The night only got better when I went back to scope out the different dessert stations and found a single piece of strawberry cheesecake left on a platter. I didn’t remember desserts from my life before Weston, so I carefully put it on my tray and practically floated back to the boys’ table.
Jack was the only one missing during dinner. Cole and Miles were in a heated debate about which hockey team had the best mascot, while Roman was busy on his phone, so I settled in next to Ezra with my prize. He caught sight of my cheesecake, and his eyes grew to the size of saucers.
“What’s wrong?” I asked, alarmed. The dessert looked fine to me.
He quickly typed on his phone before sliding it over to me.
Ezra
They have cheesecake today? Which station?
I winced. “I think this was the last one? I’m sorry.”
Ezra’s face dropped, and I immediately felt bad as he slid his phone next to his tray.
Roman snorted across the table, catching my attention. He nodded toward Ezra. “Cheesecake is his favorite. He’d eat it for every meal if he could.”
Ezra stuck his tongue out at Roman before pushing his last few bites of broccoli away. I hid a smile at their antics. They acted more like brothers than friends—not that I would really know the difference.
I remembered how easily Cole had offered me pretzels and how frequently the boys shared food. I bit my lip, eyeing the slice of cheesecake before tapping my finger next to Ezra’s phone. He looked up, and I swallowed for courage.
“Do you want to share it?” I asked softly.
Ezra’s eyes lit up, two molten pools of amber, and he nodded so enthusiastically I couldn’t stifle a small laugh before sliding the plate between us. I could feel eyes on me as Ezra dug into the dessert, but a glance over my shoulder didn’t show any of the football team watching us. Looking back at our table, my eyes met Roman’s piercing grey gaze.
He sipped his soda, not breaking his stare, and I forced myself to hold it in return. When he lowered the can, one corner of his mouth lifted in a slight smile. It was barely visible to the naked eye, but I found myself returning it.
He dipped his chin in a slight nod. “I heard you stood up for Ezra in that fight yesterday. Thanks for that.”
Him saying those words surprised me so much that I had to remind myself to breathe.
“He stood up for me, too,” I said, feeling unworthy of any praise. After what happened last night, I’d almost forgotten about the fight after art class. Besides, I hadn’t done anything more than Ezra, and I’d gladly get another black eye if it meant helping him. I gingerly touched the top of my cheek where the bruising started, but the swelling had already gone down, and my eye mostly felt numb now. “I’m just glad we weren’t hurt too badly.”
Roman grunted. He looked away and drank more soda as I let out a long breath.
Jack finally arrived as I took a bite of delicious fluffy cheesecake, and he slumped into the open spot next to Roman with a frown. The bags under his eyes were more pronounced, like he’d gone a week without sleep since I last saw him.
“What’s wrong?” I asked, drawing the other boys’ attention. “Did Dalton do something else?”
Jack rubbed a hand down his face, planted his elbows on the table, and offered me a tight-lipped smile. “It wasn’t him. I just ran into Elswood and had a little chat about the hazing. It didn’t go how I thought it would.”
I swallowed. A shiver raced down my spine at the reminder I’d be talking to the headmaster again tomorrow morning. Any meeting put my secret at risk. “What does that mean? What will happen?”
“Apparently, Cromwell and Rhodes are two of Weston’s golden children.” Jack sighed. “Their families are loaded and have more ties to the school board than the rest of us combined. There’s no way they’ll get more than a slap on the wrist for what happened.”
I scowled. That jerk was basically untouchable? My heart dropped into my stomach, and when I looked over at Ezra, he was staring off into space and tugging on his earlobe.
I scrambled to find a silver lining. “But that doesn’t mean he’d expel us instead, right? We didn’t do anything wrong. I mean—yes, we snuck into Elswood’s office—but that was for a tradition. The headmaster loves traditions.”
Jack smiled and plucked a roll off Roman’s plate. “I think he’s still more concerned about the fight in the hallway, honestly. The fact you got a few good hits in on Cromwell—even though they were in self-defense—gives Elswood an argument that it wasn’t just a case of bullying. He might claim you were fighting instead of trying to protect yourselves and get away. I don’t know what to expect, but the headmaster seems like a decent enough guy. Just tell him the truth tomorrow, and you should be okay.”
I chewed on my lip. That was the problem—I didn’t want to talk to Elswood. He’d just warned me a few days ago that seeing each other again so soon was a bad sign, and then he’d caught me in his office, trying to steal his underpants. Clasping my hands to hide their shaking, I struggled to get ahold of my thoughts before they snowballed into full-blown panic. Would I have to leave? Would Elswood make me go back to Pennsylvania?
I’d just gotten here.
A tap on my shoulder jolted me, and I jerked so far off the bench that I teetered over the edge. I grabbed the table before I could fall off, heart racing as I righted myself.
Ezra’s eyes widened beside me, and he slowly pulled his hand back.