I think of Aubrey telling us about how the bodies burned differently.
“The fire didn’t kill Madeline,” I say. “That’s not Sian’s fault.”
Gwen’s mouth twists.
“Yes, it was,” she says emphatically. “If she’d not tried to cast her spell and intervene then the ritual would have worked and Madeline would not have…have been hurt by the mirror.”
“And mother’s necklace around Sian’s dead neck? That was her own fault too, was it?”
For the first time, Gwen looks guilty.
“I needed you to stop looking. I needed to disappear. Though it tore me to part with it.” She blinks angry tears out of her eyes. “What does it signify now? Sian is dead and no worldly goods will enter the kingdom of Heaven. You will see.”
I stare down at the mirror under my knees, its glassy black surface filled with stars and the reflections of the shadowy dancers all around us. This has the potential to kill Sosa and me just the same way it killed Madeline. When I look in Sosa’s desperate eyes, hear her muffled screams, I realize that she knows exactly what is coming. She saw Madeline’s death in the botched ritual. She thought she’d survived all the worst things that could happen to her. Now there’s this.
“Let Sosa go,” I plead. “She’s only sixteen.”
“She’s the youngest of us, the most innocent, just arriving this year. Do you not see the signs?” Gwen’s eyes are wide and glassy, her breath heavy. “My little Arthur died this year, the same day I died and one hundred years since I died. The Lord was giving me the pieces of the puzzle. It’s a journey, a pilgrim’s progress, and I am finally ready to undertake it.”
“So you went to Sian to help you with your research,” I say. “You enlisted Madeline, you coerced her—”
“No such thing happened. Madeline wanted nothing more than to rest in her Heavenly Father’s arms,” Gwen says. I think that maybe, if I can just keep her talking, a plan will come to me. That’s always how it works in films, at least. Besides, I want to know the truth. I want to understand how my little sister became this person I am disgusted by. “Sian’s sins against Madeline, blocking her walk into the light, are on the witch’s head.”
“And none of it is on your head?” I say. “For instigating the entire thing, for making Maddy lie, for stealing from NeverEnd and Sian and Haddon Hall—”
“I have atoned, I have atoned, I have endured one hundred years of atonement,” Gwen shouts at me. “I have prayed and served and worshipped and been faithful for my entire one hundred and sixty-four years on this Earth and it is enough. The Lord has made a way. I will follow.”
“You’re messing with magic you don’t understand. You don’t know where the portal will open to.”
“I do, for I have faith that everything placed upon the earth is the fruit of heavenly labours,” she says. “It’s time.”
Beyond the dancing ladies, there is a sense of frenzy. The creamy milkiness of the crescent moon deepens. Its shape fills the mirror, the emptiness of the missing moon becoming a black hole with us sat directly inside. Howls are taken up, screams and cries, all around us. Sosa is sobbing. I try to move but I can’t, I can only push my body fruitlessly against Sosa’s. Do something! Her eyes seem to scream at me. Do something! But what can I do? I’m a dead boy who reads too much but not enough to know any way out of this situation. My whole existence has been an entire waste, exactly like Barnabas said to Aubrey, I’m vulnerable, I’m sheltered – and then it hits me.
“You took Sosa because you think she’s young and innocent,” I shout at Gwen over the din. “You think she’ll be your spiritual guide to the heavenly realms, but Sosa isn’t innocent. She took drugs at a party, she lusts after a boy, she hasn’t gone to church since she was resurrected,” I say, and Sosa is nodding wildly, as if these are all things she has been trying to convince Gwen of for days and days.
“All childish mistakes.”
“But she did them,” I insist. “It won’t work with Sosa, use me instead.”
“I cannot use you,” Gwen scowls.
“Why not? I’m kind and charitable, I’ve never fornicated with a woman and all I’ve done for my entire existence is read books! They’re my only vice.” I choke on my own words but push myself on. “I’ve only loved two people in all of my years and I haven’t really had time to love either of them the way they deserve to be loved. I’ve barely lived or been touched by the world, Gwen, I’m entirely sheltered. I’m the one you want.”
“You’re not the one I want. You lusted for that boy, Michael.” Her eyes take on the same dark fervour that I remember from days past. “You’re sinful in your soul, Emrys. That is why they killed you.”
“What?”
Her face is taut, almost shamed. I recall the other times she has looked at me like this. When I mentioned Michael on the day she arrived at NeverEnd and she turned her face away. All this time, for one hundred years, she has been hiding this from me, carrying a malicious, painful secret.
“You know what I mean,” she sneers. “Those boys that teased you, the cruel ones, always calling you names and such. They asked me that day where you’d gone and I told them.”
“You told them,” I repeat faintly. I wish her words would conjure memories but they don’t. I feel as if my mind is a perfect blank slate, as empty as the mirror. All sound around me dulls to nothing. All I can see is Gwen and her angry, guilty tears.
“I did tell them. I did not know, did I, that they had any bad intentions? I was only a little lass.” She sniffs. “They came to call at the house, asking after you. I said you were fishing with that lad Michael and they said where and I told them and then… You did not come home at night. Ma kept me up all night praying and the next day they found you and the lad, drowned in the river, half washed up on the bank. Ma said it had to be an accident, had to be, but I knew different. At your funeral I heard Michael’s brothers talking together. They said you were a bad influence on Michael, that you’d led him astray and made him a target with your molly ways. That his death was on your head and the Lord would judge you right for it.”
So this then is the truth I’ve been searching for. I rattle my mind for memories but they don’t come. Nothing does. I think of Aubrey, always putting facts together so carefully, dancing somewhere around me, listening to everything. What would he think? I ask myself.
“But you don’t know for sure that’s what happened,” I say desperately. “You don’t have the facts of my death—”