I wait for him to elaborate. When he bares his teeth in a sheepish look, my stomach flips again, but not in a good way this time.
“So, I told you how thrilled Dad was about how he thought dinner went…” He pauses to let out a nervous laugh and then a defeated sigh.
Where is this going? Did I blow it? Has Martin found out that Dylan knows, and that we were just putting on a show?
“Well, ever since then he keeps asking me what ‘our’ plans are for the evening, and…and I cracked under the pressure!” He drops his face into his hands, elbows resting on my desk.
What does that mean?
Spreading his fingers, he peers through them. “He started looking worried, like there was trouble in paradise,” he whispers. Popping his head up, he glances over my cubicle wall to make sure we don’t have an audience, I presume. “I know our fake relationship was never supposed to exist after one dinner, but I…may have made up a fake hangout at your place the other day…”
Oh, shit. I guess we were more believable than I thought. And damn, Martin must really like me. Now is probably not the time to feel proud of that.
Scrubbing his hand down his face, Dylan slumps back in his chair and groans. “And then, I might have made up a fake trip to the movie theater two nights ago. By the way, it’s super awkward going to the movie theater by yourself. Everyone looks at you like you’re a serial killer or like you’re going to jump up at any moment and streak through the theater as soon as the lights go out.”
I get a mental image of Dylan eating popcorn alone and going home to report to Martin what we thought of the film. I barely survived one private conversation with the man; I have no idea how I’d not fold living under the same roof with him, for how enthusiastic he is about this idea of us being together.
“Shit,” I mutter unhelpfully.
Here I’ve been silently tooting my horn all week, convincing myself I did a good thing by helping Dylan out and feeding Martin’s pipe dream. All I managed to do was make things worse. I’m an idiot. Of course, a father that invested in his son’s happiness would want to follow up. What did I expect?
I’m about to suggest that Dylan tell Martin we didn’t work out, but picturing the last light in Martin’s eyes getting snuffed out is too depressing. Plus, what a big man that would make me, letting Dylan deal with all of that on his own. Somehow, pretending feels less despicable.
“Yeah.” Dylan concurs sullenly. “And…we have a fake hangout again tonight, but I’m kind of running out of places to go by myself since I don’t have any friends in Chicago. The two I had when I was in high school here moved out of the area.”
Double shit. He shouldn’t have to be spending what little time he has left with his dad by himself, pretending to have fake dates. That’s time he won’t get back.
“So, please don’t feel obligated or guilted into this, but if there’s a chance you actually might not mind hanging out for real tonight, it would help so I can at least feel like I’m not lying to him if I get to spend some time with you. That way I won’t have to make up anything you might have said.”
Oh… he wants to hang out? I guess that’s one solution.
Cringing, he holds his hand up next to his mouth and stage-whispers, “I’m terrible. I’m the worst. I know. I’m so sorry. I’ve created a monster, and it’s me. I’m the monster.”
It’s probably not an appropriate time to find humor in the situation, but I chuff at his endearing apology. I need to answer him. This is new territory for me, though. I’ve never had to make friendship decisions before. Riley always took the lead, which is probably why I nearly lost my shit when I was forced to make some without him. Staring at the anguish on Dylan’s face, however, it doesn’t seem burdensome.
“Do you want to—” God, I feel like an immature kid about to voice this, but I already know he’s good company and not likely to judge me, “—come over and game with me?”
“Are you serious? Like you’re not just saying that because you feel sorry for me or because my father and I guilted you into it with our weird brand of crazy?”
Did not expect him to light up like that. I feel forty percent less hopeless now. Maybe that’s what our friendship can be based on—being hopeless dorks together.
“No, it’s cool. It’s always better gaming with someone else, anyway. Right?”
“Yeah.”
He already has my address from picking me up for the expo last week, so I don’t need to write it down. I’m not sure if the strange prickling sensation running across my skin is nerves or giddiness over a night of gaming.
“What time?”
“Whenever is good. I go home right after work, so…”
“Okay. Cool. I’ll just run home and shower, and…you know, tell Dad I’m going to hang out with you.”
Whether it’s the way he fidgets with the paperclip again or that I understand how difficult it must have been to ask me for a hangout, my heart goes out to him. He’s made no bones about baring his soul to me, while I’m usually all up in my head.
“I, um, don’t really have any friends to game with or…in Chicago either. My best friend lost his vision in an accident, so he can’t play anymore. He used to work here, actually.”
“Riley?” He squints in thought. “The Olivia app guy?”