Matthew shot his father.
48
ANTHONY
—Heavydirtysoul
by twenty one pilots
There is no reality, no alternate version of this night, no outcome where I had ever considered Matthew being the one to kill his father.
The whole room settles into a strange stillness, all of us collectively holding our breaths. My eyes remain fixed on Matthew because I need to see what this has done to him, need to know whether reality is already beginning to sink in.
But he doesn’t look horrified, and he certainly doesn’t look broken.
If anything, he looks relaxed.
His shoulders have lowered, some of the tension has drained from his face, and there’s something peaceful in his stance that I haven’t seen in him since this entire nightmare began. It’s like a weight he has been carrying for so long—that he forgot it was there—has finally been lifted from him.
He’s free.
I look at Marcus, expecting grief to hit him differently, expecting him to shout or collapse or at least look at the body of the man he spent most of his life admiring—instead, he walks straight to Matthew, gently takes the gun from his hand, and cups his face between his palms.
“I’m your father now, okay?” Marcus says, his voice steady despite everything. “I’m not perfect, but I’ll do a better job than him.”
Matthew nods, and the moment Marcus pulls him close, he folds into his brother and wraps his arms around him tightly. “I love you, Marc.”
“I love you, too.” Marcus drops a kiss on the top of his head. “Come, let’s go back to New York. We have to figure out how to clean this up and what to release to the public later.”
“I’ll take care of the cleanup,” Victor offers.
“I’m coming with you,” I say. “We need to talk.”
The words leave my mouth, and I hear how they sound. Great, now I sound like Solomon fucking Bucknor. I already know Matthew is going to reject the idea vehemently, but my heart still shatters when he speaks.
“The fuck you are,” he snaps, glaring at me.
“Matthew,” Marcus says, turning to his brother. “You should listen to him. In his own misguided way, I think he really cares for you. How about we all go to the island, and I’ll stay in the resort there, maybe say hello to Rita in the morning? If you still want to come to New York after, you can come with me.”
Matthew nods, and the three of us leave the house once we have our phones back, leaving Victor and his men behind to deal with the blood and bodies.
There’s a different helicopter waiting on the helipad now, occupying the same space where Victor and I landed earlier, and we climb inside without speaking. Matthew takes the seat beside his brother, putting Marcus between us.
“Thanks for calling me,” Marcus says once we’re seated, and then he turns to Matthew. “I had no idea any of this was happening. When you returned to the States, he told me you were in boarding school and wanted to be close to Aunt Becky.”
Matthew only nods and then rests his head against his brother’s shoulder, closing himself off from everything else around him, but I can still feel the hatred coming off him and I don’t need him to look at me to know exactly where I stand.
And maybe there’s no point in trying. Maybe the best thing I can do now is take my bag, leave Pinehaven, and go to Ethiopia for a while to stay with my mother and sister until I figure out what the hell comes next.
Distance has always been easier for me than explanations.
Disappear. Reset. Take another job. Keep moving.
If I tell Victor I want to start working with him again, I doubt he would object. The flight back to Pinehaven is short, but tonight, every minute seems stretched by silence, by the fact that Matthew hasn’t looked at me once. When the island finally appears beneath us, the dark water surrounding the lights of the marina, I feel something unfurl in my chest.
Home.
That is what Pinehaven has become because of Matthew.