Crap, I didn’t know Colton’s house was one of his options. If he chose it, then dinner was definitely off. “Yours, of course,” Anthony said.
Oh good.
Finally, Sunita and I made it back. She made a beeline for Jim, already talking him through the shots that she’d gotten, the pickups that would be needed, and the filming that still had to be done for the soap judging. I went straight to David, who was standing on Jim’s other side.
“Hey, Graham,” he said, beaming at me. David was such a friendly individual, but friendly in that earnest and genuine small-town way that you so rarely got hanging out in Hollywood. “I hear people had a lot of fun today out at Gloria’s.”
“They did,” I said, “most of them. It was a fun day.”
“Uh huh. And who didn’t have a good time?” he asked knowingly.
“Well, without getting into too much detail, let me just say that Colton had to do more than he should have.”
“Oh no.” David looked worried. “Did one of the dogs bite someone? I keep telling Gloria that those dogs need to be kenneled while she has people over—”
“No, no, no.” I shook my head to reassure him. “No, nothing like that. The dogs were perfect. It’s more that someone on our cast, uh, hopped into the wrong pen.”
“The wrong pen. What, you mean with Buster?” David laughed. “Who’d be dumb enough to get into the pen with Buster?” I arched an eyebrow, and a second later David nodded in understanding. “Oh right, Chazz.”
“Yeah. So anyway, it was kind of a rough day for Colton and I’d like to make it up to him. I was wondering if you could tell me whether he’s got a favorite drink or maybe a meal from a favorite restaurant I could bring him.” Wait, no, he was already cooking dinner. Damn.
David looked pensive for a moment. “You know, he does actually have a favorite beer. It’s a micro-brew though, and the liquor store in town doesn’t stock it. The only place I know that’s got it is fifty miles away.”
I glanced at my watch—yeah, I was old school enough to have a watch, plenty of my younger contestants looked at me like I was crazy for it. It was a little after five. It would probably take me an hour and a half to get there and back.
Was that too late to invite myself over for dinner? Was this actually a good idea? Did I even need to bother?
Yes, my conscience told the rest of me, and my libido agreed wholeheartedly. Yes, you need to do this. You need to show him that you appreciate his time. You need to show him that you’re sorry for your dumbass contestant and you need to prove to him that you’re interested. This is a good way of doing it. Talk is cheap. Action is important. “Can you tell me the name of the beer?” I asked David, and he beamed at me.
“I can do that.”
One hour and thirty-seven minutes later, I stood outside of the small, comfortable-looking home two minutes from downtown Paradise that belonged to Colton Jones. I held a six-pack of cans in my left hand and raised my right one to knock on his door—then I froze.
Shit. I didn’t want to push myself on him. Even now, coming with a peace offering, I felt like I might be doing something unwanted. Was this too much? Was I being one of those pushy people I loathed?
My doubts were almost enough to get me to lower my hand, but then, no. At the very least, he deserved an apology. I knocked firmly, ignored my sweating palm, and a few seconds later, the inner door opened. There was Colton, looking up at me with a curious expression on his face, as though he’d been scowling and then had suddenly been shocked out of it.
“What are you doing here?”
I held up the six-pack. “I come in peace,” I said, trying to be cute and probably not succeeding. “I asked around and found out this is your favorite. I wanted to, you know, apologize for my naughty contestant from earlier, so I thought I’d bring you some naughty beer.” I wasn’t just being stupid. The beer was literally called Naughty Marilyn. Don’t ask me why, I didn’t understand why microbrews did what they did.
But when Colton’s eyes landed on it, he actually smiled. Not a big smile, but a pleased, almost shy little curve of his lips. “Where did you get that?” he asked.
“Oh, about two miles from Vale,” I said with a shrug that I hoped came off as nonchalant.
“You drove to Vale to get me beer?”
“Yeah, I did. Although maybe I also drove to Vale to get me beer. You ever think of that?” I said.
Colton smirked and leaned his hip against the door. God, he was good looking. Once you got past the slightly snarly exterior, there was nothing about this man that wasn’t attractive to me, from the length of his hair—just long enough that you could really imagine running your fingers through it and getting a good glide—to the firm, take-no-shit things he said.
“And if you’re not interested in sharing tonight, that’s fine too,” I continued. “I’m not here to push myself on you, you got plenty of that at Gracie’s place. Which I’m really sorry for, by the way,” I added. “I just hoped that we could spend some time together.”
There, I’d put it out there. Now it was up to him to say yes or no. Either way, I didn’t think I was going to be done with Colton, but if he said no tonight, I’d have to ease up, back off, and pump the brakes a little more.
“Get in here,” he said, and opened the screen door for me and gave me one of those beers.
I smiled. “You got it, coach.”