“Why would you think that it is?”
I realize that it’s because of Anne Green’s warning. Or perhaps because of the words of the White Lady of Haddon Hall, or the lost mirror, everything I’ve spent the last six weeks trying to decipher. And now my own sister is thrown into the mix. I feel something old and unexpected: fraternal worry. The connection that Vale is not saying is me. I’m the thing that connects them all. Maybe Vale has developed his own theory that he wants to keep back from Barnabas. Through the keyhole, I watch Vale cross to the window and rest against the frame. I hear him sigh intensely. Barnabas leans back in his chair.
“I understand from Harper why you think you might have something to prove here—”
“I don’t—”
“But I want to be clear, you will not use my people, my revenants, particularly Emrys, in order to get the justice you feel you deserve. Emrys is not like you. He is sheltered, vulnerable, and under my care. Are we clear?”
“We’re clear.”
“How is your collaboration going?” Barnabas asks, and I flinch from the sudden turn of conversation. I press my forehead against the wood, waiting for Vale to spill the truth to Barnabas and tell him how I broke up our collaboration, but there is a very long pause.
“It’s fine,” Vale eventually replies. There is an even longer pause and I can imagine Barnabas’s searching, sceptical face. I find myself holding my breath, praying Vale is believable, despite my earlier intentions to tell Barnabas the truth. Gwen’s disappearance changes everything.
“Good.” Barnabas’s voice is soft and friendly once again. “Have a pleasant evening, Aubrey.”
I hear Vale slam the door on his way out and Barnabas sigh. I know I should feel flattered or pleased that Barnabas is standing up for me so thoroughly, but his words are like paper cuts, slicing through my intestines. I don’t want to be thought of as sheltered or vulnerable or helpless. It chimes too readily with everything Vale said about me not really having lived. As I listen to Barnabas packing up and leaving, I wonder if everyone sees me this way, even the people I love. Barnabas is one of the people on the planet I expected to love me the most, and yet he’s capable of keeping such a big secret from me because he thinks I’m not mature enough to hear it. Is it possible that Vale is just the first person to tell me the truth?
The sound of the key turning in the lock wakes me out of my miserable musings.
“Oh, no,” I whisper. I’ve been locked in. I wait until I hear Barnabas’s footsteps echo down the corridor before I creak open the cupboard door. It’s dim in the office, with only the orange glow of the outside floodlights over the garden pouring through the window. I immediately trip over Barnabas’s chair, stubbing my toe.
“Bollocks.” I hop around on one leg, still holding a chunk of lebkuchen. Then, terrifyingly, the window swings open from the outside. I swallow a scream and stumble backwards, knocking over a pile of books as a leather-clad arm, shoulder and then a dark head pushes itself into the room.
“Magical eavesdropping is bad manners,” Aubrey Vale says.
“Christ.” I nearly collapse with relief. “How did you—?”
“Opened biscuit box, biscuit crumbs by the cupboard door, and I unlatched the window before I left,” he says, pointing at one after the other. “Come on.”
He really is like a budget Poirot. I’d rather not accept his help, but it turns out that thin, decorative windows do not easily squeeze out a seventeen-year-old body, and Vale has to essentially wrench me through the gap by my elbow. I tumble out and onto the wet grass, like a pile of dead person.
“You okay?” he asks.
“Luckily, falling out of windows isn’t something that kills a revenant,” I say sarcastically, as I roll over with a huff. I find myself face to face with Aubrey Vale, who is kneeling beside me, his hands on my arms, brushing me down in the gesture of a kind person helping a friend who has fallen. Except he is not kind, we are not friends, and we both seem to realize that our bodies have fallen into a rhythm of giving physical consolation and blithely accepting it at the same moment. Our eyes meet. I watch his flicker from brown to green, so strange and uncanny, and I wonder why it’s happening and why it produces an odd tightness in my chest to see it, before I cough and he stands up. He stretches a hand down to help me. It’s bandaged, like mine. Vale notices me looking and clenches his fingers before stretching them again. It seems like there are so many things he could possibly say at this moment, perhaps another apology, but what he says is simply:
“Do you want me to help you find your sister?”
There are many things a person like Aubrey Vale is not good for. Sharing feelings is one of them, trusting to keep a secret might be another, but instinctively, I know my answer to this question in my bones.
“Yes,” I say. I grab his hand and the itching stops, relief spreading through me, turning to tingling that’s almost pleasant. I sigh automatically and to my shock, so does Vale. Then I pull my hand away from his warm, gentle grip and say: “Let’s get on with it.”
It feels utterly weird to be in Vale’s bedroom. Unlike my room or Tommy’s room, it has none of the hallmarks of a real, lived-in space. Over the years I’ve built additional bookshelves in mine, covering every inch of wall space. Sitting in Tommy’s room is like being in the vestibule of a cinema, framed film posters plastered everywhere. Vale has been in NeverEnd a year, but his room looks like he could have moved in last week. The walls are bare, the provided cork notice board is empty. I look around at the clean, clear surfaces; not even grooming items left out on the cabinet in front of the mirror, only a wash bag that’s zipped all the way up. Vale’s leather jacket is slung over the desk chair and his laptop case on the desk.
“What are you looking for?” he asks, pulling out the desk chair for me.
Clues as to whether you’re a normal person, I want to say, but instead I ask: “Where are your books?”
“I live in a library,” he says, like that explains it.
“No, where are the books that you own?” I peer into the blackness under his bed.
“I mostly read on my phone,” he says. “Articles and journalism.”
“You’re telling me you don’t buy novels?”
“I mainly read fiction on holiday, so I usually just buy a bunch of books at the airport.”