The new deck was one of Marigold’s favorite places. It was cantilevered over the shoreline so that at high tide, it felt like you were hovering over the water. During a winter storm, she loved to sit in this glass bubble with a hot toddy and watch the wild tossing waves.
“Rough night?” Gabby asked sympathetically as she pushed a mug of steaming coffee toward her. It looked to be the exact shade of creamy tan that Marigold preferred. “The memorial was lovely, but it must have taken a lot of work.”
“I’m glad it went well, but yeah.” Marigold inhaled a lungful of coffee-tinted steam. “Also glad it’s behind us.”
After some more chitchat, Gabby sat back in her chair and flipped her braids over her shoulders. They were interwoven with electric-blue extensions that really set off her glowing brown skin. “So I’m dying to know what story you’ve got for me. I was starting to think we already solved all the cold cases around here.”
“See, that’s the thing. It’s not a cold case, really. It’s my brother.”
“The cute firefighter?”
“Uh…gag. No. I had another brother who died before I was born. He was twelve and the story I was told was that he took a skiff out in a storm and got swept out to sea.”
Gabby’s expression shifted to sympathetic. “How tragic. So you never knew him?”
“Nope. Noah and I were born a year and a half after he died, and we were quite a surprise. Sometimes I think my mother still can’t believe it. Anyway, Aunt Dorothy was saying some odd things about Ollie—that was his name. It almost sounded like she didn’t believe he died that way. I realize she had dementia, but there’s another thing.” She told Gabby about the safe deposit box, which she still hadn’t mentioned to her mother, and the fear that Dorothy had expressed. “I’m starting to wonder if there’s more to the story. But I have to be careful that my mother doesn’t hear about it. She has a breakdown any time Ollie is mentioned. And I mean that more or less literally.”
Gabby nodded. She’d pulled out a notebook and a pen, and was writing down the details. “Is there anything else you can tell me, like where to start or who to talk to?”
“Good question. I’m going to poke around the Harbortown PD files from that era. I was thinking that you could check with your newspaper sources and see if anyone remembers the incident. Maybe there were questions at the time. You have contacts in the Carmichael family, too. You have sources all over this island at this point. I’d start with the older folks who might remember something.”
Gabby was scribbling madly. When she looked up, her eyes were alive with the enthusiasm of a brand-new project. “Got it. This does sound interesting, Marigold, but I have to ask you, since you mentioned your mother. What if I find out something uncomfortable or upsetting to her?”
Marigold had been thinking about that too. Would it be better to let things lie? “As far as I know, she doesn’t listen to your podcast, so there’s that. The other thing is, we’re so used to walking on eggshells around her and shielding her from the hard stuff, I’m sure we can keep that up no matter what we found out. She barely leaves the house anyway. She doesn’t keep up with island gossip.”
“What does she do all day?” Gabby asked curiously. Marigold knew that her own mother was a member of the state legislature, a very busy and driven woman. Essentially the opposite of Rhoda Olson.
“She does a lot of puzzles. Sudoku, word games, crosswords. Sometimes she goes through a craft phase and starts churning out sea glass wind chimes or wild rose bath bombs. I told her she should start an Etsy shop, so she could sell things without ever leaving the house. She says she doesn’t want the pressure.”
“Has she ever seen a counselor?” Gabby asked the question so directly it gave Marigold a little shock.
“Well, we come from Norwegian farming stock, so that would be a no. My father’s stated policy is that people should only speak if they have something important to say.”
“What’s more important than working through your grief?”
Gabby was right. Of course she was. But that was the thing about growing up in a family, any family; all the quirks seemed completely normal at the time.
“I’m not sure that kind of grief can be worked through,” she said softly. “I think Mom was so devastated that she couldn’t handle any reminders of Ollie. My parents don’t even have photos of Ollie in the house. I only recently realized that was strange.”
Gabby’s eyebrows lifted. “I’d say so. I’ve interviewed many people who have lost loved ones, and I’ve never heard that. No, I take that back. I talked to the sister of a serial killer once, and she’d destroyed all the childhood photos she had that included him.”
“I’m pretty sure Ollie wasn’t a serial killer.”
But still, her stomach twisted at the idea that her parents were treating their dead son like a criminal.
“Yes, I think we can cross that off the list.” Gabby flipped to a new page in her notebook. “Is there anything else that comes to mind about Ollie? What he liked to do, who his friends were, how he did in school, that kind of thing?”
Marigold thought about that for a moment, and drew a blank. “He must have liked being on the water. He fished with my dad back when we had a boat. Obviously he had access to a rowboat.” She shrugged helplessly. “I know so little. A few books on our shelves have the name Ollie written on the inside cover. There’s one that’s practically falling apart called Legends of the Sea.”
“What’s it about?”
“Mermaids, selkies, just myths relating to the ocean. I can’t imagine that’s very helpful.”
“You never know.” Gabby made a note. “Any friends?”
“No idea. Apparently he was shy. School…” She thought about Grady with a quick flash of pleasure. “I can look into that myself. There must be some school records, and maybe they’ll give me access since I’m the fill-in constable.”
“It’s a plan.” Gabby tucked away her notebook. “By the way, I talked to Heather and they’re still having fun in Fiji. Not divorced yet.”