How can I tell Barnabas that there is no way in hell I will ever work politely alongside Aubrey Vale again, especially when the fate of my home hangs in the balance?
Vale at least respects my command that he never speak to me again. Throughout November he arranges for all of Sosa’s lessons to be in Ancients, close enough to the librarian’s desk that I can overhear every word. At least this helps the near constant itching, as if our magical vow somehow knows that we’re at least honouring one part of our bargain to share some of Sosa’s lessons. Unfortunately, telling my dastardly collaborator that I am done with him doesn’t work quite as well on the mysteries we have uncovered. I can’t tell my brain to stop fixating on the missing mirror and books. Questions pound through my mind: who would take the mirror from Haddon Hall and why? Who took Vale’s books? And why is Vale so obsessed with those books in the first place? How did Michael and I die?
Sometimes, when I’m listening to him tell Sosa about witchlore, I wonder briefly if I could suck it up and prioritize the collaboration again. Maybe I’d get answers about the mirror and the books and my hand would probably stop hurting. But as soon as I imagine it, I hear his sneering voice putting me down so thoroughly in the chapel at Haddon Hall: If anyone should get more time to actually get a life, it’s you. I wince, the ugly bristle of humiliation and hurt scratching me once again. No, Aubrey Vale has gone too far this time. I flex my hand against a surge of itchiness in my palm. I look up and can’t help noticing that Vale is rubbing his own hand against his chest.
When Sosa comes back to sit beside me, she’s already engrossed in her phone. It’s probably Ali, I imagine, but that’s a hole I really don’t want to dig into.
“Vale said something weird when we went for coffee today,” she comments.
“What?” I am unkindly eager for it, something that I could potentially use against him, anything that could reinforce my hatred.
“He said he used to be a ballet dancer in London at some fancy school, but I don’t think he has the body for it.”
“He’s a shapeshifter, Sosa.”
I glance over at Aubrey Vale where he is packing his books into his satchel. One of the books is about portals. He must be trying to research the Haddon Hall mirror without me. Is it so different if I do a little bit of research on him? After all, he snooped on my entire life. I remember the way Vale took details from what I did or said, small things, and made them into tools to excavate my past. He might be some kind of teenage prodigy, but surely I’ve read enough Agatha Christie to do some imitation sleuthing? I wrack my brain for everything he told me about himself, how he wanted to be a ballerina as a child, the names of his ancestors. Tommy once told me that shapeshifters who work for the Merlin Foundation sometimes change their names when they are “reallocated”. Under the guise of checking the catalogue on the library computer, I hesitantly type Clemence Vale Anne Vale ballet school into the search engine.
There it is, the name Clemence Vale next to a small black-and-white dancer’s portrait. She looks nothing like the Vale I know, with her longer face and dimpled chin, soft cheekbones, light hair drawn drastically back into a bun and eyelashes lengthened with mascara. Could her eyes be the same? As I stare at the photograph critically, I’m shocked to notice my hand is itching less. I frown and stretch my fingers, testing the feeling of it. Why would the itch be calmed by this? There was nothing in our vow about Vale having to share things with me.
But he did promise to be respectful of you, a little voice inside my head reminds me. Could it be that Vale is giving Sosa information he wants passed back to me? Maybe, because he plundered my past, he wants me to understand his? I press on with research and by the end of the day I have tracked Clemence Vale through seven years of prestigious ballet school. I remember what Vale said so lightly on the tennis court about shapeshifter families: At any moment the Merlin Foundation can ask them to do anything it wants and there is no way to say no. I wonder what kind of a childhood I am looking at. Did Aubrey/Clemence want to be a ballet dancer, to be in a ballerina form, for all those years? Or was he asked to do it by the Merlin Foundation? How much choice did he have in his past life? I don’t have any answers, but every time I click on a picture of Clemence, my hand hurts less. I start to wonder if looking into the other mysteries that come attached to Vale will relieve my symptoms too.
I tell myself it’s just about my hand, but I can’t deny how the warning from the White Lady and the strangeness of the missing mirror have been bothering me. So I scour our catalogue for any book that mentions a magical mirror, finding nothing relevant. Until one day, in the archives office, Esther merrily says:
“It’s good to see you researching the stories in The Lives of Revenants so thoroughly, Emrys.”
“What?” I look at her, confused. In truth, I haven’t worked on the summaries for The Lives of Revenants illustrations since Halloween night. It takes me a minute to remember what I promised Barnabas at the start of term.
“The enchanted mirror,” she says, looking at me with a raised eyebrow. “In The Lives of Revenants.”
“But there isn’t a mirror in that manuscript,” I say, wondering how I could have missed something so obvious, something that so clearly links night kin with the mirror.
Esther shows me a page in the manuscript. On one side, there is a revenant placing a bird on an altar in a church, an illustration that made me queasy. I always wondered how the poor bird felt, being sacrificed. The other side is a revenant kneeling over what I thought was a lake. Esther taps her finger against its glossy blue surface.
“The enchanted pool. Look at how the revenant looks into the water to see Heaven, but also their reflection? It’s thought that the water is a metaphor for the Haddon Hall mirror.”
“How do you know that?” I say. It’s not something that’s popped up in any of my research.
“I read about it,” she says, shrugging. “Come with me.”
Then she guides me into the archives, to a cupboard labelled: Private. She opens the door. It’s stuffed to the gills with unmarked books.
“How long has this been here?” I demand.
“This is mine and Barnabas’s collection. Journals, unaccredited works, nearly all anonymous,” she says. “We’ve been meaning to add it to the main catalogue, but it’s a labour of love.”
I thought I knew every nook and cranny of this place. I can’t believe Esther has managed to hide a whole stash of secret books away from me. That familiar tingling excitement to get my hands on new books ripples through me.
“Do you remember which one you read?” I say, eyeing the teetering piles.
“No. The quest for knowledge, eh?” she says cheerfully, and pats me on the back. “I’ll put the kettle on.”
A labour of love is one way of describing the reams of musty and sometimes mouldy books. Another is that is a thankless disaster task with no reward in sight. The initial novelty quickly wears off after I uncover a crusty wasps’ nest and countless dead mice. Then, on the first Friday in December, I pull out something that makes my itching palm calm down entirely. The relief is so immediate, like sticking my hand in freezing cold soothing water, that I drop the book with a gasp. I stare down at it, curiously opening the fly cover. The title is Tempestuous, and like many of the others, it has no author. I wonder if my physical reaction is a fluke. After all, I only swore to help Vale get the missing books back, and this isn’t one of them. I wait until the itch has restarted, deep in the centre of my skin, to tentatively pick up the book. The same thing happens. I sigh shakily as the sweet relief floods through my body. I wonder if it would do the same thing for Aubrey Vale?
“What are you doing?”
I whip around. Madeline is standing there.
“Taking a book out,” I say, turning the book so the title is against my chest. “What are you doing?”