“But we don’t know it did,” I hiccup.
“The boy you loved died when you died; maybe you saw it. That’s enough to cause pain. To make you guarded and fearful. And if…well, Emrys, if someone killed you, it explains it even more.”
The thought should terrify me. It should bring shock to my body, but instead all I think of is seeing the family tree of Vale’s ancestors, their implied violent deaths. I recall how haunted I felt by their untimely ends. Did it feel so real because I remember something like it, deep down? Did something terrible happen to Michael and me, and is that why I’ve always been so afraid?
“Did anyone ever hurt you?” Tommy asks.
“Me? No.” I snort. “I mean, of course other lads could be cruel.”
“Cruel how?”
“Oh, in all the natural ways. I was an oddball, wasn’t I? I didn’t make it easy for myself.” I sniff. “I was a dreadful footballer, I didn’t box, I liked to read, especially novels. I wasn’t bored by my sister and mother; I actually liked their company. I only had one friend, Michael, and I spent all my time with him, had no interest in lasses. So they called me a molly. It was such a dangerous thing to be called back then. Of course it never stopped me. Michael was my dearest friend, the dearest to my heart; they could say anything and I would never abandon him.”
“Did anyone know about the two of you? That you were in love?”
“I don’t think so…I don’t know.” I press my head against my knee. “I wish I could remember.”
“Did you talk to Vale about it?”
“No.” I gulp. “He knows that I don’t recall my death, but he has no idea this has been tormenting me.”
“Why the hell not?” Tommy pokes my arm. “You’ve told him practically everything else. I thought you were finally…why haven’t you been talking to him?”
“Well, I…” I swallow hard and find I can’t look at him. “He said some things. He made me…well, an offer. But I…I couldn’t. He deserves much better than I can provide. Me, with my little dead existence and my books and my silly ways. It seems unfair to burden him with the full story, and to tell him the truth now…”
I shake my head, thinking, To tell him now would be admitting how important he is to me. How much I need him.
“Emrys.” Tommy gives me an incredibly stern look. “You are in love with Aubrey Vale.”
I sniff pathetically. Tears fall and I let them. Yet there’s something loosening inside my chest, a part of me crying out in response to Tommy’s words: Yes, yes, terribly and most ardently. Nothing comes out of my mouth.
“Well, aren’t you?” Tommy demands.
“I think so,” I squeak. “It’s rather like loving a cactus at times, but, yes, I think I must be.”
“Then why, in God’s name, did you not tell him that?”
I ponder it. The wondrous expression on his face, the earth-moving realization of love, the ferocious terror of everything it could mean.
“Because Michael is dead,” I say. “Because I’m a revenant. Because Aubrey isn’t. Loving people is just losing people, whether very soon or much later. I don’t think I can survive outliving another person I love, but I don’t have a choice, do I? I’ll survive everything.”
“So basically what you’re saying is you’re afraid of getting hurt again,” Tommy summarizes.
“Wouldn’t you be?”
“Yeah, I was. It took me decades to realize Maddy was the girl for me. I thought I had so much time left, time to take her dancing and court her properly, but look at me now.” Tommy’s eyes are bleak. “There are no guarantees, except that you’ll get hurt either way. You have to be brave.”
“I’m not sure I’m brave enough to love him,” I whisper to Tommy. “Or to love anyone the way I loved Michael, especially when…I don’t know how I lost him.”
“Will that make you braver?” Tommy asks shrewdly. “Knowing about Michael? Is that what you want?”
I think of Aubrey Vale sitting opposite me in a pub, asking me what I want for the first time in my death. It feels like a lifetime ago. Now, my priorities have all shifted. I want the puzzle of my own death to be solved. I want peace of mind for Michael’s death. I want to know the truth. I absolutely do want to be worthy of Aubrey Vale and brave enough to love him back.
“Yes,” I say.
“Then we’ll find it out,” Tommy says kindly. He wraps an arm around my back. “We’ll go through Maddy’s things, we’ll go back to Glossop, we’ll find whatever she and Gwen must have been communicating through. We’ll dig into the past and we’ll help you remember how you died, if that’s what you need.”
“What about what you need?” I ask, leaning against him. Tommy breathes out slowly.