This time, I’m not imagining it—Anthony’s shoulders do stiffen, but his expression stays neutral.
“If that’s what you want.”
We return to our rooms without talking about it again. I go into my shower, standing under the hot water while trying very hard not to revisit the view from the bench press. By the time I’m dressed and flop onto my couch, I feel marginally cleaner, but no less restless.
A few minutes later, my door opens, and Anthony steps inside. He has already showered and changed, too, but there’s something strange about him.
There’s tension in his jaw, and his shoulders look stiff beneath his shirt. I watch him cross the room, but instead of sitting beside me, he stops directly in front of the couch. I tilt my head back to look at him. His mouth is moving but I hear none of it.
“Sorry, say that again?”
He looks like repeating himself physically hurts. “Don’t go to the gay club.”
My entire brain stops.
That is definitely not what I expected to hear. Anthony has never told me who I can or cannot sleep with. He barely asks about my sex life unless I bring it up first, and even then, most of his responses have been dry comments, jokes, or expressions that I interpreted as “Straight Man Confusion” rather than judgment.
Over the last six months, his guard has definitely come down around me, and I know he’s more comfortable with affection, more willing to stay close, more likely to touch me casually without immediately finding some reason to move away.
The first thing my mind comes up with is that he has been pretending he doesn’t have a problem with me being gay. Maybe every story about my hookups made him uncomfortable, and he only tolerated it because he liked me as a friend.
“Why?” I ask, because I need to know.
I really, really need to know, and at the same time, I’m terrified of hearing the answer because while I can handle being rejected by Ghost, I can’t stand to lose Anthony.
“I’m going to tell you something,” he says slowly, and his voice sounds wrong. “And it’s going to make you mad. I don’t have an explanation that’s going to make it okay, but I do hope you can forgive me.”
Whatever horny little problem I had in the gym disappears, replaced by my skyrocketing pulse. His hand is shaking when he dips it into his pocket, and there’s a mask in it when his hand comes back out.
I fly off the couch because I know that mask. I know the shape, the thornlike design, the curve around the eyes and cuts across the upper part of a face I have spent months trying to imagine. I have looked up at those exact eyeholes while Ghost fucked me into my mattress.
My first thought is that Anthony did something to Ghost, and that’s probably why he deactivated his account.
“How did you get that?” I ask, jabbing a finger toward it.
Anthony takes one slow breath before answering. “I bought it some months ago.”
Understanding crashes through me, and my knees suddenly feel shaky, and almost as quickly as I had jumped to my feet, I drop back to the couch.
Anthony is Ghost.
37
MATTHEW
—STUD by Troye Sivan
I cannot believe I have been sleeping with Anthony all this time while trying to curb my attraction to him because I didn’t want my straight friend to be uncomfortable around me. Anger hits me first, followed by lust, and then disbelief—but on top of all that, there’s also something so close to excitement.
I’ve had my tongue inside Anthony’s ass. Oh my fucking God.
“But you’re straight?” I manage to ask, although my voice is barely above a whisper.
He gives a small shrug. “Maybe I’m not as straight as I thought. I’m sorry for tricking you like that.”
Right. Yes. The lying. I should focus on that instead of replaying what his cock felt like while I unknowingly stared at my friend’s masked face.
“That’s fucked up, man. This is so messed up. All the times I was talking to you about Ghost, and you are him!” My voice has more strength, rising to a pitch I can’t control. “If you wanted to explore, you could have told me. I was eye-fucking you half of the time and then chastising myself for doing that the other half.”