Page 26 of Light It Up

Page List

Font Size:

“Did someone get rid of it?” Marigold flipped her braid back over her shoulder. It kept tickling her chin.

“That would be very much against the rules, but we can’t dismiss the possibility. It’s weird that they left the folder itself, though. Why not disappear the whole thing?” Tina settled the lid back onto the box. She still had the Olson file in one hand. “I need to show the chief.”

“Sure. How long has he been here? Do you think he might remember?”

“No, he wasn’t here then. As far as I know, only one detective is still active from back then. He would have been a rookie at the time. It’s worth a try.”

Marigold put the box back on the rack, and they headed back to the fluorescent lights and constant ringtones of the main bullpen.

They found the old-timer, Massimo Fiori, on the outdoor patio where people went to smoke. He was in his seventies, so he would have been forty or so at the time of Ollie’s disappearance. A wiry man in a surprisingly well-tailored blazer, he gave off the stylish vibe of a dance teacher.

Tina introduced Marigold and explained what they were looking for. “About thirty-three years ago, a boy from Sea Smoke Island was swept out to sea on a rowboat. Do you remember that case?”

Massimo took a drag on his cigarette, which was a fancy kind Marigold didn’t recognize. “There’s been a few like that. Fishermen, reckless kids, the odd tourist here and there.”

“Yes, but this was in the middle of winter,” Marigold said. Then it struck her that she wasn’t sure how she knew that.

Had Aunt Dorothy told her? Everyone told Ollie not to take the rowboat out in a winter storm. Wasn’t that what she’d said? Or had Marigold embellished? Memories were so unreliable, and this was a memory of something told to her, not something she herself had experienced. But in her imagination, snow had been swirling around the little skiff and Ollie had struggled with the oars, fighting to keep his craft from being taken by the powerful ocean currents.

Massimo blew a perfect smoke ring, then jabbed the end of his cigarette through it to break it up. “You ought to check with the Coast Guard. Ocean search and rescue goes through them.”

Good idea, actually. She should have thought of that already.

“We’re on it,” Tina said smoothly. “But you know how those federal guys are. You have to fill out multiple forms just to get a simple answer. We’re just asking around to see if anyone remembers the case. The name was Olson.”

And there it was. Just a flicker of recognition, then a narrowing of eyes as Massimo flipped through the inner files of his memory. “Olson, yeah. I do remember because we wasted too many man hours on something that turned out to be a hoax.”

A hoax? Hearing that word felt like the first dive into the freezing ocean at the start of summer—that shock of disbelief, the delay in understanding, the scramble to catch up. Hoax? What could he possibly mean?

Thank God for Tina. “You determined it was a hoax?”

“Maybe the kid ran away, maybe something else happened, but no one got swept out to sea. We never found anyone. We even analyzed the currents and decided it would have been impossible for anyone to have gone too far astray.”

Marigold finally found her voice. “But what about the skiff? Was it missing? You said he could have run away?”

“Sea Smoke is pretty remote. The only way that could have happened is if someone picked him up. So, maybe. The skiff…we never found it, but it wasn’t registered so we were never even sure there was a skiff. My buddy worked the case, and what I remember is that he didn’t think anyone was telling the full story. They were all lying, but he could never figure out why. Made no sense unless they were covering something up.”

Another shock traveled through her. A coverup would definitely gibe with her experience of hitting brick walls every time Ollie’s name came up.

“Who was your buddy, the one who led the investigation?”

“Oh, he’s long gone. Died a few months after that case.”

“Condolences,” said Tina. “How’d that happen? In the line of duty?”

“Ayup. Robbery in progress, bullet went rogue. Tough break. He was a good man. Petey MacNamara.” He dropped the cigarette onto the concrete patio and stepped on it. “His widow still works in dispatch, last I knew. You could talk to her, but I don’t know if you’d get much.”

Marigold collected herself enough to ask another question. “We found the file empty. Do you have any explanation for that?”

“Got me. Maybe Petey got ticked off spending precious time on a hoax.” He shot them a pointed look, as if he too was spending too much time on said hoax, then headed back inside the squad room.

Marigold and Tina shared a look. “This is weird, right?” Marigold asked.

“Definitely getting some vibes here. Just not sure what they are. To me it sounds like they hit dead ends on the island. Was someone trying to cover something up? Like…”

“Like my parents? Maybe. But what?” She ticked off possibilities on her fingers. “Maybe Ollie ran away. Or got kidnapped. Or even murdered. Whatever happened, wouldn’t they want the help of the police?”

“Unless they were threatened.”


Novels you may like ...