1
On a midwinter night on Sea Smoke Island, two odd things happened, although since it was Sea Smoke, “odd” was a moving target. The fire department responded to the first call, since it was a fire at a pottery studio. The second call went to Marigold Olson, not only because it was a case of indecent exposure, but because the exposer was her aunt Dorothy.
At the time, Marigold was in Harbortown on a date so bad that the call from the dispatcher felt like a rescue.
“Sorry, hon, but you oughta get back here, your aunt’s causing a ruckus.”
“Oh God, what now?”
“They’re saying she’s walking down the road taking her clothes off one by one.”
“In this weather?”
“Ayuh. At least she’s got plenty of layers to go through. It’s twenty degrees out tonight. Poor thing might have frostbite.”
It wasn’t the first time Aunt Dorothy had wandered off, but usually it wasn’t below freezing. And she wasn’t naked.
“It’ll be a few until I can get back. I’ll get someone on it.”
“I’m real sorry to interrupt your date. Especially after, you know…”
Marigold sighed. How had Betty known about her date? Funny how Sea Smoke Island was like an underwater vault when it came to some secrets, while others were impossible to keep.
Her phone beeped with another call, saving her from having to discuss her catastrophic love life with Betty the dispatcher. This one was from her twin brother Noah, who’d just returned from Alaska and was working as a volunteer firefighter. “We just passed Aunt Dorothy on our way to a fire.”
“Another fire? Jesus. What is that, the seventh this winter?”
“Good thing we decided to hire an outside investigator, huh?”
Before she could defend herself and her so far futile investigative work, she heard the whine of the brakes as the engine screeched to a stop. “How about you stop rubbing it in and pick up Aunt Dorothy before she freezes into a naked statue?”
“She always did claim to be a selkie. Maybe she’s trying to find her pelt.”
“Just pick her up,” she said through gritted teeth.
“Relax. Already did. I’m mostly calling because my twin radar is telling me your date sucks. Consider this a rescue.” Noah clicked off the call.
Her twin wasn’t wrong. She should never have swiped right on this guy. Honestly, she needed to delete the damn app from her phone until she was actually ready for a relationship.
She sighed and smiled ruefully at the guy across the table from her. His name was something like Bret or Burt or Bart, but she refused to expend brain cells on remembering it because he’d spent the entire evening detailing his workout routine. He probably thought she was equally obsessed with sets and reps because she had the build of a Nordic pole vaulter. She didn’t have the heart to tell him it was entirely genetic and her favorite form of exercise was…well, she was still trying to find one she liked. Other than swimming, of course, but that didn’t count because here in Maine, it mostly involved jumping in, shrieking loudly, and clambering out while your limbs still worked.
If Luke Carmichael hadn’t been off on his extended honeymoon, she would have handed Aunt Dorothy’s case to him. He was the constable, after all. She was either the assistant constable or the constable’s assistant, depending on her mood. But while he was gone, she was the one in charge of everything, so she had no choice.
Quite possibly, it was a conflict of interest for her to decide how to handle her aunt’s situation. But on a remote coastal island like Sea Smoke, law and order was kind of a community project and no one blinked at the idea of Marigold dealing with her relative in her own way. Aunt Dorothy had always been a little “off,” or “eccentric,” or “different”—at least she had been ever since the tragedy that had defined the Olson family since before Marigold was born.
“She hasn’t been the same since, you know…” her mother would say. And Marigold would want to scream, “Tell me everything!” but wouldn’t because the Olson family didn’t talk about such things.
By the time she got back to Sea Smoke, her aunt had already been tucked into bed, so Marigold waited until the next morning to check on her.
It was one of those ruthlessly cold, bright winter days that she found to be exhilarating. She hummed to herself as she steered her black Toyota Tundra in the direction of Stony Hill Road. If you could survive these temperatures, you could survive anything—it was empowering.
On the way, she passed the smoking shell of Ann Burgess’ pottery studio. Ann and Dorothy had been friends ever since the Burgesses had moved to the island fifteen years ago.
Wrapped in a tartan wool coat, Ann was using a piece of driftwood to poke at the smoldering remains of her cedar-shingled studio. Marigold slowed to a stop on the gravel road. Sea Smoke Island didn’t have a single paved road, but some were better graded than others. Winter was hard on the island infrastructure. This road got more attention because of residents like Ann, who had plenty of money to contribute to local fundraisers.
“How’s the cleanup going?” she called to Ann.
“Got a suspect yet?”