was going insane with this information, like it was an awakening revelation, and I needed answers now.
Fuck—I felt sick when I looked at her upset face, knowing I was the cause of her affliction.
“Sweetheart, I swear I will find out who did that.” My tone grew deadlier, malice dripping from my words as I swore my oath of protection to her. I’d move heaven and hell to keep her heart safe. “Even though you know it wasn’t me, someone still intentionally hurt you. I need to find out who and why.”
Scarlett gave me a weak, wobbly smile. “I don’t need you to go chasing down cyber criminals in the middle of the night to uncover some text from a decade ago.” Her voice was vigorous, her resolve coming through in her words. “I’m strong enough to protect myself.”
“I know you are,” I agreed immediately. “You’re the strongest person I know.”
“I can take care of myself.” That time, it sounded more like she was trying to convince herself, her pitch slightly wavering. Those large blue eyes were like twin pools of uncertainty watching me.
“You do, sweetheart. And I know you always will.” I stroked her cheek, not able to stop touching her soft, smooth skin. “I’ve just joined in. Now you can let me help take care of you, too.” My teeth flashed in a smile that didn’t quite reach my eyes, my heart still hurting from all the agony pouring off of her. “Teamwork makes the dream work, right?”
She gave a little snort, the sound adorable as fuck. My angel’s voice was soft and understanding, but it still didn’t deter me from my newest mission: figuring out who the fuck had sent that text. “I don’t need you to protect me, Finn. I just need you to not harm me.”
“Never.” I pressed a kiss to her tear-soaked cheek, her salty taste lingering on my lips when I pulled away.
That doubt lingered in her gaze as she sucked her plump bottom lip into her mouth, nibbling on it out of nervous habit. Usually she kept the walls up high, but the weight of the night must have finally cracked them. She wasn’t just overthinking the worst anymore; she was giving those ugly doubts a seat at the table.
“I’m still convinced you’re going to end up hurting me.” Her voice was quieter, like she was scared to even admit her fears to herself. “Nobody stays forever.”
“I’ll be your nobody then, since I’m convinced that you’re what the rest of my life looks like.” I didn’t miss a beat in my response, her gasp ringing through the quiet, dark apartment as I pressed a kiss to her cheek. “And for the record,” I murmured against her skin, my heart swelling with fierce heat. “I’m so fucking proud of you for saying that out loud. I know how scared you are of letting those walls down, but you’re doing it, Scar. You’re letting me in.
“Now, please tell me what I have to do to make these tears stop. They’re tearing me apart, baby.” Swiping at her wet face, I sighed, “Angels aren’t supposed to cry this much.”
“You’re slightly deranged.” She shook her head from my grasp but I could see that smile beginning to peek through, like the sun breaking through the clouds after a thunderstorm.
So heart-wrenchingly beautiful.
“Is this really all worth it for you?” Scarlett leaned back into the pile of blankets, her oversized sleeves now covering her hands as she crossed her arms. Her pert roman nose was scrunched in confusion. “It just seems like you’re doing all of the work and I’m just ...” she flung her hand, the sleeve of the sweatshirt flying. “... Here.”
As if I would want her anywhere else? I internally snorted.
“There’s no such thing as a perfect relationship, Scarlett,” I shrugged nonchalantly, though the chaotic pulse in my chest was anything but. “Real relationships do take work and I’m more than willing to work for it—day and night, ‘round the clock, no breaks, no fucking overtime pay, baby. I don’t care as long as I get to call you mine at the end of every day. I’ll do whatever it takes to keep you, to get to love you.”
She gasped again, the L word making her azure eyes flare. She sat up in her seat, that magnetic pull between us too strong for even her to fight. “Scarlett, I’d pick your hailstorm and thunder, I’d pick your rain over anyone else’s sunshine. All I ask is that you let me love you the way you deserve to be loved.”