“Fuck, wait, wait,” I told him, trying to find some sense of balance inside of myself.
“Move, Graham,” he said breathlessly. “Fuck, I need you to move. Oh my god, you’re so fucking big.”
I laughed a little. “And you’re so fucking good,” I murmured, pressing my lips against his ear. I wanted to bite him, so I did, nibbling his earlobe as he whined. “Give me a second, just a little bit longer. I’m going to make it so good for you, I fucking swear, but I just need…”
His heel hit my ass, jolting me forward inside of him. We both gasped. “You need to move,” Colton said. It would have been funny if he didn’t sound so broken. “God, first man inside of me in years, and what does he want to do? Take his fucking time.”
Years? I was curious, but I didn’t ask. It wasn’t my business, and now wasn’t the time. The only thing I needed to concern myself with right now was fucking this incredible man. “You want me to move?” I whispered, then captured his mouth in a kiss before he could say the same thing again. I knew what he wanted. My pleasure had gone from a roar to a sweet, sharp ache in my groin. “I can do that,” I said, then pulled my hips back slow, so slow, so that he felt every inch of me pulling out of him. And when I pushed back in, ugh, the sounds he made were perfect—sensual and inarticulate, a desperate cry for me to give him what we both wanted so badly.
Still, I took it slow, exploring Colton’s reactions and how he responded to every push, every pull. I watched his smooth, pale skin darken, flushed with need. The head of his cock was almost purple, and so hard that it rubbed against my abdomen every time I thrust back inside.
“Faster,” he urged me. “Fuck, go faster, please, please.”
“What if I don’t want to go faster?” I teased him, keeping it slow and steady. The look of indignation on his face made me laugh.
“I think you do want to go faster,” he said firmly. “I think you want to fuck me harder.” He wound his arms around my shoulders and pulled me in close.
Our lips were just a millimeter apart as he said, “I think you want to come inside of me. You want to fill me the fuck up, you want to make me so full of your dick that I’m choking on it. Now fuck me like you mean it.”
Holy shit. The time for teasing was over. I pulled back and slammed back into his body, and the sound he made was music to my ears. I did it over and over again, tilting my hips just right so I managed to graze his prostate. The noise that came out of his mouth was broken, desperate, gorgeous. Colton squeezed his eyes shut and reached down for his cock, but I grabbed his wrist and pinned it back up by his head. “No touching.”
“I can’t come if I don’t touch.”
“Then maybe you don’t come yet,” I said, and…oh. His eyes went even darker, and his cock drooled the line of pre-cum onto his stomach. “Oh, you like that, don’t you?” I taunted him as I pounded into his ass as hard as I could while still leaving enough breath to speak. “You want me to make you cum on just this dick, don’t you?”
“I don’t think you can,” Colton said, and he might have been right. I didn’t know that I could last that long at this point.
Next time.
“Keep your hand up there,” I ground out, then let go of him and reached my own hand down to circle around his cock. Fuck, he felt so good. Touching him in the shower had been just a taste—now I was ready for both of us to finish.
Colton’s ass clenched around me again, and he began to pant. A second later, he came, ropes of white spurting all over his chest and belly, and that was it for me. I had already seen him through two orgasms, I couldn’t hold off any longer. I fucked in deeper once, twice. On the third, I stayed inside, as far as I could go, burying myself in him as I came, pulsing hard into the condom.
I wished I was actually coming inside him. I wished I could pull out, then touch him with my fingers and feel the evidence of my spent passion, but we didn’t know each other well enough for that.
Fuck it, it had been amazing anyway. I flopped down next to Colton after slowly withdrawing from his body so it didn’t hurt, and he rolled over and wrapped his arm around my waist, burying his face in my neck. It seemed like it had been pretty good for him too.
“Holy shit,” he said, after a few minutes of us lying in silence, no movement other than disposing of the condom. “That was fucking incredible.”
“Why, thank you,” I said.
“Yeah, don’t get too big a head about it,” he warned me, but he was smiling in a way I don’t think I had ever seen him smile before. It was carefree and made him look young.
I leaned over him, a little bit wary now that the urgency was diminished, and pressed a kiss to Colton’s mouth. To my delight, he didn’t push me away or tell me that wasn’t something he was into after the fact. He accepted it, pulled me closer, and opened his lips for me. We kissed for a long time, and when we finally stopped, it was just to sleep and not to part.
Something woke me up early in the morning—a creak, maybe some kind of groan. It sounded suspicious enough that I sat up in bed, but Colton grabbed my arm and pulled me back down next to him. “It’s the fron’ door,” he said, sleep-slurring his consonants a bit. “Don’t worry about it, it’s jus’ Anthony sneaking in.”
“Not a very good way to sneak in,” I commented as I lay down once more.
“Yeah, well, I don’t fix the door for a reason,” Colton replied, laying his head back on my chest as soon as I was down next to him. Warmth filled me as he nuzzled in close without any sign of having second thoughts or wondering if he’d be welcome. “It’s a way for me to keep track of him while still giving him some independence.”
“Independence is pretty important to him, huh?” I murmured, keeping my voice quiet as footsteps crept past the door.
“Mmm, yeah,” Colton said, and there was no mistaking the hint of sorrow in his voice now. “It’s hard for him. Anthony’s father is my older brother, and he, well.” Colton sighed. “Chris isn’t around anymore. He went to prison for dealing meth when Anthony was two, and the same day he got out three years later he died of an overdose.”
“Holy shit,” I said, not quite sure what to make of that. “Your brother was…a drug dealer?”
Colton laughed, and it wasn’t a very nice sound. “Among many other shitty things, yes, he was a drug dealer. He was a lot like our father, honestly. My grandfather, everybody knew about him, you know. Grandpa really did something with his life. He was great for this town, and he was a role model for a lot of people, but he wasn’t great at paying attention to his own family. He didn’t do such a good job with my dad, and my dad didn’t do a good job with us.”