51
MATTHEW
—War of Hearts
by Ruelle
I feel like the universe is laughing at my expense.
Because there’s no reasonable explanation for how I could finally find something good with the man who ticks nearly every box I never even realized I had—only to discover that he’s a fucking liar who entered my life because he was hired to kill me.
The strange and surprising thing is, getting over the fact that Anthony is a killer was easy (which probably says something deeply concerning about me that I have no intention of examining too closely right now). I mean, I’ve technically joined that rank myself, haven’t I? Granted, my body count is considerably less impressive—and I would like to keep it that way—but I can hardly sit on some moral high horse about murder when I recently put a bullet through my own father’s skull.
No. It’s the lying that keeps doing my head in.
The surveillance, the GPS on my phone, the recording device in my room . . . all those months of friendship where I thought I was getting to know him naturally when he already knew things about me I had never chosen to share. And then add “Ghost” on top of everything else, because apparently deceiving me as one person was not ambitious enough for Anthony Benson.
Every time I start convincing myself that I understand why he did some of it, another detail comes back and pisses me off all over again.
And despite all of that, I still love the asshole.
Yeah.
Surprised me too.
I have spent the last few weeks being furious with him, ignoring every message he sent and telling myself that the anger would eventually burn through whatever feelings I have for him. Except the asshole has lodged himself somewhere too deep—because the anger stayed and so did the love, entwined with each other and sending me out of my fucking mind.
Which is why I’m now inside Macaulay House, riding the elevator up to our floor like the emotionally compromised idiot I am.
The truth is, I’m still very fucking mad at Anthony. But I also miss him so much that pretending otherwise has become exhausting. At some point, I have to accept that I’m the fool who fell in love with someone as spectacularly unhinged as him.
But I’ve also seen the parts of Anthony most people probably never get too close to see. I’ve seen him vulnerable. I’ve watched him lose that frightening control of his because of me.
And as Marcus pointed out, in Anthony’s own extremely misguided and occasionally criminal way, he genuinely cares about me.
That doesn’t erase what he did, though, and it does not magically make the lies acceptable. I’m certainly not about to arrive at his door and reward him for basic character growth by pretending the last few weeks never happened. I’ve made it very fucking clear how badly he hurt me, and judging by the increasingly desperate messages he has been blowing up my phone with, I’m fairly certain the message has been received.
Possibly with emotional damage.
Good. He deserves some.
And when I strip away the anger to really think about everything that happened, there’s one truth I keep coming back to.
Someone else could have taken that assignment, spent those months getting close to me, learning the way I think and the things I like, listening to me talk too much and watching me become comfortable enough to trust them. And when my father finally gave the order, that person could have killed me without hesitating.
But Anthony didn’t kill me.
He was given every opportunity to finish the job he was paid for, and instead he turned against the man who hired him, put himself between me and a bullet, and made it clear that keeping me alive is more important to him than everything else.
I am alive today because of Anthony.
I step out of the elevator, barely making it two paces before I see Anthony coming out of his room with a traveling bag in one hand and Victor beside him. The sight of him strikes me dumb, and I forget I’m supposed to be angry.
My breath hitches the moment my eyes land on him. He looks terrible; his face is ashen, his hair more disheveled than I have ever seen it, and he looks exhausted, which makes it obvious the last three weeks haven’t exactly been kind to him either. But none of that makes him any less attractive, and lust rushes through me so quickly that I almost feel dizzy.
Sorry, not sorry. I’m still a man at the end of the day, and unfortunately for my pride, the man I’m hopelessly in love with also happens to look devastating even when he looks like he hasn’t slept properly in weeks.
Anthony stops dead the instant he sees me, and for a few seconds, neither of us moves. His eyes drag slowly over me from head to toe before coming back to my face, his expression hanging somewhere between disbelief and something so raw that it makes my chest ache, like he’s afraid that if he moves too quickly, I might disappear before he reaches me.