Page 48 of Light It Up

Page List

Font Size:

They reached the end of the sandbar road and began an almost immediate ascent onto a series of switchbacks that wound up a hillside. The eastern side of the island featured cliffs that rose from the surf and sweeping ocean views. The Carmichael family owned all of it, including the private road they were now on, which led to the inn.

“So what else?” she asked. “You have about five minutes before my meeting with the inn manager.”

“I’ll make it quick, then. Like you said, I’ve questioned a lot of folks during the course of this investigation. Everyone has ideas of who might be behind the fires. I keep feeling like I’m caught in the firing line of some old feuds. People want to point fingers at the people they already think the worst about.”

“Yeah, that tracks.” Marigold had experienced that dynamic herself. The Clydes always blamed the Gearys, the McPheeneys despised the Ochoas, and vice versa. Sometimes it amazed her that there weren’t more murders on the island, especially in the winter. “I always apply an automatic feud discount to every story I hear. Do you feel like you’re getting biased information?”

“It’s not that. I’m able to filter out fact from petty revenge. But there’s someone that keeps coming up. It’s…well, it’s your brother.”

“Noah? What does he have to do with any of this? Wait—you don’t think…No fucking way. If you think for one second⁠—”

Fergus tilted his head back and roared with laughter, like a highly amused lion. “Remind me never to go after your twin. Yowza. Relax, I’m not talking about Noah. It’s the other one. Ollie, I think his name was?”

A shock zapped through her. She was just pulling into the inn’s wide parking lot, where an array of golf carts were wrapped in their winter coverings. She jerked to a halt and swung toward Fergus. “What did you just say?”

He eyed her with caution. “Maybe this isn’t a good time.”

“Oh no, you’re not backing out now. Why is anyone talking about Ollie? That makes no sense. What are they saying?”

No one ever talked to her about Ollie. That was one of the weird, distorting things about gossip. If there was talk that you weren’t part of, it created a funhouse mirror kind of experience, where everyone else was busy creating a version of reality you had no idea about. What did people say about Ollie? Suddenly she was desperate to know.

“Well, I was confused at first about why people were even bringing him up. He died a long time ago, am I right? Before you were born?”

She nodded, her heart beating fast.

“People say there was something strange about his disappearance. It seems that no one really knew Ollie, or saw him around. What was strange was that his friends also left around the same time. There was a group that hung out together, all from off-island. The others were older than Ollie, people say they were a bad influence. A week after Ollie died, they were all gone. People found that strange.”

She stared at him. Outlined against the deep gray sky outside the window, his profile looked stern. “Do they say anything about the other kids?”

“Just that one of the boys had big-time family money behind him, and every time he did something bad, his parents would pull out their checkbook.”

That matched what Standish had said. Maybe it was this other kid who had done something bad, not Ollie. If that bad thing was a sexual assault, the family would have paid good money to cover it up. Maybe the half a million dollars had been a bribe for Dennis Murphy to hold his tongue.

Then what about Ollie? Had he gotten a bribe too? Or…

A shiver ran through her. What if Ollie had refused to accept the bribe, and had been pushed into the ocean on a rowboat instead?

She shook herself back to reality. That was pure speculation.

“People really opened up to you,” she told Fergus. “You really are a good interrogator.”

“I got the impression no one wants to talk about it around your family. But have you ever asked?”

“No,” she admitted. “I’m not in the habit of talking about Ollie. I mean, he’s long gone, for one thing. He can’t possibly have anything to do with this arson spree, can he?”

“I don’t see how.” He took off his wool hat and brushed off the melting snow before putting it back on. “But it does come up. It’s almost like people have been waiting to talk about it.”

“Thanks for telling me. I admit I know almost nothing about Ollie. Even finding out he was hanging out with a bad crowd is kind of refreshing.” She hesitated, not sure she should go forward with what she wanted to say next. But why not? Fergus was obviously an expert at loosening tongues and prying information out of people. “I’m actually about to talk to Judy Griffin about that group of friends. The rich kid stayed here. I’m hoping she has records, or maybe she remembers him. She’s worked here about that long, maybe even longer.”

He raised his eyebrows at her. “So you’re already looking into those kids? Because of Ollie?”

To buy herself some time, she pushed open her door and swung out. Should she tell him about Dennis Murphy and how looking into him had led her to the Lightkeeper Inn? That autopsy report from the Netherlands came to mind again, and she decided to hold off. She still didn’t completely trust Fergus.

“Has it occurred to you that the ‘stop’ message could be related to that?” he asked.

Goddamn, the man didn’t miss a thing.

“The thought crossed my mind,” she admitted.


Novels you may like ...