That’s the beauty of loopholes. While Macaulay told me to report if Matthew became sexually involved with another man, he never said anything about what happens if that man is me, and I see no reason to correct an omission that currently works in my favor.
Not that we were sexually involved.
I’m not even gay.
Matthew hands me the beer. “It should be ready in a bit,” he informs me.
“What are you cooking?”
“Rice and stew.”
He picks up his phone from the coffee table and checks the screen. The brightness on his face dulls as he locks the phone and drops it back onto the table.
I don’t know what’s changed, but for some strange reason, his disappointment bothers me. I suppose I can understand if someone gives you a taste of something you enjoy, only to take it away without explanation.
“You’re expecting a text?” I ask before I can stop myself.
Something guarded crosses his face, and I expect him not to say anything. Instead, he seems to make some decision internally and sits beside me on the couch, leaving a little space between us.
17
ANTHONY
—Quit by Cashmere Cat
feat Ariana Grande
“Okay,” Matthew says. “There’s something you should know about me.”
I take a sip of the beer. “Is this a coming-out thing? Because it’s not exactly breaking news that you aren’t attracted to women.”
“Fuck you.” He lets out a genuine laugh this time, and it’s better than the smile he’s been wearing all afternoon. “Was it that obvious?”
“I’ve known you for two months, and I’ve never seen you check out a woman’s ass.”
“I haven’t seen you check out anyone’s ass either.”
“I’ve checked out plenty of asses.”
He gives me a skeptical look, and the stupidity of this conversation isn’t lost on me. He’s so trusting that he just believes I figured out his sexuality. It would be charming if trust weren’t such a dangerous habit. It really would be a waste when—if—I eventually have to kill him.
“So, you’re okay with me being gay?” he asks.
There’s caution in his voice, and it makes me lower the beer and look at him. “Why wouldn’t I be okay?” I don’t expect him to be nervous about sharing with me that he likes men. “We are what we are, and there’s no changing that. I sure am not one to judge anyone.”
I have never spent any meaningful amount of time thinking about who other people sleep with. As long as it’s not interfering with my money, it has nothing to do with me. Morality around sex has always seemed especially pointless. People will tolerate corruption, theft, cruelty, and then become offended because two consenting adults are touching each other. That seems backward. I kill people for money—it would be ridiculous if I sat here pretending I have found the moral high ground because a man likes dick.
If anything, from a purely selfish perspective, I want more men to be gay. Every man interested exclusively in other men is one less man competing with me for women, which improves the odds for the rest of us.
Matthew’s shoulders loosen slightly, and that tiny physical change tells me he’s been made to expect antagonism. I already know his father doesn’t accept him. What I don’t know is how much damage the expectation has done or how deeply it reached into the rest of his life.
“Anyway, that app I was telling you about,” Matthew continues. “I matched with someone, had one super-hot encounter with him, and now he’s basically ghosted me. I just don’t know what went wrong.”
I take another drink from the beer and make sure my face stays neutral. “Maybe you should forget him.”
Matthew lets out a long sigh and sags deeper into the cushions. “That’s the problem. I’ve tried, trust me, but it was such an unforgettable experience.” He glances at me briefly. “The thing is, I have some particular tastes, and I couldn’t do them properly with my ex. But with this guy, it’s the closest thing to perfect I’ve ever experienced.”
I keep my attention on the bottle in my hand instead of his face. “So, find another match then. There should be someone else on this island you can stick your dick into, or is it the other way? Or start a friends-with-benefit thing with Owen.”