I hesitate, weighing all the ways I could answer. Ultimately, I decide for the full truth.
“I couldn’t live with myself if my actions were to affect someone I love again.”
Surprise flits across her face, and just like that, I have her full attention. Perhaps this is how I do it. If only for a brief moment, I can give her a glimpse of the man she never got to know.
“There’s an event coming up this weekend, as you’ve probably heard,” I say. “It’s hosted by a local romance bookstore in British Columbia, and up until now, I was working with them. I had to step away because of this controversy, but I doubt that’ll be enough to appease the critics. A lot of people there are counting on the success of this event. The whole town is invested. They’ve poured so much of themselves into this. I can’t be the reason it all falls apart.” I shake my head. “I can’t, Amy. I need to fix this.”
Leaning over the table, I lace my fingers and clear my throat.
“You have every right to be skeptical of me. You don’t know me anymore. But I can tell you who I am now, and you can make up your mind afterward.” I inhale deeply and go for it. “I coach a girls’ rugby team at the local elementary school. They have more spunk in their little fingers than I have in my entire body, and I love every second of it. I’ve been sober for over a year. I’ve made new friends, and they’ve welcomed me into their homes like I’ve been part of their lives forever. Friends who count on me. Friends I want to rely on.”
I pick up my water and take a sip, soothing my dry throat.
“And there’s Lola. She owns that bookstore.” And my whole fucking heart, but I keep that thought to myself. “She staked everything on this event. I don’t want her to suffer because of the terrible mistakes I made in the past.” I hold her gaze. “So I’m begging you, Ames. Please, help me make things right.”
Lowering my head, I exhale a long, trembling breath.
Miles clasps my shoulder and squeezes once.
Seconds tick by, and when I force myself to look at my ex-wife again, the rest of her mask has slipped away.
“Okay,” she whispers. “I’ll help.”
My heart thunders in my chest. “You will?”
She holds up one hand. “But I need you to pay me for my share of the house, Tyler. It’s been hanging between us for too long. I want it gone.” She peers down at her belly and rests her hand on top of the curve. “Look…” she says, her voice breaking.
Her brown eyes lift to mine, and for a moment, I feel like I’m staring at the Amy I met in high school. The Amy I married. The woman who’d cheer for me at every game and hadn’t yet been scarred by all the shit we’ve endured.
“I’m glad you’re moving on,” she says. “I want that for you, but I want that for me too. A lot of the years we spent together were some of the best of my life, and I’ll always look back on them fondly. You’re the boy who taught me how to love, who made my heart race and my stomach flutter. You never forget your first love. And we’ve been through a lot since then, haven’t we?”
She lets out a wet laugh, and I do too.
“Yeah, we have.”
“But some of those years were also the most painful I’ve ever experienced, and I need to turn the page on that chapter of my life.” Her lips tremble, and she swallows. “When we got back together, I think I already knew. Somewhere in the back of my mind, I knew we’d been over for a while, but I refused to admit it to myself. I couldn’t let you go. And I’m sorry for that. For holding on to our history, to who we used to be, instead of accepting that we’d grown too far apart. It wasn’t fair to either of us.” She drops her gaze for a second before meeting mine again. “I need to heal. And I can’t do that with that house hovering over me.”
“I understand,” I rasp.
I exhale, something finally giving way in my chest. We should’ve had this conversation a long time ago. Or maybe we weren’t ready for it back then, when our pain was still too raw. But sitting here with her, listening to her, sharing what’s been weighing on me too… I needed it more than I thought. Proper closure for both of us.
“Would you be open to selling it?” I ask. “If I handle all of it, I mean.”
Amy frowns. “You don’t want to keep it anymore?”
“No, I don’t. I think…” I inhale through my nose. “Like you said. It’s time to move on.”
A smile tugs at her lips. “Look at us, agreeing on something again.”
“Who’d have thought?” I chuckle, though I school my features quickly. “Thank you, Ames. You don’t know what this means to me.”
“I’m happy to learn you have someone in your corner.” Her smile grows pensive. “She’s one lucky girl.” And then she turns to Miles and Riley. “What do you need from me?”
Chapter Twenty-Four
LOLA
Iwake up Friday morning with a migraine and my phone lying next to my pillow, dead.