“I’m a visual thinker, so it helps to have everything laid out so I can stare at it obsessively. The red stickers show where the most recent fires have been set. The orange stickers happened earlier, within the past two years. From what the fire crew tells me, before then fires didn’t happen very often, maybe one or two a year. I know that some of those fires have already been explained. But just for the hell of it, I mapped those out too.”
That explained why there were more than seven locations marked. The Bloodshot Eyeball was included, as well as a fire at Luke Carmichael’s house and another at Darren Simms’. Even though those fires had been solved, she could see why Fergus wanted to include them. Maybe they’d sparked someone’s interest in setting fires, so to speak. Maybe a neighbor had been inspired to continue the trend.
Fergus went on. “While I was staring at this map the other night, something occurred to me. I wanted to run it by you.” He stepped to the map and traced a line from one sticker to another. “Is it my imagination or do these locations spell something, sort of generally speaking?”
She squinted at the map and saw nothing.
“Two letters,” he prompted. “Two letters that say a whole lot. I didn’t mark it because I want to see if anyone else picks up on it or if I’m hallucinating.”
She saw it then, a trail traced from one side of the island, with two spurs heading east. Then a misshapen curve starting on the north end, heading south, and back up. “An F and a U. FU.”
“Ha! So it’s not just me. It’s a real pattern.”
“Or just a coincidence. What about the timing of them?”
“The timing doesn’t line up,” he admitted with a shake of his head. He tapped the various stickers as he spoke. “Chronologically, it goes like this. Boom, boom, boom. All over the map. But does that matter? Maybe he’s going around filling in the gaps.”
She screwed up her face and cocked her head this way and that. “Seems like a stretch, I gotta say. And where does it lead, really? Are we narrowing down the suspects to people who swear?”
“No, but we could be looking for someone with a grudge against the island as a whole rather than specific targets. He’s not choosing the houses for any other reason than they happen to be on this route.” He traced it again with his forefinger.
She could tell that he relished the investigative process; his eyes were alight with speculation.
“So what do you think? Do you know anyone who might fit that description?”
“Mad at the whole island? I’ll have to think about it.” Lots of people had general grudges against the injustice of the world, which manifested itself on Sea Smoke Island in very particular ways. The divide between the wealthy eastern end of the island and the hardscrabble west end, the long winters that were even more difficult for those who couldn’t afford a vacation to Florida, the impossible home prices, the sense of being background players for summer tourists, the threat of overfishing, the resentment against attempts to address it, the feeling of clinging to a way of life jeopardized on all sides. Young people leaving. Strangers arriving with different expectations, new demands.
“Fair enough,” said Fergus. His nose was right up against the map, but Marigold found her attention returning to the table with all the notebooks and so forth. His handwriting wasn’t easy to read, so she skipped over everything written by hand and focused on a printed report within easy eyeshot.
It was an autopsy report. Scratch that; it was a translation of an autopsy report from the Netherlands. In the scant few moments she gave herself to scan it, she saw that the victim had been a fifteen-year-old girl, five foot four, a hundred and ten pounds, and that her beaten body had been found washed up on the banks of a canal. Cause of death: drowning. The date on the report was from five years ago.
At the wall, Fergus took a step back, and she snapped her attention away from the table. Why was Fergus carting around autopsy reports from five-year-old murders in the Netherlands? It couldn’t possibly have anything to do with the arson case he was supposed to be solving.
Even if he was investigating other crimes, why would he be working on a case from the Netherlands? Shouldn’t that be the Dutch police? Was he consulting? Or did he have some personal connection with it?
She could just ask. But as she eyed Fergus MacFadyen, she once again got the strong sense that he was hiding something important. Better to keep her cards close to the vest.
Suddenly, the room’s pretty sage-green walls seemed to close in on her, and the low hum of the bedside lamp became an annoying drone, and something thumped against the window—a bat, most likely—and she really had to get out of there.
“I just realized my brother is waiting for me,” she stammered.
He’d better be, as soon as she texted him.
“Oh sure, no worries,” said Fergus, shaking off his absorption with the map. “I’ll walk you back to your truck.”
“No need, I’ve got it covered. This is real interesting.” She pointed at the map, which was nothing but a blur of red and orange and black squiggly lines now. “Let me know how it pans out.”
He didn’t move from his position at the map as he watched her with careful alertness. “Everything okay?”
“Yes, it’s all good. I just forgot it’s, uh, darts night. It’s a tournament, and if we miss our turn we’re toast. Noah’s already on his way. Wish us luck!” She edged toward the door, relief seizing her as her hand settled around the old bronze knob.
Out in the corridor, with its discreet sconces and gold-patterned wallpaper, she forced a deep breath of air into her lungs.
What the hell had just happened? She should have just asked Fergus about that report. He hadn’t tried to hide it, after all. He’d invited her to his room and hadn’t bothered to put away those papers.
At the other end of the hall, a sound made her jump. The guest she’d noticed at the bar, with the dark coat, was using his keycard to open the door of his room. As her heart pounded, he slipped inside his room.
Totally innocent behavior.