They both laughed, and once again she felt that tug of attraction. To hide it, she guzzled a mouthful of Sprite.
Gabby snorted and offered Fergus her hand. “I’m Gabby. You must be either the new arson investigator or the new teacher. I’m pretty sure I know almost everyone else around here.”
“Fergus MacFadyen.” He shook her hand heartily. “Investigator. You do the podcast, don’t you? Dirty Rotten Bastards? Nice work.”
“Back at you. Already putting those investigative skills to work, I see.”
“I like to know everything I can about any community I step into. Your podcast taught me a lot.”
“Wow, thank you.” Gabby was practically batting her eyelashes. She was madly in love with Barnaby, but even she was responding to Fergus’ good-natured charm.
Danger, danger, clanged Marigold’s inner alarm system. Not just because he was so attractive. Was it weird that he’d done so much advance research for a one or two-week job? Again, she got that sense that Fergus was more than he seemed.
Fergus cocked his head at her. “You’re giving me the stink-eye, Constable. Something wrong?”
Was she? She hadn’t realized that she was staring at him so suspiciously. “Nope. Just wondering how your actual investigation is going. The fires, remember those?”
“I do. I can give you a full report, but a memorial didn’t seem like the right occasion. Apologies if I got that wrong.”
“Apologies? What’d you do, man?” Noah joined them, giving Fergus a friendly punch on the arm. For a near-hysterical moment, Marigold imagined what the three of them must look like—like three members of Odin’s court going at it.
“He didn’t do anything,” she said, rolling her eyes. “No need for anyone to apologize to anyone.”
Gabby raised her hand, glancing up at the three of them. “I feel like I should apologize for not being eight feet tall like the rest of you.”
They all laughed.
“Definitely not,” said Noah. “I should apologize for barging in and giving you a crick in your neck.”
As Noah and Gabby launched into a laughing exchange about how she was used to it because of Barnaby, Marigold turned to Fergus.
“Since we’re apologizing, I’m sorry if my face inadvertently gave you the stink-eye. Didn’t mean to.”
“And I apologize for not keeping you fully informed and hope to fix that over drinks at the Lightkeeper Inn. They don’t have to be alcoholic drinks, but Jasmine is a stellar bartender. She makes the best whiskey sour I ever had.”
With the sense of being outmaneuvered, Marigold let out a sigh. She had no legitimate reason to say no. She didn’t even want to say no. But the thing was, Fergus made her nervous. She couldn’t quite get a handle on him.
Which might be the best reason of all to have drinks with him. If he was hiding something, she could try to figure it out over one of Jasmine’s expertly mixed cocktails. Anyway, how could she resist someone who appreciated Jasmine’s skill?
“Fine,” she agreed. “Tomorrow, eight-ish.”
He grinned, accepting her capitulation, and moved on to his next conversation.
She gave it a moment until he was fully engaged in a chat with the new head of the historical society, then turned to Gabby, who’d just ended her banter with Noah. “Feel like playing chaperone tomorrow night?”
“Hell no, girl. That man is a snack, and he likes you. You go and have yourself some fun.”
“That’s not…it’s not like…shut up,” she ended lamely, while Gabby patted her on the shoulder. “He wants to talk about the investigation.”
“I don’t think that’s all he wants. Is it so strange if he’s into you?”
Flustered, Marigold finished the rest of her Sprite. “The last time someone was into me, he had a whole evil secret agenda. I’m trying to be a little more careful now.”
“I get it. But what are the chances that an officially hired arson investigator has an evil secret agenda?”
It did sound silly, now that Gabby put it that way. But it also sounded a bit like “famous last words.” There was something about Fergus, something not fully straightforward, but she couldn’t say what.
Her feet throbbed in her chunky black heels, and she decided she’d had enough of this gathering. She slipped into the entryway to grab her coat. As she dug through the multitude of wool coats, down parkas, and canvas jackets hanging on the pegs in the entry, she bumped elbows with Grady.