“Aubrey?” Harper calls from the library, and both of us jump, breaking eye contact. “Are you in here?”
“Coming,” Vale calls back. I don’t want him to leave. Come back, I chant inside my head. Don’t leave me for ever. Come back to me, please.
“Safe travels, Napoleon,” is what I say instead. I offer my hand to shake in farewell. I immediately curse myself for the silly, formal gesture, reminiscent of the first time we met, but this time he doesn’t tease me. He takes my hand. The tingling feeling begins. I wonder if this will be the last time I feel it. Then, formally, he bows his head low, kissing the back of my hand like he is a courtier. My breath catches in my throat and I think we have slipped through time together, in this fairest of goodbyes.
“Goodbye, dear heart.” His whispered words are warm on my skin. It sounds archaic and stilted from his lips and yet, somehow, utterly poetic and perfect. But then he’s gone. My hand begins to itch and I cover my mouth with it. I wonder if it will sting for ever.
With Vale, Harper, Doctor Toppings, and all of the other staff gone for solstice break, the revenants of NeverEnd slip out of our habits. We stop sleeping, we stop eating together. The snow continues to fall, blocking us in for the week. Over Christmas Day and Boxing Day, the power goes out. The water fails and the milk sours and no one cares. We simply switch to older habits – lighting candles, nibbling stale mince pies and hard cheese from the larder, gathering melted snow and boiling it in the fireplace. Barnabas and Esther hold a constant vigil in the chapel. Tommy doesn’t leave Madeline’s room. I move myself into Ancients, hiding in the archive with a supply of beeswax candles and read the days away in the half-light with Anne Green, the ghost, who flits through.
“What happened to your mystery? What did you do with your warning?” she asks.
I notice distantly how my curiosity and urgency burned up at Peveril Castle with my sister. All my chances of finding answers about Michael are gone. Days become meaningless; time becomes looser. I forgot how it could be, when we collectively let it slip through our fingers. When we decide to mark days not by meals or slumber, by replicating the instincts that our bodies once had, but by things with indefinite endings: grief, absolution, regret.
Then, on Friday, the last day of the year, Madeline’s ashes are returned. They arrive in a pine box with her name embossed in gold. The four of us sit in the cold common room with the box between us. The fire in there has been unlit for so many days there is ice on the insides of the windows.
“She could rest here, with us.” My voice is hoarse. I realize I’ve not used it for days.
“We can hold a funeral here on Sunday, but I do not think it will necessarily be the best idea to inter Madeline here.” Barnabas’s voice is heavy. “I do not know how permanent our position will be now. We may all be facing uncertain futures. There will likely be a review. I would hate to have to leave Madeline behind alone.”
Barnabas’s voice breaks and I feel another sliver of my heart peeling away. I think of Aubrey, telling me to fight, to rebuild. I force myself to say something.
“But NeverEnd is our home,” I whisper. They ignore me.
“I’ll hold onto her.” Tommy’s voice is raw. He sounds like he’s been crying for two weeks. “If we have to move on, I’ll take her to York Cathedral. She loved it there.”
Tommy picks up the box and leaves the three of us sitting in the cold. Esther is moving her rosary through her fingers and Barnabas reaches out, gently stroking my hair.
“My father’s house has many rooms,” Barnabas quotes softly. I know he wants to comfort me, to suggest that just like Madeline and Gwen believed, there is a heavenly realm with perhaps its own glorious NeverEnd to which they now belong, and one day, we will all be part of it. But I can’t be comforted by the notion that in several eternities, when the sun finally implodes and this world can no longer even sustain the immortal dead, I might see my sister again and get from her the answers I so desperately seek. I go back to the archives. Anne is there, lingering.
“You are all haunting and haunted,” she says.
I remember Gwen telling me I was the wrong Emrys. I remember Michael handing me a new book the week before my death, telling me I would love it. I feel again the soft brush of Aubrey’s lips against the skin of my burning hand. Love, or the potential of it, haunts me.
TWENTY-EIGHT
On the first Sunday of the new year, the four of us sit in the chapel as Barnabas leads us through a series of prayers for Madeline. We leave her ashes on the altar beside her prayer book, her charred watch and a collection of yuletide foliage that Esther has made. As Barnabas and Esther sit and sing together, Tommy steps outside. I follow him under the yew trees, which are dripping melted snow in the cold air. Tomorrow, Harper and Doctor Toppings and the students will return. But it doesn’t feel like we will. They’ll be resuming something, and we are on a different course, carved away from them by grief.
“Are you sure about not interring Madeline here, at home?” I ask Tommy.
“It’s not our home,” Tommy says forcefully, turning to glare at me with red-rimmed eyes. “How do you still not get this? My home was Boston. Maddy’s home was her convent, and home died for both of us when we died.”
“But we’ve been happy here.” My voice is terribly small. I hate hearing him talk like this. I know he’s angry at me; he’s been angry for days and days, but I don’t know if I’m strong enough to bear the brunt of it now. I don’t know if I’ll ever be strong enough again.
“Happiness isn’t home. Happiness is just a feeling; it changes every day. Home is…home is your roots; home is where your soul flies when you die. When normal people die.” Tommy huffs with a terrible sadness and the driest of humour. “Home is for the living. And the dead. Maddy’s home now and we’re…still here.”
It is at this moment that I realize how differently Tommy and I understand the world, because how can Madeline be home and not be at NeverEnd? Nothing about it makes sense to me. Am I losing him, or is he already gone? Has everything I thought we’d built the last sixty-six years vanished overnight or was it never really there? Tommy looks older than I’ve ever seen him, as if he’s a stranger appeared in the garden, handing me unkind truths. We both look a little weird, actually, Tommy dressed in pyjamas and his old military jacket, me in an old shirt and too-short trousers, my bootlaces undone and a blanket over my shoulders. We look like our house was burned down in the middle of the night and we took what we needed to survive.
“You sound envious,” I say to him. Tommy laughs properly this time, a nasty bark.
“Because I am.” He looks at me like I’m stupid, and I flush.
“You could go back to New England, if you wanted—”
“No, you don’t get it. My home is last century. It’s my parents’ house and the sound of my father singing…” His voice catches painfully and I feel the tears fall down my cheek. I think of how my mother and Gwen used to sing before Gwen’s bedtime, night-time prayers filling our small house. “Home is in the past.”
I know he means it. A part of me knows he’s probably right, as he’s right about so many other things, but I also know that I never loved the first house I lived in as much as I have loved NeverEnd.
“You’re home to me,” I say. “Here with you, it’s the most at home I’ve ever been.”