“Yes,” Mr. Smythe confirmed. “He’s inviting the two of you to a party in Newport, for Independence Day. Your mother too. You’ll be his houseguests. He wants to see the girl before he makes his final decision. But of course”—he glanced back at the door—“you and I know he won’t find an issue there.”
No, Isabelle thought. Daniel has not arranged this from heaven.
If only she could be as forthright as Mr. Smythe and offer herself in her daughter’s place. In a different world, under different rules, Isabelle could make an argument to protect Mariah. Take me instead, she could say. I’m not old yet. If it’s proven fertility you need? I’ve had four fat, rosy babies, each birth easier than the last. I’ve got years before I turn forty. My monthlies are as regular and readable as they ever were. Take me instead. I swear there will be a child within the year.
But her voice went ahead and spoke without her. “A party,” it said. “How lovely. Of course we’ll come.”
Mr. Smythe stood. “I’ll show myself out,” he said. “Details about travel to Newport will be sent along shortly.”
“Mr. Smythe,” Isabelle called out, as he reached the door. “Please tell Mr. Whitten I’m not going to say anything to Mariah just yet. About his proposal.”
“Surely not,” Smythe said. “Not until we know he’s agreed to her.”
He waited another beat for Isabelle to speak. She thought about remaining silent. But a lifetime of good manners was not easily overcome.
“Please extend my thanks to Mr. Whitten.”
Once he’d left, she moved to the window, no longer concerned about being seen. Mr. Smythe walked down the steps with a young man’s gait, as if his beloved had just accepted him.
Isabelle walked across the hall to the small study. From the secretary desk she pulled a ledger—something she’d never laid eyes on in all her life before Daniel died. He’d had a way of building fortunes and then losing them—betting on the newest best thing until it failed. They had taken a hit in the panic of 1893 but he managed to roar back, raising capital for a shipbuilding business. It had gone so well that when Jay Hopkins first showed up, with oil paint caked under his fingernails, Isabelle suspected him of fortune hunting. Jay came from a family of faded wealth who claimed—like so many New Englanders—to be Mayflower descendants.
“Mariah’s no target for a fortune hunter,” Daniel had said. Isabelle thought he was referencing Mariah’s beauty. Maybe if she’d pressed her husband, he would have admitted what estate lawyers had to explain. The shipbuilder had developed palsy and their business—like their life—was in ruins.
These past months she’d been so preoccupied with keeping Mariah’s condition a secret and dispatching the baby (she put a hand on her breast, remembering its soft damp head). Now the numbers in the ledger, their sharp rebukes, terrified her. What would they do when the money ran out? Isabelle was no better at earning a living than she was at concealing scandals.
If they found new ways to economize, there could be enough to live on for another month, maybe two. She had no more assets left to move, no jewelry left to sell; even her wedding ring was long gone. The only remaining object of value was Mariah, who’d been irretrievably tarnished.
Isabelle slammed the ledger shut. Mariah was lucky to have a family at all. Plenty of mothers would have disowned her. An uncountable number of young girls had survived marriages to old men, many with age gaps even wider.
Considered in a certain light it was the best possible opportunity. How lucky for them, that John Whitten’s eccentricities allowed for overlooking a blighted past. Right now, Mariah Bishop was penniless and ruined. If she became Mrs. John Whitten, she’d be one of the richest women in New York. Mariah would balk at first; an eighteen-year-old girl does not know what’s best for her, or her family. She could not imagine the perils of poverty, no more than Isabelle could, not really, even while it knocked so insistently on her door.
You can learn to love him, Isabelle would say. You can learn to be happy. And Mariah would have to believe her.
2.
Upstairs, Mariah lay across her bed wearing only a slip, her dress and corset flung to the floor. Bisou, her Yorkshire terrier, nestled under her chin. This had become Mariah’s habitual pose. When she’d been with child, stuck in this room to conceal her condition from the outside world, she assumed one day she would rejoin the living. But now, even with all traces of the baby gone, Mother would only let her leave the house to perform small errands or go for short walks. There was no social life for Mariah in Hoboken, no way to meet people or make friends her own age. She was not permitted to accompany her mother when she went to New York. She was not permitted to do anything.
To fill the hours she spent alone, Mariah wrote stories. She couldn’t control anything in the real world, but the page was hers to command. Every decision belonged to her. She wrote stories about boarding the Morrigan with the rest of her family, and stories where her family never boarded the Morrigan at all. Stories where a young girl was wooed by a deceiving young man but retained her virtue and with it her future. Stories where the young man—an artist—was not deceiving at all but married the girl and they lived together in a light-flooded garret. This morning Mariah had written a story about two sisters, one with dark hair and one redheaded, who came into an unexpected inheritance. They used it to buy a house in Cambridge and lived there together without ever worrying about marriage at all. They threw lavish parties and danced around bonfires. No one over the age of thirty was ever invited.
Mariah read this story from beginning to end, then sat up, lit a candle, and burned it a single page at a time. Otherwise, Granny—an incorrigible snoop—would uncover it and offer her critique. And it was oddly satisfying to watch each page curl till the ashes fell to the floor, the last ember biting her fingers before she shook the remaining scraps from her hands. This ritual had created hard, flat bubbles on the tips of her thumb and forefinger.
She went to the window and moved the curtains aside in time to watch Mr. Smythe hurry back to the waiting carriage. He moved quickly, like he couldn’t get away from them fast enough. He was only a secretary, but a visit to their house would likely represent the lowliest task of his week, if not his month. Or year.
Poor Mother. Mariah knew she had been pining to see John Whitten himself. She had probably imagined his arms full of flowers, lips full of proclamations of love. Mariah knew that kind of disappointment. She had stood at this very window for weeks, waiting for Jay.
The door opened without a warning knock. Mother’s face was full of color. She looked vulnerable, absent the simmering fury that had become her salient trait.
“He’s invited us to a party in Newport.”
“Oh. Mother.”
Mariah took a half step toward her, to see if she’d accept an embrace. Mother did not exactly welcome it but also did not move away. She felt so tiny in Mariah’s arms, as if she’d stopped eating. Mariah imagined her taking food from her own plate to give to her, and to Granny. It was terrible to think of her pretty young mother marrying an old man, or anyone apart from Mariah’s dashing father, who’d only been forty when he died. It flooded her with shame, that in the midst of her family’s dreadful misfortune, Mariah had found a way to make things even worse.
Bisou plopped to the floor and pranced around them with a celebratory flurry. Mariah stayed in Mother’s arms as long as she would allow it, which amounted to a few moments.
“Thank you,” Mariah said, when her mother stepped back. “I know this is for us. For Granny and me. I’m sorry.”
Mother lifted her hands to Mariah’s shoulders. “The party is in less than a month and there’s no money for new clothes.”