“No!” she screamed. “Stop! I know everything! I’ll help you! Just don’t shoot!”
Atwater hesitated, but he didn’t lower his hand. “Help me what?”
“Destroy the evidence. That’s what you want, right? That’s why you kidnapped me. Maybe you saw the tape player get dropped off. That’s it, right? You know I have the tape, and you know I listened to it. That’s why you have to get rid of me. But the tape is still there. Killing us won’t do anything.”
Fergus hauled himself over the transom, and rolled onto the deck. Perry Atwater—she was sure now that it was him—didn’t take the shot.
“Stop where you are,” he ordered Fergus, who raised his hands in a surrender gesture.
How had Fergus shaken off the effects of whatever they’d given him? Maybe being such a large size had its advantages.
“I just want to talk,” Fergus said, dripping on the deck. “I’m here for Marigold, that’s all. Just let me come with you. It’s for your own safety, too. There’s a storm coming and you might need extra hands.”
The man looked out at the sky, where dark clouds were seething like a mass of restless bats, a nearly full moon appearing and disappearing behind them. In the fluctuating light, she caught a hint of silver at his temples. She’d seen him before, she realized with a start. In the Lightkeeper bar when she’d been drinking kir royales with Fergus. And then later, at the door of a room down the corridor.
This was most definitely Perry Atwater III.
“I like it out here,” Atwater said, almost dreamily. “The ocean heals everything. The ocean keeps your secrets. I’ve dreamed about this moment.”
Marigold shared a glance of alarm with Fergus. Where exactly was this man’s head at?
“Listen, Atwater. Even if we all go down with the ship, that tape is still going to be there. People will find it even if we’re gone. But if you take us back, I’ll destroy it. No one else will ever listen to it. No one will know the truth.”
Atwater stared at her, then his gaze drifted back to the choppy dark waves. “The truth?”
“That Ollie lied to you. Lied to everyone.”
Affirm his world view. Say what he wanted to hear. Keep him listening. Then get him talking.
“People think kids that age don’t have deep feelings, but that’s completely untrue. You were head over heels, weren’t you? You were infatuated. You wanted more, and you thought it was mutual. Maybe it was. And then…you found out the truth. And you couldn’t let that stand. Couldn’t let it be real. You thought, the ocean will fix it. The ocean transforms everything. Just like a selkie. All you had to do was send that rowboat out to sea, and the ocean would do the rest.”
She felt Fergus looking from her to Atwater, trying to track what she was saying, what it meant for his case. He was also creeping closer to them, almost imperceptibly. If he could get near enough to tackle Atwater, maybe they could get out of here without anyone getting hurt.
“Ollie loved selkies.” Atwater said it in a whisper. “But selkies are evil. They lie to the world. They claim to be human but they’re not. They’re supposed to stay in the ocean, not come onto land and fool people.”
“Just like Ollie fooled you?”
Atwater let out a harsh, heartbroken sound. “The ocean took care of everything, I just did what was needed. It wasn’t my fault.”
“It wasn’t,” Marigold lied. Of course it was his fault. And she wanted him to pay. But she had to get him to confess, because no matter what she’d just told him, that tape didn’t prove anything.
A gust of wind rocked the boat from side to side. Out of Atwater’s sight, Fergus rose to a crouch. This was her moment. Strike.
“How were you supposed to know that the girl you liked wasn’t a girl at all?”
39
As if responding to Marigold’s shocking statement, a wave picked up the boat and flung it into the valley between swells. A shudder raced through the hull. Fergus rose to his feet, prepared to pounce on the armed man at the controls.
He wanted to go for it now, but as long as that man had a gun, he had the upper hand. So for now, he focused all his attention on Atwater and waited for his moment.
“Ollie was born a boy, but he lived as a girl, didn’t he?” said Marigold. She spoke calmly, even as blood ran down her face from being struck with the gun “That’s why no one has photos of him. My parents were ashamed. That’s why Mom home-schooled him. Her.”
In the wheelhouse, staring through the windshield at the darkness ahead, Atwater shook his head. “You’re wrong. They weren’t ashamed. They loved Ollie, but she was shy and didn’t want to be around people, not until she saw me in the woods. We got to be friends. She wasn’t like anyone I’d ever known. She didn’t care about money or status or anything like that. The only things that were real to her were stories and magic and mythical creatures.”
“So you did love her,” said Marigold softly.
“She was so beautiful and tiny. Unearthly. Like a real-life fairy. We would meet in the woods. Then she would run away home. Like a tease.”