“Oh, I am sorry,” he spoke, and his manner was detached, smooth, a tightness returning to his features after he had shown me, just for a breath, that peaceful, contemplative stare. “I apologize for putting my roguish hands on a fine lady like yourself. Next time I’ll let you hit the stone below.” The aversion in his words echoed around us.
I inhaled and it was uneven, as if my lungs stuttered. “Why must you paint me with the brush of pompousness? I have been nothing but civil to you, excluding our initial meeting.”
“Because I see the way you look at me.”
“How—how do I look at you?” Mortification slid down my spine, an unrelenting, inward chagrin at being so unmasked, so exposed. My humiliating lust would be my undoing. I simply could not face him. I was tempted to turn and run back to the dust road.
“Like I am a beetle your boot didn’t quite stamp out. Like I crawl with no right to it.”
“I do not—”
“Don’t piss on me and tell me it is spring rain,” Cyd drawled, crossing his arms. The tightness in him was gone, replaced with his usual sardonic dislike. “I bet you don’t even know my name.”
“I know your name,” I coughed out, suddenly robbed of my ability to speak and rather offended at his crassness. “I have even referred to you by it. I think I have.”
He eyed me questioningly. “Alright. What is it?” There was something triumphant in his manner that confused me, a certainty that he was right and I was wrong.
He truly thought I did not know his name.
I was so confused at his supposition that I said nothing, only gaped at him, thus accidentally admitting to my guilt.
“I knew it,” Cyd went on, and his speech was still sardonic but there was a sting in it, his utterance like the naming of a wound. “I godsdamn knew you didn’t know it.” His last words seemed to be more directed at himself than at me, like he was angry at himself for thinking otherwise.
Shaking his head, he turned back to the cavern, back to taking in its marvels, pacing a bit, expertly skirting the floor’s formations and mirrored pools of blue reflection. “I see you took the time to learn Griffin’s name. You even, the other day, thanked Kirby, by name, for holding a door open for you. I would normally wager it was because they’re both fine-looking men, but I am fairly certain I’ve heard you say Harvey’s name and, oddly enough, women back in the city actually love him, but not for his looks. And even some of the young lads. I’ve heard you refer to them—Sam, Blackwell, Howard. But never me. It’s like you can’t be bothered.”
Involuntarily, I brought my hand to cover my mouth, my fingertips pressed to it.
As if searching for something to do, he cast a hand upward, the tattooed one, to graze the bottom of a spearhead-like rock formation growing from the ceiling. “As I said, I see the way you look at me. It is not just my criminality. My father, bastard that he was, was right. He warned me not to marry up in the world. He warned me to understand my station. He warned me about landed, wealthy women. He said, ‘Boy, some women just need a swive with a ruffian so they can marry a gentleman and have a fond daydream to pleasure themselves to.’ He told me not to expect any regard from a lady. He was right. He was right about my former wife. He was right about my knowing my footing in life. Yet it always surprises me when I expect something other than disdain from a woman like you. Why would I expect anything more?”
Halfway across the cavern, looking like the illustration of some ruthless god, he turned to stare at me, the mist curling up around his legs, fading off just before it reached his knees. He was anointed by the moss light above like a phantom crown on his head, and his dark-brown garb stood out against the bleached rock around him.
He was beautiful.
Placing both hands over my heart, I cleared my throat. “That is a horrid thing for a father to teach his son. And I am sorry for it, for your having been told that you should go through this life with anything less than courtesy and decency from others. And I am sorry that my irritation with you—which I admit, you do irritate me—has been seen as repulsion or dislike. Even if I dislike you, I should not mistreat you.”
“That’s a pretty speech. But pretty mouths often say meaningless things and fools see it as holding some kind of value. They fail to understand that nothingness can come from a pretty mouth. You still cannot prove that you know my name. You still have yet to say it.”
I was at a loss. There was a secondary layer to what he was relaying to me, but I could not quite make it out. “I do not mean to show you so much contempt,” I whispered.
There was a vulnerability between us. Even when he had tried to regain his usual snideness, he had not quite managed it, and what was meant to be a condemnation of me had felt more like a confession, like he had revealed how he truly believed the world saw him. A temptation overcame me, to step close, to reach up and take his face in my hands and tell him that it was unfair to both of us, that he should not believe I could be so cold and he could be so wretched.
So I did take a step, one cautious foot, one terrified lean forward. Perhaps I was not brave enough to cradle his face in my hands, but I needed him to know—was faltering for a way to express—that I only did not like his demeanor, that I simply disliked him for his dislike of me. For that was the truth, was it not? He unseated me because he had never given me the chance, after our difficult beginning, to build a bridge between us. But perhaps I was equally guilty. Perhaps I was just as cagey and difficult as he was.
And just as I was humbling myself, just as I was about to take a second step towards him, he undid any of my resolve to propose a truce with a laugh. It was dry and cool, and its rancor resounded in the chamber of white stone.
“Still no speaking of my name, little abbess. But that is no matter. For as much enmity as you have for me, know that I carry tenfold of it towards you.”
29
INVITATION
The walk back to the public dust road was without conversation. The ride back to the abbey was also silent. For two whole, excruciating hours next to him, I sat on Pippa and wished for my office, for my bedroom, for a meal and a cup of wine, for solitude to clear my mind. As we rode far enough down the road that the denseness of the tree line had faded, I decided I would indulge in a pipe of lightleaf, to drug myself a bit from this unexplainable heartache. But by the time we rode past town, I was seething. I understood that he had been spit upon in his life. I guessed that the family of his former wife had very likely disapproved of the match and made their marriage difficult. I appreciated that the bars on his hand had likely caused some to be cautious around him. But his stalwart certainty in my snobbery made me boil over with rage.
He had not let me have the span of a breath to defend myself. He had just decided, right then and there in the cavern, that I was a cruel, conceited shrew with my nose in the air. Viciously, I rejoiced that I had not managed to say his name. He should be left to think that I did not know it, that I did not think him worthy.
As he thought the worst of me, I would think the worst of him. And so, despite that perfect heartbeat wherein I had seen him unguarded and fallible, cloaked in the radiance of stone and moss, mist at his feet and angst in his expression, I rejected it. I scrubbed that portrait of him out of remembrance and returned to the ease of displeasure. For I knew it would require effort, would take work on my part, to win him over, to soothe his pride. And did I not have enough to labor after? Was I not beleaguered already by the care of three hundred souls including my own? Did I not have enough to ponder, to study?
It was far simpler to loathe than to learn.