“Godsdamn it,” he yelled, but as he made to pick me up, Griffin rushed towards us, saying, “Tilda, it is complete bedlam in there. You have to go and sort it.”
Cyd gave me a shove. “You heard the man. Get in the chapel.”
When I stepped inside, the tumult was heartbreaking. Everyone was crying. Women stood in line to take their turn down the steps, but for every devotee falling in line, others were screaming for their friends’ whereabouts. One Daughter was inconsolable because she could not find her cat to take down with her. Mothers were yelling at their departments to heed the discipline we had all worked at.
I clapped my hands. “Ladies,” I cried out. I only continued once they had all turned to me. “You are carrying out our plan excellently,” I lied. “Please continue to do so. Single file. Line up at the chair. Prepare to go down. Hurry along.”
“You heard the prioress!” Cordelia ordered, clapping herself.
“Light a candle!” Clara cried. “I can’t see a thing down here.”
“Quickly, girls,” Lynette chided, snapping her fingers at her library staff.
“Portia, move faster,” Maureen Ingrid implored, shepherding our sleepiest member towards the door.
I stood and watched them, eyeing the Mother Treasurer, who shook her head to say that all two hundred and eighty-eight of us were still being counted.
“Tilda,” said a voice near me.
I turned to see Ruby. “Ruby, I think Freddie is in line.”
The big woman shook her head. “No. I want to stay above ground. I want to fight.”
My heart sank. I could not judge her for the thing I myself wanted, so I said in a low pitch, “Present yourself to Captain Griffin. Arm yourself. The pitchforks and knives are still stacked in the dining hall. Anyone else who feels this way, tell the same to them. I will not stand in the way of those who want to defend our home.”
Ruby nodded and then, with a frown, said, “If Freddie looks for me, just tell her I am coming. Tell her I am looking for a fellow farmer or something.”
“You ask me to lie to my oldest friend?”
“Won’t you lie to her about your own plans?” she challenged me, and her eyes were on the dagger Ruarc had given me on my hip.
I looked down to see my right hand resting on it. “You have me there, Ruby.”
As I supervised the scramble of devotees to get under the wellspring door, I avoided looking at Cyd, who was glaring at me from the chapel doors while he helped the Mothers count. I also noticed Serena and Cordelia leaving the chapel in Ruby’s footsteps. Ruby and I were not alone in our conviction to stand tall against the giant army that scaled the wall as we panicked.
“Prioress—I mean, Tilda,” exclaimed Timothy Morrow, pelting down the aisle towards where I stood next to the idol of Sister Sea. When he reached me, he was out of breath.
“Timothy, I am sure Griffin would prefer you go down below too,” I said.
The scholar shook his head. “I cannot. I will stay and defend. I am no warrior, but I’m no weakling either. More importantly—” He paused to point at the line of women standing at the hole in the dais. “I think I have just realized the hymn’s meaning! Or some of it. What Maureen meant when she had Lorraine cast her spell.”
“I hardly think this is the time,” I interrupted him.
Timothy charged ahead, speaking over me. “The hymn’s lyrics say ‘your water-held, beloved bones will be at rest beneath the wellspring door.’ The water from which the fountain springs is directly connected to the channel that runs through the catacombs, correct?” When I did not reply, he carried on. “I’ve just come from the fish fountain. The round part in the middle? Where the water shoots up? I think the wellspring door was used as a cover for that opening! In winter, I mean. It’s the same size! And it’s shaped like a well. Remember when this place was founded, many widows joined and they had children. It would stand to reason that if the fountain was inactive due to the weather, they would want to cover that hole so no little ones fell in.”
He was frustrating me, but I was also rendered useless watching the women go down the steps one by one, and I had decided I would stay by the mermaid idol and smile encouragingly at every devotee as they descended. “So what does that mean?” I asked, nodding at a scribe Sister as she took her first step down into the passageway.
“It means,” Timothy began, “the protection spell crafted by Maureen has something to do with the fish fountain. I am certain of it.”
“Are all devotees accounted for?” Griffin asked as the number of women above ground visibly dwindled. “We should bar the doors soon. The sounds of their hooks hitting the walls grows more frequent. And I can see what look to be the tops of ladders.”
In his ear I whispered, “I think Ruby, Serena, and a few others are arming themselves in the dining hall. They don’t want to go down without a fight.”
“I’m going to wring your neck, Tilda,” Cyd said, coming to stand just behind Griffin. He pointed at Timothy. “And Griffin will wring yours if you don’t get below right now.”
Timothy crossed his arms and looked past Griffin’s sad expression at Cyd, not even close to being cowed. “I’ve a right to stand up to tyranny as much as anyone else here.”
“Godsdamn it,” Griffin rasped and then kissed Timothy on the mouth. “Why did you have to be you?” he bit out as he pulled away. “Why did I have to meet you like this? Why now? I cannot bear to watch you die. Surely, the fates don’t ask that of me.”