Jack appeared on screen. “The day we recorded Finally Home it was a thousand degrees in Nashville and I just wanted to get home to my swimming pool. Regardless, I’d looked forward to seeing Ivy again. I’d thought she was about the prettiest thing I’d ever seen the first few times I met her but I didn’t think much of it. I had no idea I’d fall in love with her in that booth. In my defense, she later jumped into my pool wearing this cute but very small bikini and I was done for. I mean, c’mon. I’m only human.” Jack paused, nodding to whatever Blake had asked. “Yeah, you bet. Rhett and I both have swimming pools at our homes now. And yes, I think of the four of us outside that community pool wishing we could jump in that cool water instead of sweating through our cheap clothes every time I jump in the deep end. I bet Rhett would tell you the same thing.”
Holly appeared on the screen. “That’s how the idea for the dance contest came about. Rhett and I got it in our heads we were going to win the dance contest and be able to get us all into the swimming pool the rest of the summer.”
“Spoiler alert. We didn’t win,” Rhett said in the film, shaking his head. “But we gave it a good try.”
“We were spectacular,” Holly said.
The next scene was an excerpt of them dancing at the talent show.
There was another bit with Ivy talking about Jack’s marriage proposal and the ring that fell in the creek. “We had to dive down to find it. Took us a bit. But my Jack wouldn’t have left until he found it. That’s the way he is. You don’t leave a diamond in the creek. Kind of like he didn’t want to leave without getting Daddy’s permission. He’s old-fashioned. Sweet as can be. And it was my fault the darn ring slipped into the creek. That’s the kind of man you want. One who’ll dive into deep water when you need him to.”
There was a montage of the wedding, with Finally Home playing under it. White lights and glowing lanterns. Grant escorting Carol down the aisle. Ivy hanging onto her father’s arm as she walked down the aisle, then a close up of Jack’s face as he waited for her, crying. Their first kiss as man and wife.
Finally Home ended as we moved to the reception and a shot of Jack dancing with his mother to Mamas Don’t Let Your Babies Grow Up to Be Cowboys. We could hear Rhett calling out “Too late,” followed by Luci shouting, “You tried, Mama.”
The narrative moved to Knox sitting in the interview chair with his guitar. He talked about getting it when he was ten, about listening to records with his Gramps. He went on to say how much his grandfather had meant to him and that he’d taught Knox how to be a good man. The Compass came on for a second or two before fading so the audience could hear Knox talking. “But Gramps said, don’t you let them talk you small, kid. You’ve got something. You go on and dream past this place.”
Then it was Grant again, talking about his teacher, Mr. Ferris. “He said I had a few unique qualities that he’d seen in drummers before. A combination of listening skills with physicality. I was this athletic, tall kid, even at ten, always moving. And he was right, I’m innately more of a listener than a talker. He was also the first person who said I was good at something. Made me want to do better as a way to thank him. Please him too, I guess.”
The screen changed to Ivy reading a seven-year-old Luci’s request for a science kit, then the postscript about a dollhouse. Jack’s letter asked Santa to bring his sister’s present instead of his. Holly didn’t need anything. Not really.
Not really.
I didn’t know if I’d heard that the first time, but it struck me now.
Back to the letters to Santa. Rhett knew there was no Santa. Grant’s letter was four lines long. “Please don’t tell my dad.” My request for headphones followed. Then Ivy’s own letter, the girl who thought she was dumb but remembered to ask Santa to bring something for Mama. Blake cut to June, listening that night, with Gus’s hand resting over hers.
I’d heard the letters on the eleventh as ten separate childhoods. Put beside one another, they kept bringing me back to our mothers. What they could afford. What they’d gone without. What we’d tried to make easier for them, or tried to hide. Even my headphones had been a way of keeping peace with mine.
On screen, Carol appeared at a table by a window. A cup sat beside her elbow, untouched. Someone passed behind the camera, and her eyes followed them, checking whether she was needed elsewhere. Then she settled back in her chair and gave Blake her attention. “What I remember from those days? I was tired. And worried. That knot in my stomach was there when I went to sleep and there when I woke up. I couldn’t imagine how I was going to keep any of my kids fed and clothed. That includes Rhett. Even before his mother passed away, he was mine. I didn’t have much money but I had plenty of love for this sweet, smart little boy.”
Then Jack was in the barn on the sixteenth, singing Mama’s Song. The camera found Carol in the audience singing along to every word.
Cut to Jack in the interview chair. “You want me to talk about my mother? It would take all month to tell you all the sacrifices she made for us. None of this would’ve happened without her. She downplays how amazing she was. Always has. But she’s the one who told me, ‘being poor don’t mean you’re bad.’ I carried that with me, you know, through the hard years when we first moved to Nashville. And now she reminds me to stay humble, to remember where I came from without feeling ashamed. I sometimes think she needs to hear the same message.”
Next, we returned to the interview room, with Ivy in the chair. “My Mama? Well, she’s an angel on this earth. Everyone who knows her will tell you that. She’s my hero. I want to be just like her, but I have a ways to go before that. And yes, she adores Jack. Calls him an answer to prayer. Which is true. I don’t know who was praying harder for him to finally appear, me or Mama.” On screen, Ivy grew somber. “Mama never gave up on me or let me believe I was stupid. You want to know who she is? Listen to my song about her. She’s the one who told me it’s okay to just be myself and ignore the haters.” She sang a few lines from the song, “Don’t You Believe That Lie.”
“Baby, here’s the thing—
The birds don’t read their music,
But listen when they sing.”
More of Ivy—probably answering Blake’s questions even though we couldn’t hear her voice. “Before Jack, I didn’t really talk about my troubles with reading, but I have pretty severe dyslexia. I don’t usually share this, but I can’t read music. It all just lives inside of me. Just like Mama told me. I simply had to listen to my own voice. Since I met Jack, I’ve started feeling comfortable about sharing my own truth. He pointed out that talking about it might help others. That’s who he is, you know. He makes me a better person.”
Ivy nodded on the screen, then answered another question, smiling. “Yes, it’s funny about sharing a similar line in our songs about our mothers. They both told us not to believe the lies people told us about being poor or stupid. Our mothers are similar in that way. As far as the songs go, we wrote them before we knew each other and they released around the same time. I’d not heard his song until after mine was released. I figure it’s just God’s way of pointing out the truth. We belong together.”
On screen, Jack was at the microphone once more. “This one’s written by Beck Reed.” The first notes of I Saved You a Seat sounded.
Jack sang my song—the painful story about the fractured relationship with my mother. His voice had that ache and heartbreak that I’d felt when I wrote it. The camera stayed wide enough to keep me and the piano in view.
Next came a shot from one morning at breakfast, with Grant talking about his mother. “I was surprised to find out she’d saved my letter to Santa. Ivy later told me she’d kept boxes of my things, including newspaper clippings about our shows. I had no idea. She never seemed like the sentimental type. My dad was rough on me. Lots of grueling physical tests that were supposed to build character. I left home bitter, I guess you’d say. Haven’t looked back much but am starting to wonder if I should.”
Next a moment with Rhett. “Carol Wilder? She’s my mother. No question. Without her, I’d have been utterly lost. I’d probably either be a drunk or in prison.”
Then another bit of Rhett, talking about Jack. “I have a philosophy about life. Anything that scares you—probably what you should be doing. Built my whole life around that concept.” On screen, Rhett looked up at the ceiling before returning his gaze to the camera. “He asked me how the heck we were going to afford to get there. I was working two jobs. I told him we’d find a way. When you grow up like we did and you find a friend like Jack, you become a ‘we.’”
Another montage, with You Heard What I Couldn’t playing. An image of Jack and Rhett at the reception, embracing. Rhett dancing with Carol. Jack nailing Rhett with a snowball. Jack Wilder and the Strays playing at the church in Blue Fern, with a shot of Rhett’s face as he watched. Blake and me sharing a blanket under the stars. A shot of the full moon and then Knox and Madeleine kissing under its glow. Grant and Luci at Helen’s Handknits, heads bent as they looked at something on the table. Holly and Rhett making snow angels. Ivy sitting on Jack’s lap around the campfire.